In this study, we developed a cost-effective and rapid method for fabricating force-sensing resistor (FSR) sensors as an alternative to commercial force sensors. Our aim was to achieve performance characteristics comparable to existing commercial products while significantly reducing costs and fabrication time. We analyzed the material composition of two widely used commercial force sensors: Interlink FSR-402 and Flexiforce A201-1. Based on this analysis, we selected 4B and 9B pencils, which contain high concentrations of graphite, and silicone sealant to replicate these material properties. The fabrication process involved creating piezoresistive sheets by shading A4 copy paper with 4B and 9B pencils to form a uniform layer of graphite. Additionally, we prepared a mixture of 9B pencil lead powder and silicone sealant, ensuring a consistent application on the paper substrate. Measurement results indicated that the force sensor fabricated using a mixture of 9B pencil powder and silicone sealant exhibited electrical and mechanical characteristics closely resembling those of commercial sensors. Load tests revealed that the hand-made sensors provided a proportional voltage output in response to increasing and decreasing loads, similar to commercial FSR sensors. These results suggest that our fabrication method can produce reliable and accurate FSR sensors suitable for various applications, including wearable technology, robotics, and force-sensing interfaces. Overall, this study demonstrates the potential for creating cost-effective and high-performance FSR sensors using readily available materials and simple fabrication techniques.