With 2010 being the fortieth-anniversary year of the Gray Panthers, Roger Sanjek’s new history of the organization is timely. Regrettably, the problems with which the Panthers have grappled for 40 years have gotten larger, the Panthers smaller. As Sanjek notes, however, the Gray Panthers have always been one among many players in a broader progressive movement, and their diminished presence now does not equate with the end of progressivism. Sanjek’s book is an outstanding record of the developmental arc of this fascinating organization and can be read as both commentary on the cultural construction of old age within American politics and an illumination of the more general forces that lead to the rise and fall of social movements. Sanjek seems to be the person who needed to write this book. A true participant-observer, Sanjek was intermittently active in the movement himself from his own Berkeley days in 1977 to the present day in New York City. He began to take a reflective look at the movement in 1981, when officially allowed to have access to organizational documents at the Presbyterian Historical Society in Philadelphia, with Maggie Kuhn’s support. Though a long time coming, it is fortunate that Sanjek never totally abandoned the project or his involvement as an activist. The book is a product of his extremely close reading of documents, records, minutes, clippings, and transcripts, as well as face-to-face interviews with many key personalities in the movement, including Kuhn, Lillian Rabinowitz, and others. He fully acknowledges his “positionality” as a Gray Panther member and the methodological realities associated with constructing history through the conflation of documents, observations, personal memories (headnotes), scratch notes, regular field notes, and other ephemera. As he notes, the story is “part ethnography, part history, part memoir” (xviii). Early chapters start with the people—the exemplary figures who were attracted to the movement and the founder of the movement, Kuhn herself. In providing an extensive biography
Read full abstract