Conventional Bulk-boundary Correspondence Research Articles

Bulk-entanglement spectrum correspondence in PT - and PC -symmetric topological insulators and superconductors

In this study, we discuss a type of bulk-boundary correspondence, which holds for topological insulators and superconductors when the parity-time (PT) and/or parity-particle-hole (PC) symmetry are present. In these systems, even when the bulk topology is nontrivial, the edge spectrum is generally gapped, and thus the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence does not hold. We find that, instead of the edge spectrum, the single-particle entanglement spectrum becomes gapless when the bulk topology is nontrivial: i.e., the holds in PT- and/or PC-symmetric topological insulators and superconductors. After showing the correspondence using K-theoretic approach, we provide concrete models for each symmetry class up to three dimensions where nontrivial topology because of PT and/or PC is expected. An implication of our results is that, when the bulk topology under PT and/or PC symmetry is nontrivial, the noninteracting many-body entanglement spectrum is multiply degenerate in one dimension and is gapless in two or higher dimensions. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

High spin axion insulator

Axion insulators possess a quantized axion field θ = π protected by combined lattice and time-reversal symmetry, holding great potential for device applications in layertronics and quantum computing. Here, we propose a high-spin axion insulator (HSAI) defined in large spin-s representation, which maintains the same inherent symmetry but possesses a notable axion field θ = (s + 1/2)2π. Such distinct axion field is confirmed independently by the direct calculation of the axion term using hybrid Wannier functions, layer-resolved Chern numbers, as well as the topological magneto-electric effect. We show that the guaranteed gapless quasi-particle excitation is absent at the boundary of the HSAI despite its integer surface Chern number, hinting an unusual quantum anomaly violating the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence. Furthermore, we ascertain that the axion field θ can be precisely tuned through an external magnetic field, enabling the manipulation of bonded transport properties. The HSAI proposed here can be experimentally verified in ultra-cold atoms by the quantized non-reciprocal conductance or topological magnetoelectric response. Our work enriches the understanding of axion insulators in condensed matter physics, paving the way for future device applications.

Restoration of non-Hermitian bulk-boundary correspondence by counterbalancing skin effect

In systems exhibiting the non-Hermitian skin effect (NHSE), the bulk spectrum under open boundary conditions (OBC) significantly differs from that of its periodic counterpart. This disparity renders the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence (BBC) inapplicable. Here we propose an intuitive approach called doubling and swapping to restore the BBC, using the non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model as an example. Explicitly, we construct a modified system free of NHSE by swapping the asymmetric intracell hoppings in every second primitive unit cell. Importantly, this change does not alter the OBC spectrum. As a result, the modified periodic system can serve as the bulk for defining topological invariants that accurately predict edge states and topological phase transitions. The basic principle is applicable to many other systems. By extending the study to disordered systems in which the asymmetric hoppings are randomly swapped, we show that two types of winding numbers can also be defined to account for the NHSE and topological edge states, respectively.

Observation of Higher-Order Nodal-Line Semimetal in Phononic Crystals.

Higher-order topological insulators and semimetals, which generalize the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence, have attracted extensive research interest. Among them, higher-order Weyl semimetals feature twofold linear crossing points in three-dimensional momentum space, 2D Fermi-arc surface states, and 1D hinge states. Higher-order nodal-point semimetals possessing Weyl points or Dirac points have been implemented. However, higher-order nodal-line or nodal-surface semimetals remain to be further explored in experiments in spite of many previous theoretical efforts. In this work, we realize a second-order nodal-line semimetal in 3D phononic crystals. The bulk nodal lines, 2D drumhead surface states guaranteed by Zak phases, and 1D flat hinge states attributed to k_{z}-dependent quadrupole moments are observed in simulations and experiments. Our findings of nondispersive surface and hinge states may promote applications in acoustic sensing and energy harvesting.

