Dissemination In Space Criteria Research Articles

Impact of the McDonald Criteria 2017 on Early Diagnosis of Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis.

Multiple sclerosis is a chronic immune mediated demyelinating disease leading to neurological disabilities that need to be diagnosed and treated early. Guidelines on multiple sclerosis diagnosis and monitoring experienced comprehensive changes over the last decades. The first McDonald criteria published in 2001 emphasized the importance of MR imaging but also recognized the role of cerebrospinal fluid diagnostics. The demonstration of an intrathecal immunoglobulin G synthesis is a well-established additional component and has a long tradition in the diagnosis of relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. However, the role of cerebrospinal fluid for diagnostic purposes was rather diminished in each revision of the McDonald criteria. In the latest revision of the McDonald criteria of 2017, the detection of an intrathecal immunoglobulin G synthesis as oligoclonal bands experienced a revival. Patients with the first clinical event suggesting multiple sclerosis who fulfill the criteria for dissemination in space can be diagnosed with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis when oligoclonal bands in cerebrospinal fluid are detected. The diagnostic sensitivity of these novel criteria with a focus on dissemination in time and oligoclonal bands as a substitute for dissemination in time was published in different cohorts in the last year and is of special interest in this review. Recently published data show that by applying the 2017 McDonald criteria, multiple sclerosis can be diagnosed more frequently at the time of first clinical event as compared to the 2010 McDonald criteria. The main effect was due to the implementation of oligoclonal bands as a substitute for dissemination in time. However, careful differential diagnosis is essential in patients with atypical clinical manifestations to avoid misdiagnoses.

Oligoclonal bands increase the specificity of MRI criteria to predict multiple sclerosis in children with radiologically isolated syndrome.

BackgroundSteps towards the development of diagnostic criteria are needed for children with the radiologically isolated syndrome to identify children at risk of clinical demyelination.ObjectivesTo evaluate the 2005 and 2016 MAGNIMS magnetic resonance imaging criteria for dissemination in space for multiple sclerosis, both alone and with oligoclonal bands in cerebrospinal fluid added, as predictors of a first clinical event consistent with central nervous system demyelination in children with radiologically isolated syndrome.MethodsWe analysed an international historical cohort of 61 children with radiologically isolated syndrome (≤18 years), defined using the 2010 magnetic resonance imaging dissemination in space criteria (Ped-RIS) who were followed longitudinally (mean 4.2 ± 4.7 years). All index scans also met the 2017 magnetic resonance imaging dissemination in space criteria.ResultsDiagnostic indices (95% confidence intervals) for the 2005 dissemination in space criteria, with and without oligoclonal bands, were: sensitivity 66.7% (38.4–88.2%) versus 72.7% (49.8–89.3%); specificity 83.3% (58.6–96.4%) versus 53.9% (37.2–69.9%). For the 2016 MAGNIMS dissemination in space criteria diagnostic indices were: sensitivity 76.5% (50.1–93.2%) versus 100% (84.6–100%); specificity 72.7% (49.8–89.3%) versus 25.6% (13.0–42.1%).ConclusionsOligoclonal bands increased the specificity of magnetic resonance imaging criteria in children with Ped-RIS. Clinicians should consider testing cerebrospinal fluid to improve diagnostic certainty. There is rationale to include cerebrospinal fluid analysis for biomarkers including oligoclonal bands in planned prospective studies to develop optimal diagnostic criteria for radiologically isolated syndrome in children.

Optic nerve double inversion recovery hypersignal in patients with clinically isolated syndrome is associated with asymptomatic gadolinium-enhanced lesion

