The Quran is a vital guide for Muslims, requiring proper recitation with tajwid. However, many converts struggle with accurate Quranic recitation even after years of embracing Islam. This study aims to develop Total Physical Response (TPR)-based teaching activities to enhance Quranic recitation proficiency among converts by integrating physical movements with learning, aiding in recognizing Hijaiyah letters and tajwid rules. Utilizing the Fuzzy Delphi Method (FDM), this study achieved expert consensus on proposed TPR-based activities. Ten experts in technical and vocational education, educational technology, and curriculum development participated, selected through purposive sampling. Data collection involved a two-stage process: a workshop where experts rated each activity on a 5-point Likert scale, followed by FDM analysis, transforming responses into triangular fuzzy numbers. This rigorous evaluation required at least 75% consensus and a threshold value (d) not exceeding 0.2. Findings validated all 25 TPR-based activity elements, demonstrating their suitability for teaching Quranic recitation to converts. TPR’s integration of physical activities significantly enhances memory retention and understanding, making it effective for converts with diverse backgrounds and minimal prior Quranic knowledge. The study recommends developing structured modules, providing expert training, creating interactive learning environments, and implementing continuous assessments. Incorporating Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) and varied teaching methods aims to improve engagement and motivation, ultimately making Quranic learning more effective and enjoyable for converts.