Three-dimensional organotypic models benefit from the ability to mimic physiological cell–cell or cell–matrix interactions and therefore offer superior models for studying pathological or physiological conditions compared to 2D cultures. Organotypic models consisting of keratinocytes supported by fibroblasts embedded in collagen matrices have been utilised for the study of oral conditions. However, the provision of a suitable model for investigating the pathogenesis of periodontitis has been more challenging. Part of the complexity relates to the different regional epithelial specificities and connective tissue phenotypes. Recently, it was confirmed, using 3D organotypic models, that distinct fibroblast populations were implicated in the provision of specific inductive and directive influences on the overlying epithelia. This paper presents the organotypic model of the dentogingival junction (DGJ) constructed to demonstrate the differential fibroblast influences on the maintenance of regionally specific epithelial phenotypes. Therefore, the review aims are (1) to provide the biological basis underlying 3D organotypic cultures and (2) to comprehensively detail the experimental protocol for the construction of the organotypic cultures and the unique setup for the DGJ model. The latter is the first organotypic culture model used for the reconstruction of the DGJ and is recommended as a useful tool for future periodontal research.