Background: Optic nerve involvement is not considered in dissemination in space (DIS) or time (DIT) of multiple sclerosis (MS) lesions. Objectives: To evaluate frequency of optic nerve involvement using three-dimensional (3D)-double inversion recovery (DIR) sequence in clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) and to measure its relationship with DIS and DIT (2010 and 2017 McDonald criteria). Methods: From November 2013 to August 2016, 57 CIS patients underwent 3T-magnetic resonance imaging (3T-MRI) including 3D-DIR sequence and optical coherence tomography (OCT) at 3 months after CIS. We assessed signal abnormalities of the optic nerves on DIR sequence and collected data for DIS and DIT criteria according to 2010 and 2017 McDonald criteria. Results: Among the 57 recruited patients, the presence of ⩾1 DIR hypersignal in optic nerve was observed in 36 (63%; 48 optic nerves) including asymptomatic hypersignal in 22 (38.5%; 25 optic nerves). Optic nerve involvement was significantly associated with DIT (p = 0.006) and MS according to 2010 criteria (p = 0.01) but was not significantly associated with presence of DIS criteria according to 2010 and 2017 McDonald criteria. We identified a significant (p < 0.001) temporal peripapillary retinal nerve fiber layer thinning on eyes with optic nerve involvement versus healthy controls. Conclusions: Optic nerve involvement is very frequent at the earliest clinical stage of MS. It is associated with the presence of asymptomatic gadolinium-enhancement and retinal axonal loss and may reflect the inflammatory disease activity level.

Inclusion of optic nerve involvement in dissemination in space criteria for multiple sclerosis.

To investigate the effect of including optic nerve involvement in dissemination in space (DIS) criteria for diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS) in patients with clinically isolated syndrome (CIS). We studied 160 patients with CIS: 129 with optic neuritis (ON) and 31 with non-ON CIS. MRI brain/spinal cord was done at the time of presentation and a follow-up MRI brain after 3-12 months. We evaluated optic nerve involvement clinically or with visual evoked potentials (VEPs, n = 42). We investigated the performance of the McDonald 2017 DIS criteria and modified DIS criteria including optic nerve involvement for development of clinically definite MS after ∼15 years. In the ON group, including symptomatic optic nerve involvement identified an additional 15 patients with DIS. The modified DIS criteria that included optic nerve involvement were more sensitive (95% vs 83%) and more accurate (81% vs 78%) than the McDonald 2017 DIS criteria, but less specific (57% vs 68%). In combination with dissemination in time criteria, the modified DIS criteria remained more sensitive (83% vs 74%) and accurate (81% vs 75%), and the specificity was the same (77%). Including asymptomatic optic nerve involvement in DIS the non-ON group did not identify any additional patients and the performance of the McDonald 2017 criteria and the modified criteria was the same. The inclusion of symptomatic optic nerve involvement in DIS in patients with ON improved the overall performance of MS diagnostic criteria. Including asymptomatic optic nerve involvement in DIS in patients with a non-ON CIS may be of limited value. This study provides Class III evidence that for patients with suspected MS, inclusion of symptomatic optic nerve involvement in DIS criteria improves the overall performance of diagnostic criteria for MS.

Three-Tesla MRI does not improve the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis

ObjectiveIn the work-up of patients presenting with a clinically isolated syndrome (CIS), 3T MRI might offer a higher lesion detection than 1.5T, but it remains unclear whether this affects the fulfilment of the diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis (MS).MethodsWe recruited 66 patients with CIS within 6 months from symptom onset and 26 healthy controls in 6 MS centers. All participants underwent 1.5T and 3T brain and spinal cord MRI at baseline according to local optimized protocols and the MAGNIMS guidelines. Patients who had not converted to MS during follow-up received repeat brain MRI at 3–6 months and 12–15 months. The number of lesions per anatomical region was scored by 3 raters in consensus. Criteria for dissemination in space (DIS) and dissemination in time (DIT) were determined according to the 2017 revisions of the McDonald criteria.ResultsThree-Tesla MRI detected 15% more T2 brain lesions compared to 1.5T (p < 0.001), which was driven by an increase in baseline detection of periventricular (12%, p = 0.015), (juxta)cortical (21%, p = 0.005), and deep white matter lesions (21%, p < 0.001). The detection rate of spinal cord lesions and gadolinium-enhancing lesions did not differ between field strengths. Three-Tesla MRI did not lead to a higher number of patients fulfilling the criteria for DIS or DIT, or subsequent diagnosis of MS, at any of the 3 time points.ConclusionScanning at 3T does not influence the diagnosis of MS according to McDonald diagnostic criteria.