Emergent non-Hermitian localization phenomena in the synthetic space of zero-dimensional bosonic systems

Phase transitions in non-Hermitian systems are at the focus of cutting edge theoretical and experimental research. On the one hand, parity-time- $(\mathcal{PT}\ensuremath{-})$ and $\mathrm{anti}\ensuremath{-}\mathcal{PT}\ensuremath{-}\mathrm{symmetric}$ physics have gained ever-growing interest, due to the existence of non-Hermitian spectral singularities called exceptional points (EPs). On the other hand, topological and localization transitions in non-Hermitian systems reveal new phenomena, e.g., the non-Hermitian skin effect and the absence of conventional bulk-boundary correspondence. The great majority of previous studies exclusively focus on non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, whose realization requires an a priori fine-tuned extended lattice to exhibit topological and localization transition phenomena. In this work, we show how the non-Hermitian localization phenomena can naturally emerge in the synthetic field moment space of zero-dimensional bosonic systems, e.g., in $\mathrm{anti}\ensuremath{-}\mathcal{PT}$- and $\mathcal{PT}\ensuremath{-}\mathrm{symmetric}$ quantum dimers. This offers an opportunity to simulate localization transitions in low-dimensional systems, without the need to construct complex arrays of, e.g., coupled cavities or waveguides. Indeed, the field moment equations of motion can describe an equivalent (quasi)particle moving in a one-dimensional (1D) synthetic lattice. This synthetic field moment space can exhibit nontrivial localization phenomena, such as non-Hermitian skin effect, induced by the presence of highly degenerate EPs. We demonstrate our findings on the example of an $\mathrm{anti}\ensuremath{-}\mathcal{PT}\ensuremath{-}\mathrm{symmetric}$ two-mode system, whose higher-order field moment eigenspace is emulated by a synthetic 1D non-Hermitian Hamiltonian having a Sylvester matrix shape. Our results can be directly verified in state-of-the-art optical setups, such as superconducting circuits and toroidal resonators, by measuring photon moments or correlation functions.

Experimental Identification of the Second-Order Non-Hermitian Skin Effect with Physics-Graph-Informed Machine Learning.

Topological phases of matter are conventionally characterized by the bulk-boundary correspondence in Hermitian systems. The topological invariant of the bulk in d dimensions corresponds to the number of (d - 1)-dimensional boundary states. By extension, higher-order topological insulators reveal a bulk-edge-corner correspondence, such that nth order topological phases feature (d - n)-dimensional boundary states. The advent of non-Hermitian topological systems sheds new light on the emergence of the non-Hermitian skin effect (NHSE) with an extensive number of boundary modes under open boundary conditions. Still, the higher-order NHSE remains largely unexplored, particularly in the experiment. An unsupervised approach-physics-graph-informed machine learning (PGIML)-to enhance the data mining ability of machine learning with limited domain knowledge is introduced. Through PGIML, the second-order NHSE in a 2D non-Hermitian topoelectrical circuit is experimentally demonstrated. The admittance spectra of the circuit exhibit an extensive number of corner skin modes and extreme sensitivity of the spectral flow to the boundary conditions. The violation of the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence in the second-order NHSE implies that modification of the topological band theory is inevitable in higher dimensional non-Hermitiansystems.

Coexistence of photonic and phononic corner states in a second-order topological phoxonic crystal

Recently, higher-order topological insulators (HOTIs) have been extended from the electronic system to classical wave systems. Beyond the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence, HOTIs can host zero-dimensional topologically protected corner states, which show the strong field localization and robustness against fabrication flaws. Here, we propose a second-order topological phoxonic crystal (PXC) based on a two-dimensional (2D) square lattice, of which different unit cell choices can show either a topologically trivial or non-trivial band structure characterized by the 2D Zak phase. The proposed PXC supports the coexistence of photonic and phononic topological corner states, and their robustness to disorders and defects is numerically demonstrated. Our work opens a venue for achieving simultaneous confinement of photons and phonons, which is potentially useful for exploring the interaction of photonic and phononic second-order topological states and for designing novel topological optomechanical devices.

Non-Hermitian higher-order topological superconductors in two dimensions: Statics and dynamics

Being motivated by intriguing phenomena such as the breakdown of conventional bulk boundary correspondence and emergence of skin modes in the context of non-Hermitian (NH) topological insulators, we here propose a NH second-order topological superconductor (SOTSC) model that hosts Majorana zero modes (MZMs). Employing the non-Bloch form of NH Hamiltonian, we topologically characterize the above modes by biorthogonal nested polarization and resolve the apparent breakdown of the bulk boundary correspondence. Unlike the Hermitian SOTSC, we notice that the MZMs inhabit only one corner out of four in the two-dimensional NH SOTSC. We extend the static MZMs into the realm of Floquet drive. We find anomalous $\pi$-mode following low-frequency mass-kick in addition to the regular $0$-mode that is usually engineered in a high-frequency regime. We further characterize the regular $0$-mode with biorthogonal Floquet nested polarization. Our proposal is not limited to the $d$-wave superconductivity only and can be realized in the experiment with strongly correlated optical lattice platforms.

