To promote the application of high-strength-materials in concrete-filled steel tubular (CFST) columns, finite element modeling, and parametric analysis were conducted on circular CFST stub columns filled with normal-strength concrete (NSC) and ultra-high strength concrete (UHSC). For simulating properties of concrete under passive confinement, a three-dimensional constitutive model for NSC and UHSC was established, of which the stress-strain relation and evolution of dilation angle are both related to confining pressure and axial plastic strain. The model was verified by tests of CFHSST (concrete-filled high-strength steel tube) and UHSCFST (ultra-high-strength concrete-filled steel tube), demonstrating that the interaction between concrete and steel tube can be revealed correctly. Parameter analysis of CFST stub columns filled with NSC and UHSC was carried out, with the grade of steel tube covering from Q235 to Q890 and the D/t ratio ranging from 8.9 to 75. With the decrease of D/t ratio, the deformation capacity and post-peak performance of columns are improved. A recommended range of steel contribution ratio of UHSCFST was proposed for the consideration of cost and safety, which is 25% ∼ 63%. Based on the analysis of interaction between concrete and steel tubes, the compatibility of the two materials is recommended, of which the yield of steel tube occurs after contact with concrete and before the concrete reaches its peak strength. Besides, the formula in EC4 overestimates the load-bearing capacity of CFST stub columns with high-strength materials. Therefore, a modified formula was proposed that reduces the enhancement factor of concrete strength and enables a safer prediction of load-bearing capacity.