P.028 Each revision of the McDonald diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis allow earlier diagnosis in more patients

Background: The 2005, 2010, and 2017 McDonald diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis (MS) were compared at baseline in participants of a Canadian multicentre clinical trial of minocycline in clinically isolated syndrome (CIS). Methods: The cohort included 142 participants. Baseline clinical and imaging data were used to determine if participants met criteria for dissemination in space (DIS) and time (DIT) as required for each version of the criteria. We also explored the impact of permitting a clinical diagnosis of transverse myelitis to represent a spinal cord lesion, and for multifocal clinical onset to represent DIS. Results: The clinical trial excluded patients meeting the 2005 McDonald criteria at baseline. The 2010 criteria were met by 28.9% (41/142) of participants. If a multifocal clinical presentation was considered evidence of DIS 29.6% (42/142) met the 2010 criteria. The 2017 criteria were met by 36.7% (52/142). Allowing a clinical diagnosis of transverse myelitis to confirm a spinal lesion, or multifocal onset to confirm evidence of DIS, led to a diagnosis in 38% (54/142) and 38.7% (55/142), respectively. Conclusions: This study confirms that each revision of the McDonald diagnostic criteria allowed an MS diagnosis in more CIS patients at onset. Exploration of other modifications suggests further improvement may be possible.

Forkhead box C1 gene variant causing glaucoma and small vessel angiopathy can mimic multiple sclerosis

A 34–year old Caucasian female was initially diagnosed with multiple small-vessel strokes at age 20 years which were etiologically classified as secondary to anti-phospholipid antibody syndrome (APS) although she had no history or laboratory data to suggest APS. Based on her MRI of brain findings, one of her neurologists was concerned she could have multiple sclerosis (MS) and hence the patient was referred to our clinic for further evaluation. The patient's MRI of brain showed confluent lesions in the periventricular and juxta-cortical lesions that fulfil 2017 McDonald criteria for dissemination in space. She had no symptoms other than occasional, mild headaches and had no findings to suggest clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) or MS; additionally, her cerebrospinal fluid analysis was unremarkable. Past history showed that she had undergone surgery for glaucoma, and subsequently developed bilateral sensorineural hearing loss in the third decade that was diagnosed as Meniere's disease. Her family history revealed that her son had dysmorphic facies and was small for age. He had a bifid uvula, bilaterally duplicated thumbs and scoliosis. Additionally, he had hypertelorism, a wide forehead and flattening of mid-face. Due to his complex medical presentation, whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed that revealed a maternally inherited heterozygous pathogenic frameshift in the FOXC1 gene. Genotyping of the mother showed the FOXC1 gene variant and adds to the growing list of differential diagnoses that may mimic MS in the context of radiological changes involving cerebral small vessels. This is the first report of a FOXC1 gene variant presenting with radiological features that can erroneously be interpreted as being consistent with MS.

Oligoclonal Bands in Spinal Fluid Improve the Specificity of Different MRI Criteria for Dissemination in Space to Predict a First Clinical Event in Children with the Radiologically Isolated Syndrome (S51.002)

Oligoclonal Bands in Spinal Fluid Improve the Specificity of Different MRI Criteria for Dissemination in Space to Predict a First Clinical Event in Children with the Radiologically Isolated Syndrome (S51.002)

Radiologically isolated syndrome in children: Clinical and radiologic outcomes.