Sensitivity of non-Hermitian systems

Understanding the extreme sensitivity of the eigenvalues of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians to the boundary conditions is of great importance when analyzing non-Hermitian systems, as it appears generically and is intimately connected to the skin effect and the breakdown of the conventional bulk boundary correspondence. Here we describe a method to find the eigenvalues of one-dimensional one-band models with arbitrary boundary conditions. We use this method on several systems to find analytical expressions for the eigenvalues, which give us conditions on the parameter values in the system for when we can expect the spectrum to be insensitive to a change in boundary conditions. By stacking one-dimensional chains, we use the derived results to find corresponding conditions for insensitivity for some two-dimensional systems with periodic boundary conditions in one direction. This would be hard by using other methods to detect skin effect, such as the winding of the determinant of the Bloch Hamiltonian. Finally, we use these results to make predictions about the (dis)appearance of the skin effect in purely two-dimensional systems with open boundary conditions in both directions.

Gain/loss effects on spin-orbit coupled ultracold atoms in two-dimensional optical lattices

Due to the fundamental position of spin-orbit coupled ultracold atoms in the simulation of topological insulators, the gain/loss effects on these systems should be evaluated when considering the measurement or the coupling to the environment. Here, incorporating the mature gain/loss techniques into the experimentally realized spin-orbit coupled ultracold atoms in two-dimensional optical lattices, we investigate the corresponding non-Hermitian tight-binding model and evaluate the gain/loss effects on various properties of the system, revealing the interplay of the non-Hermiticity and the spin-orbit coupling. Under periodic boundary conditions, we analytically obtain the topological phase diagram, which undergoes a non-Hermitian gapless interval instead of a point that the Hermitian counterpart encounters for a topological phase transition. We also unveil that the band inversion is just a necessary but not sufficient condition for a topological phase in two-level spin-orbit coupled non-Hermitian systems. Because the nodal loops of the upper or lower two dressed bands of the Hermitian counterpart can be split into exceptional loops in this non-Hermitian model, a gauge-independent Wilson-loop method is developed for numerically calculating the Chern number of multiple degenerate complex bands. Under open boundary conditions, we find that the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence does not break down with only on-site gain/loss due to the lack of non-Hermitian skin effect, but the dissipation of chiral edge states depends on the boundary selection, which may be used in the control of edge-state dynamics. Given the technical accessibility of state-dependent atom loss, this model could be realized in current cold-atom experiments.

Anisotropic Three-Dimensional Quantum Hall Effect and Magnetotransport in Mesoscopic Weyl Semimetals.

Weyl semimetals are emerging to become a new class of quantum-material platform for various novel phenomena. Especially, the Weyl orbit made from surface Fermi arcs and bulk relativistic states is expected to play a key role in magnetotransport, leading even to a three-dimensional quantum Hall effect (QHE). It is experimentally and theoretically important although yet unclear whether it bears essentially the same phenomenon as the conventional two-dimensional QHE. We discover an unconventional fully three-dimensional anisotropy in the quantum transport under a magnetic field. Strong suppression and even disappearance of the QHE occur when the Hall-bar current is rotated away from being transverse to parallel with respect to the Weyl point alignment, which is attributed to a peculiar absence of conventional bulk-boundary correspondence. Besides, transport along the magnetic field can exhibit a remarkable reversal from negative to positive magnetoresistance. These results establish the uniqueness of this QHE system as a novel three-dimensional quantum matter.

