Introduction Testicular torsion is an urological emergency. It is a time-sensitive condition in which twisting of the spermatic cord and testicular blood supply occurs, causing acute onset severe scrotal pain. The incidence of testicular torsion is highest amongst prepubertal males; however, it can occur at any age. Every hour that passes from the onset of symptoms has been shown to decrease the salvageability rate of the torted testis. Another significant factor that impacts testicular salvage is the degree of torsion. Prompt surgical exploration of the scrotum and orchidopexy, if the testis is salvageable, is the mainstay of treatment. A major sequela following orchidopexy for torsion is the decrease in testicular volume. The aim of this study is to assess testicular volume loss post orchidopexy in patients who presented with testicular torsion, as well as to identify the significance of the degree of rotation and duration of torsion in post-fixation volume loss. Methods This is a retrospective study in which all patients who underwent scrotal exploration for a primary diagnosis of testicular torsion between June 1, 2016, to January 15, 2023, were reviewed. The information obtained included the patients' demographics such as age, duration of symptoms, and laterality. Ultrasound images were reviewed for pre- and postoperative findings which included confirmation of testicular torsion as well as testicular volume measurements. Patients were excluded if they underwent an orchidectomy, had a diagnosis other than testicular torsion once scrotal exploration was done, or did not perform a follow-up scrotal ultrasound. Additionally, patients who underwent an orchidopexy for undescended testis earlier in life were also excluded. For statistical analysis purposes, degrees of testicular torsion and time to surgery were classified into mild, moderate, and severe. Results A total of 109 patient records were reviewed within the specific time frame. Of these, 47 patients were excluded as per the exclusion criteria mentioned previously, which gave us a sample size of 62 patients. Our findings showed that increasing severity of the degree of torsion as well as the time for surgery have statistically significant (p-value <0.05) effects on postoperative testicular volume loss. However, it was noted that time to surgery has a more pronounced effect on the mean volume loss than the degree of torsion. Moreover, the analysis also showed that, on average, with every additional hour from the onset of symptoms to surgery, the approximate volume loss is 0.15 ml. However, once time exceeds the 4.5-hour mark, the mean volume loss is 0.4 ml for each additional hour. Conclusion The current study indicates that earlier surgical intervention and correction of torsion are associated with enhanced preservation of postoperative testicular volume. Both the degree of torsion and time to surgery influence mean volume loss; however, time to surgery has a greater impact on the mean volume loss. These results highlight the importance of early diagnosis and intervention in cases of testicular torsion to minimize the risk of long-term testicular volume loss.