Objective:To describe clinical and radiologic outcomes of children with incidental findings on neuroimaging suggestive of CNS demyelination (termed “radiologically isolated syndrome” or RIS).Methods:Clinical and radiologic data were obtained from a historical cohort of children with no symptoms of demyelinating disease who had MRI scans that met the 2010 MRI criteria for dissemination in space for MS.Results:We identified 38 children (27 girls and 11 boys) with RIS now being prospectively followed at 16 sites in 6 countries. The mean follow-up time was 4.8 ± 5.3 years. The most common reason for initial neuroimaging was headache (20/38, 53%). A first clinical event consistent with CNS demyelination occurred in 16/38 children (42%; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 27%–60%) in a median of 2.0 years (interquartile range [IQR] 1.0–4.3 years). Radiologic evolution developed in 23/38 children (61%; 95% CI: 44%–76%) in a median of 1.1 years (IQR 0.5–1.9 years). The presence of ≥2 unique oligoclonal bands in CSF (hazard ratio [HR] 10.9, 95% CI: 1.4–86.2, p = 0.02) and spinal cord lesions on MRI (HR 7.8, 95% CI: 1.4–43.6, p = 0.02) were associated with an increased risk of a first clinical event after adjustment for age and sex.Conclusions:We describe the clinical characteristics and outcomes of children with incidental MRI findings highly suggestive of CNS demyelination. Children with RIS had a substantial risk of subsequent clinical symptoms and/or radiologic evolution. The presence of oligoclonal bands in CSF and spinal cord lesions on MRI were associated with an increased risk of a first clinical event.

Author response: The contemporary spectrum of multiple sclerosis misdiagnosis: A multicenter study.

We appreciate the comments of Dalla Costa et al. on our Contemporary Issues article.1 As discussed, this study was not designed to assess the frequency of multiple sclerosis (MS) misdiagnosis or its specific causes.1 We catalogued the diagnoses ultimately assigned to patients mistaken as having MS and reported the evaluation of the MS specialists who determined that a misdiagnosis had occurred according to their analysis of what led to misdiagnosis. Accepting this limitation, application of MS diagnostic criteria to a neurologic syndrome not typical for MS contributed to misdiagnosis in 65% of cases.1 MS diagnostic criteria fail in this situation, but are often applied in clinical practice. In 60% of cases, declaring MRI criteria for dissemination in space satisfied in a patient with nonspecific symptoms contributed to misdiagnosis.1 Ultimately, these 2 errors perpetuate one another. Nonspecific symptoms acquire additional and unwarranted attention when nonspecific MRI lesions are present, and nonspecific MRI lesions are accorded undue attention in the presence of symptoms of common conditions such as migraine. Further studies should establish the frequency of misdiagnosis, but the combination of nonspecific symptoms and nonspecific MRI abnormalities is likely a common contemporary source of MS misdiagnosis.

Editors' Note

Editors' Note: Regarding “The contemporary spectrum of multiple sclerosis misdiagnosis: A multicenter study,” Dalla Costa et al. express concerns about the interpretation of results because of the number of patients screened, the clinical and paraclinical characteristics of the misdiagnosed patients, and the lack of specification of fulfilled multiple sclerosis (MS) criteria through which the diagnosis was made. Solomon et al., authors of the study, explain that the study was not designed to assess the frequency of MS misdiagnosis or its specific causes. They add that application of MS diagnostic criteria to a neurologic syndrome not typical for MS contributed to misdiagnosis in 65% of cases, and that in 60% of cases, using MRI criteria for dissemination in space in a patient with nonspecific symptoms contributed to misdiagnosis. Commenting on “Early start of DOAC after ischemic stroke: Risk of intracranial hemorrhage and recurrent events,” Prof. Kawada argues that larger patient cohorts more accurately estimate the risk of intracranial hemorrhage (ICH) from direct, non–vitamin K antagonist oral anticoagulants (DOACs). Seiffge et al., authors of the study, agree but point out that they looked at symptomatic ICH only and a well-designed randomized clinical trial is necessary to address timing of DOAC after ischemic stroke due to nonvalvular atrial fibrillation. —Chafic Karam, MD, and Robert C. Griggs, MD Editors' Note: Regarding “The contemporary spectrum of multiple sclerosis misdiagnosis: A multicenter study,” Dalla Costa et al. express concerns about the interpretation of results because of the number of patients screened, the clinical and paraclinical characteristics of the misdiagnosed patients, and the lack of specification of fulfilled multiple sclerosis (MS) criteria through which the diagnosis was made. Solomon et al., authors of the study, explain that the study was not designed to assess the frequency of MS misdiagnosis or its specific causes.