Competition between band topology and non-Hermiticity

The introduction of non-Hermiticity to topological systems profoundly modifies their topological properties, leading to unprecedented phenomena beyond the descriptions of Bloch band theory, e.g., the breakdown of the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence. However, the comprehensive interplay between band topology and non-Hermiticity remains elusive. Here, based on a non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model, we demonstrate that in the non-Hermitian topological systems, band topology and non-Hermiticity interplay by competing with each other, exhibiting a transition from symmetry dominance to non-Hermitian dominance. The former is featured with two edge states separately distributed at the two ends of the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger chain, similar to their Hermitian counterparts. In the latter, however, driven by non-Hermiticity, the two edge states become localized toward the same chain end, exhibiting the non-Hermitian skin effect. We find that such a transition is a universal behavior in the non-Hermitian systems, which is responsible for the breakdown of the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence and is the key factor to understanding the non-Hermitian topological properties. Furthermore, it is shown that this transition can be modified by the mode coupling between the edge states. As a comparison, we propose a non-Hermitian square-root Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model, where the edge states do not couple with each other and the mode coupling effect can be deactivated. Our work explicitly reveals the interplay between band topology and non-Hermiticity, which lays the foundation for the studies of non-Hermitian topological physics.

Characterizing bulk-boundary correspondence of one-dimensional non-Hermitian interacting systems by edge entanglement entropy

Dramatically different from the Hermitian systems, the conventional Bulk-Boundary Correspondence (BBC) is broken in the non-Hermitian systems. In this article, we use edge entanglement entropy to characterize the topological properties of non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger Hubbard model. For free Fermions, we study the scaling behavior of entanglement entropy and demonstrate that the edge entanglement entropy is a good indicator to delimit different phases of non-Hermitian systems. We further generalize the edge entanglement entropy to the non-Hermitian interacting Hubbard chain, and obtain the topological phase diagram in the plane of interaction and non-Hermitian hopping amplitudes. It is found that the Hubbard interaction diminishes and weakens the breakdown of Bulk-Boundary Correspondence, which eventually disappears at some critical value of interaction.

Topological dislocation modes in three-dimensional acoustic topological insulators

Dislocations are ubiquitous in three-dimensional solid-state materials. The interplay of such real space topology with the emergent band topology defined in reciprocal space gives rise to gapless helical modes bound to the line defects. This is known as bulk-dislocation correspondence, in contrast to the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence featuring topological states at boundaries. However, to date rare compelling experimental evidences have been presented for this intriguing topological observable in solid-state systems, owing to the huge challenges in creating controllable dislocations and conclusively identifying topological signals. Here, using a three-dimensional acoustic weak topological insulator with precisely controllable dislocations, we report an unambiguous experimental evidence for the long-desired bulk-dislocation correspondence, through directly measuring the gapless dispersion of the one-dimensional topological dislocation modes. Remarkably, as revealed in our further experiments, the pseudospin-locked dislocation modes can be unidirectionally guided in an arbitrarily-shaped dislocation path. The peculiar topological dislocation transport, expected in a variety of classical wave systems, can provide unprecedented control over wave propagations.

Skin effect in disordered non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger

In recent years, a large number of novel phenomena such as the breakdown of conventional bulk-boundary correspondence and non-Hermitian skin effect, have emerged in non-Hermitian systems. In this work, we investigate the localization of the eigenstates and the non-Hermitian skin effect of the disordered non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger (SSH) model by inverse participation rate (IPR) and average inverse participation rate (MIPR). We also investigate the bulk-boundary correspondence ratio of the system. Based on the above, we further investigate the effect of disorder on the non-Hermitian skin effect and the topological properties of the NH system. We find that the disorder does not destroy the localization of the topological edge state due to the protection from the topology of the system. But the eigenstates of bulk are greatly affected by the disorder. In the presence of disorder, the eigenstates of the bulk will rapidly extend into the bulk. Thus, the non-Hermitian skin effect is vulnerable to the disorder. When the disorder is enhanced, the non-Hermitian skin effect will be greatly suppressed. We also show that the disorder will reduce the energy gap and imaginary energy of the system. Our study contributes to the further understanding of the non-Hermitian skin effect.

The topological counterparts of non-Hermitian SSH models

Inspired by the relevance between the asymmetric coupling amplitude and the imaginary gauge field, we construct the counterpart of the non-Hermitian SSH model. The idea is the nonzero imaginary magnetic flux vanishing when the boundary condition changes from periodic to open. The zero imaginary magnetic flux of the counterpart leads to the eliminating of the non-Hermitian skin effect and the non-Hermitian Aharonov–Bohm effect which ensures the recovery of the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence from the non-Bloch bulk-boundary correspondence. We explain how some the non-Hermitian models can be transformed to the non-Hermitian SSH models and how the non-reciprocal hopping in the non-Hermitian SSH models can be transformed from one term to the other terms by the similarity transformations. We elaborate why the effective imaginary magnetic flux disappears due to the interplay of the non-reciprocal hoppings in the partner of the non-Hermitian SSH model. As the results, we obtain the topological invariants of the non-Hermitian SSH model in analytical form defined in conventional Brillouin zone. The non-Hermitian SSH model in domain configuration on a chain is discussed with this method. The technique gives an alternative way to study the topological properties of non-Hermitian systems.

