The metamorphosis of a caterpillar into a butterfly is an awe-inspiring example of how extraordinary functions are made possible through specific chemistry in nature’s complex systems. The chrysalis exoskeleton is revealed and shed as a caterpillar transitions to butterfly form. We employed solid-state NMR to evaluate the chemical composition and types of biomolecules in the chrysalides from which Monarch and Swallowtail butterflies emerged. The chrysalis composition was remarkably similar between Monarch and Swallowtail. Chitin is the major polysaccharide component, present together with proteins and catechols or catechol-type linkages in each chrysalis. The high chitin content is comparable to the highest chitin-containing insect exoskeletons. Proteomics analyses indicated the presence of chitinases that could be involved in synthesis and remodeling of the chrysalis as well as cuticular proteins which play a role in the structural integrity of the chrysalis. The nearly identical 13C CPMAS NMR spectra of each chrysalis and similar structural proteins supports the presence of underlying design principles integrating chitin and protein partners to elaborate the chrysalis.