Evaluation of 2016 MAGNIMS MRI criteria for dissemination in space in patients with a clinically isolated syndrome

Objectives: We compared validity of 2010 McDonald and newly proposed 2016 Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Multiple Sclerosis (MAGNIMS) criteria for dissemination in space (DIS) in predicting the conversion to clinically definite multiple sclerosis (CDMS) in patients with clinically isolated syndrome (CIS). Methods: Between 2006 and 2016, we enrolled 170 patients who had a first clinical event suggestive of multiple sclerosis (MS) from seven referral hospitals in Korea. Patients were classified into two groups based on the main outcome at the last follow-up: CDMS converters, who experienced a second attack, and non-converters. Results: Of 170 patients with mean follow-up duration of 54 months, 51% converted to CDMS. The sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and positive and negative predictive values of 2010 McDonald criteria were 70.9%, 63.1%, 67.1%, 66.3%, and 67.9%, and those for 2016 MAGNIMS criteria were 88.4%, 46.4%, 67.7%, 62.8%, and 79.6%, respectively. When we excluded 80 patients who underwent disease-modifying therapy before the second clinical event, the specificity increased to 92.3% and 84.6%, but the sensitivity decreased to 58.8% and 82.4% for 2010 McDonald and 2016 MAGNIMS criteria, respectively. Conclusion: 2016 MAGNIMS magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) criteria for DIS showed higher sensitivity but lower specificity than 2010 McDonald criteria in predicting conversion to CDMS in CIS patients.

Comparison of MRI Dissemination in Space Criteria for Predicting a First Clinical Event in Children with the Radiologically Isolated Syndrome (S2.001)

Comparison of MRI Dissemination in Space Criteria for Predicting a First Clinical Event in Children with the Radiologically Isolated Syndrome (S2.001)

FLAIR* to visualize veins in white matter lesions: A new tool for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis?

ObjectiveTo explore the potential of a post-processing technique combining FLAIR and T2* (FLAIR*) to distinguish between lesions caused by multiple sclerosis (MS) from cerebral small vessel disease (SVD) in a clinical setting.MethodsFLAIR and T2* head datasets acquired at 3T of 25 people with relapsing MS (pwRMS) and ten with pwSVD were used. After post-processing, FLAIR* maps were used to determine the proportion of white matter lesions (WML) showing the ‘vein in lesion’ sign (VIL), a characteristic histopathological feature of MS plaques. Sensitivity and specificity of MS diagnosis were examined on the basis of >45% VIL+ and >60% VIL+ WML, and compared with current dissemination in space (DIS) MRI criteria.ResultsAll pwRMS had >45% VIL+ WML (range 58–100%) whilst in pwSVD the proportion of VIL+ WML was significantly lower (0–64%; mean 32±20%). Sensitivity based on >45% VIL+ was 100% and specificity 80% whilst with >60% VIL+ as the criterion, sensitivity was 96% and specificity 90%. DIS criteria had 96% sensitivity and 40% specificity.ConclusionFLAIR* enables VIL+ WML detection in a clinical setting, facilitating differentiation of MS from SVD based on brain MRI.Key points• FLAIR* in a clinical setting allows visualization of veins in white matter lesions.• Significant proportions of MS lesions demonstrate a vein in lesion on MRI.• Microangiopathic lesions demonstrate a lower proportion of intralesional veins than MS lesions.• Intralesional vein-based criteria may complement current MRI criteria for MS diagnosis.

Assessment of Early Evidence of Multiple Sclerosis in a Prospective Study of Asymptomatic High-Risk Family Members