Experimentally Detecting Quantized Zak Phases without Chiral Symmetry in Photonic Lattices.

Symmetries play a major role in identifying topological phases of matter and in establishing a direct connection between protected edge states and topological bulk invariants via the bulk-boundary correspondence. One-dimensional lattices are deemed to be protected by chiral symmetry, exhibiting quantized Zak phases and protected edge states, but not for all cases. Here, we experimentally realize an extended Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model with broken chiral symmetry by engineering one-dimensional zigzag photonic lattices, where the long-range hopping breaks chiral symmetry but ensures the existence of inversion symmetry. By the averaged mean displacement method, we detect topological invariants directly in the bulk through the continuous-time quantum walk of photons. Our results demonstrate that inversion symmetry protects the quantized Zak phase but edge states can disappear in the topological nontrivial phase, thus breaking the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence. Our photonic lattice provides a useful platform to study the interplay among topological phases, symmetries, and the bulk-boundary correspondence.

Reconstructed conventional bulk-boundary correspondence in the non-Hermitian s -wave nodal-ring superconductor

Recently, the interplay between the non-Hermitian skin effect (NHSE) and topological phases has attracted a lot of attention. When the NHSE occurs in a topological system, the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence (BBC) based on the Bloch band theory is destroyed. In this work, we investigate a non-Hermitian nodal-ring semimetal with the $s$-wave superconducting (SC) term. We find that the SC term introduces the intrinsic coupling between the different general Brillouin zones (GBZs) of the particle and hole subbands in our model, which drives the total GBZ to the BZ. Furthermore, when the SC term is finite, we show a possibility that the GBZ is the same as the BZ. We also find that the Bloch winding number of the quasi-one-dimensional model can predict the number of Majorana zero states faithfully in this case, which implies that the conventional BBC is reconstructed in our model. The localization strengths of the Majorana zero states are also calculated to show the reconstruction of conventional BBC. The finite-size effect, related experimental regimes in the electric circuit, and the fragility of this reconstructed conventional BBC are also discussed in this work.

Quantum superposition demonstrated higher-order topological bound states in the continuum

Higher-order topological insulators, as newly found non-trivial materials and structures, possess topological phases beyond the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence. In previous studies, in-gap boundary states such as the corner states were regarded as conclusive evidence for the emergence of higher-order topological insulators. Here, we present an experimental observation of a photonic higher-order topological insulator with corner states embedded into the bulk spectrum, denoted as the higher-order topological bound states in the continuum. Especially, we propose and experimentally demonstrate a new way to identify topological corner states by exciting them separately from the bulk states with photonic quantum superposition states. Our results extend the topological bound states in the continuum into higher-order cases, providing an unprecedented mechanism to achieve robust and localized states in a bulk spectrum. More importantly, our experiments exhibit the advantage of using the time evolution of quantum superposition states to identify topological corner modes, which may shed light on future exploration between quantum dynamics and higher-order topological photonics.

Observation of Non-Hermitian Topology with Nonunitary Dynamics of Solid-State Spins.

Non-Hermitian topological phases exhibit a number of exotic features that have no Hermitian counterparts, including the skin effect and breakdown of the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence. Here, we implement the non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger Hamiltonian, which is a prototypical model for studying non-Hermitian topological phases, with a solid-state quantum simulator consisting of an electron spin and a ^{13}C nuclear spin in a nitrogen-vacancy center in a diamond. By employing a dilation method, we realize the desired nonunitary dynamics for the electron spin and map out its spin texture in the momentum space, from which the corresponding topological invariant can be obtained directly. From the measured spin textures with varying parameters, we observe both integer and fractional winding numbers. The non-Hermitian topological phase with fractional winding number cannot be continuously deformed to any Hermitian topological phase and is intrinsic to non-Hermitian systems. Our result paves the way for further exploiting and understanding the intriguing properties of non-Hermitian topological phases with solid-state spins or other quantum simulation platforms.