Copper, in seawater, is predominantly bound by organic ligands of unknown composition. Complexation has been thermodynamically characterized using synthetic ligand competition experiments which assumes equilibrium among all chelators within the system. However, equilibration times are constrained by wall loss issues with the synthetic ligands. Here, a solvent extraction methodology, was utilized to avoid the wall-loss problems. Using an exceptionally high concentration of a strong copper chelator, oxine (8-hydroxyquinoline), at least six hours of equilibration time is required to reach steady state between the competing ligand and the labile copper in seawater. This is much longer than equilibration times used in previously published works. Our method was optimized by using samples from GEOTRACES expeditions in the North Pacific and North Atlantic Oceans. Surprisingly, 60–90% of the copper was not exchangeable with oxine under these conditions. We define this fraction as “inert”, and these data, which include profiles as deep as 1000 m in the North Pacific, suggest that this is a widespread feature. Our results suggest that there are two distinct pools of labile and inert copper, rather than an assemblage of similar complexes with incremental differences in stability constants. The results have important implications for the marine geochemistry of copper and its bioavailability. Complexation has been shown to limit copper bioavailability and influences scavenging and residence time. Moreover, a basic paradigm of copper speciation methodologies, that even strong Cu complexes are relatively labile, is likely incorrect.