Subclinical inflammatory demyelination and neurodegeneration often precede symptom onset in multiple sclerosis (MS). To investigate the prevalence of brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and subclinical abnormalities among asymptomatic individuals at risk for MS. The Genes and Environment in Multiple Sclerosis (GEMS) project is a prospective cohort study of first-degree relatives of people with MS. Each participant's risk for MS was assessed using a weighted score (Genetic and Environmental Risk Score for Multiple Sclerosis Susceptibility [GERSMS]) comprising an individual's genetic burden and environmental exposures. The study dates were August 2012 to July 2015. Participants in the top and bottom 10% of the risk distribution underwent standard and quantitative neurological examination, including disability status, visual, cognitive, motor, and sensory testing, as well as qualitative and quantitative neuroimaging with 3-T brain MRI and optical coherence tomography. This study included 100 participants at risk for MS, with 41 at higher risk (40 women [98%]) and 59 at lower risk (25 women [42%]), at a mean (SD) age of 35.1 (8.7) years. Given the unequal sex distribution between the 2 groups, the analyses were restricted to women (n = 65). When considering all measured outcomes, higher-risk women differed from lower-risk women (P = .01 by omnibus test). Detailed testing with a vibration sensitivity testing device in a subgroup of 47 women showed that higher-risk women exhibited significantly poorer vibration perception in the distal lower extremities (P = .008, adjusting for age, height, and testing date). Furthermore, 5 of 65 women (8%) (4 at higher risk and 1 at lower risk) met the primary neuroimaging outcome of having T2-weighted hyperintense brain lesions consistent with the 2010 McDonald MRI criteria for dissemination in space. A subset of participants harbor many different neuroimaging features associated with MS, including perivenous T2-weighted hyperintense lesions and focal leptomeningeal enhancement, consistent with the hypothesis that these individuals are at higher risk of developing clinical symptoms of MS than the general population. Higher-risk asymptomatic family members of patients with MS are more likely to have early subclinical manifestations of MS. These findings underscore the importance of early detection in high-risk individuals. clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT01353547.

Diagnostic Utility of Systematic Aquaporin-4 Antibodies Determination in the First Event of Immune-Mediated Optic Neuritis

Background: Antibodies against aquaporin-4 (AQP4-ab) have diagnostic and prognostic value. However, little is known to date about their utility in the first event of optic neuritis (ON). Objective: To evaluate the utility of systematic AQP4-ab determination in a retrospective cohort of patients with a first onset of ON. Patients and Methods: All patients (n = 42) were tested for AQP4-ab in the following context: typical ON (TON) and atypical ON (AON). Clinical, radiological and biochemical data were collected; patients with TON vs. AON and AQP4-ab positive vs. negative were compared. Results: The proportion of AQP4-ab seropositive patients was 40% in the TON group vs. 40.9% in the AON group. Visual acuity (VA) at baseline was poor in AON patients (p = 0.02) and these patients were associated with worse VA outcome (p < 0.001) at 6 months compared with TON patients, with a median follow-up of 3.27 ± 1.79 years. Brain MRI with dissemination in space criteria (p < 0.001), spinal cord partial lesions (p < 0.001) and oligoclonal bands (p = 0.02) were associated with the initial stages of TON. VA severity, number of myelitis attacks and ON relapses did not differ significantly between seropositive and seronegative patients. AQP4-ab were detected only in neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorders patients. Conclusion: This study showed a high seropositivity for AQP4-ab in TON patients, suggesting that it could diagnostic utility at the onset of ON.

Importance of cerebrospinal fluid analysis in the era of McDonald 2010 criteria: a German-Austrian retrospective multicenter study in patients with a clinically isolated syndrome.

The majority of patients presenting with a first clinical symptom suggestive of multiple sclerosis (MS) do not fulfill the MRI criteria for dissemination in space and time according to the 2010 revision of the McDonald diagnostic criteria for MS and are thus classified as clinically isolated syndrome (CIS). To re-evaluate the utility of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analysis in the context of the revised McDonald criteria from 2010, we conducted a retrospective multicenter study aimed at determining the prevalence and predictive value of oligoclonal IgG bands (OCBs) in patients with CIS. Patients were recruited from ten specialized MS centers in Germany and Austria. We collected data from 406 patients; at disease onset, 44/406 (11 %) fulfilled the McDonald 2010 criteria for MS. Intrathecal IgG OCBs were detected in 310/362 (86 %) of CIS patients. Those patients were twice as likely to convert to MS according to McDonald 2010 criteria as OCB-negative individuals (hazard ratio = 2.1, p = 0.0014) and in a shorter time period of 25 months (95 % CI 21–34) compared to 47 months in OCB-negative individuals (95 % CI 36–85). In patients without brain lesions at first attack and presence of intrathecal OCBs (30/44), conversion rate to MS was 60 % (18/30), whereas it was only 21 % (3/14) in those without OCBs. Our data confirm that in patients with CIS the risk of conversion to MS substantially increases if OCBs are present at onset. CSF analysis definitely helps to evaluate the prognosis in patients who do not have MS according to the revised McDonald criteria.

Periventricular lesions and MS diagnostic criteria in young adults with typical clinically isolated syndromes

In patients who present with a clinically isolated syndrome (CIS), whose features are suggestive of multiple sclerosis (MS), fulfilling McDonald 2010 magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) criteria for dissemination in space (DIS) and dissemination in time (DIT) enables a diagnosis of MS. While ⩾1 periventricular lesion is included in the 2010 DIS criteria, earlier McDonald criteria required ⩾3 periventricular lesions to confirm DIS and recent Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Multiple Sclerosis (MAGNIMS)-recommended DIS criteria also require ⩾3 lesions. We investigated the effect of varying the required number of periventricular lesions and found that the best combination of specificity and sensitivity for clinically definite MS was seen for ⩾1 periventricular lesion using both the McDonald 2010 and MAGNIMS 2016 criteria.

Contribution of the symptomatic lesion in establishing MS diagnosis and prognosis.

To study the contribution of the symptomatic lesion in establishing multiple sclerosis (MS) diagnosis and prognosis. We performed an observational study based on a prospective clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) cohort of 1,107 patients recruited for clinical and brain MRI follow-up from 1995 to 2014. Eligible patients (n = 954) were divided into 4 groups according to baseline MRI: patients with a normal MRI (n = 290); patients with a single asymptomatic lesion (n = 18); patients with a single cord/brainstem symptomatic lesion (n = 35); and patients with more than 1 lesion (n = 611). For each group, we studied the risk of second attack, with 2005 McDonald MS and Expanded Disability Status Scale 3.0, using univariable and multivariable regression models adjusted by age, sex, oligoclonal bands, and disease-modifying treatments. We tested the diagnostic performance of a modified dissemination in space (DIS) criterion that includes symptomatic lesions in the total count and compared it to the DIS criteria (at least 1 asymptomatic lesion in at least 2 of the 4 MS characteristic MS locations) for all patients and for the subgroup of patients with brainstem or spinal cord topography. Patients with a cord/brainstem single symptomatic lesion have a higher risk of second attack and disability accumulation than patients with 0 lesions but have a similar risk compared to patients with 1 asymptomatic lesion. Diagnostic properties are reasonably maintained when the symptomatic lesion qualifies for DIS. Despite the recommendations of the 2010 McDonald criteria, symptomatic lesions should be taken into account when considering the diagnosis and prognosis of patients with CIS.

Should the symptomatic region be included in dissemination in space in MRI criteria for MS?

To investigate whether inclusion of lesions in the symptomatic region influences the performance of dissemination in space (DIS) criteria for a diagnosis of clinically definite multiple sclerosis (CDMS) in patients with a clinically isolated syndrome (CIS). We studied 30 patients with CIS with brainstem/cerebellar and spinal cord syndromes who had MRI scans at the time of CIS and were followed up for the development of CDMS. We retrospectively applied the McDonald 2010 DIS criteria (excluding all lesions in the symptomatic region) to baseline MRI scans and 2 modified DIS criteria: (1) the inclusion of asymptomatic lesions in the symptomatic region in DIS, and (2) the inclusion of any lesion in the symptomatic region in DIS. The performance of the McDonald 2010 DIS criteria and the 2 modified criteria for the development of CDMS was compared. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of the DIS criteria was, respectively, 73%, 73%, and 73% for the McDonald 2010 criteria, 80%, 73%, and 77% when asymptomatic lesions in the symptomatic region were included, and 87%, 73%, and 80% when any lesion in the symptomatic region was included in DIS. Including lesions in the symptomatic region in DIS increases the sensitivity of MRI criteria for diagnosing multiple sclerosis without compromising specificity. These findings may help inform future revisions of the diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis. This study provides Class II evidence that for patients with CIS, including lesions in the symptomatic region as part of the criteria for DIS does not significantly increase the accuracy for predicting the development of CDMS. The study lacks the precision to detect an important change in accuracy.