Franz Schubert. Sinfonien Nr. 4-6. Vorgelegt von Arnold Feil und Douglas Woodfull-Harris. (Neuc Ausgabe samtlicher Werke, Ser. 5: Orchesterwerke, Bd. 2.) Kassel: Barenreiter, 1999. [Zur Edition, p. vii--viii; Vorwort, p. ix-xi; facsims., p. xii-xx; score, 275 p.; und Lesarten, p. 279-305; Notenbeispiele, p. 307-13. Cloth. ISMN M-006-49704-1; BA 5538. DM 400.] Franz Schubert. Nr. 7 in h. Vorgelegt von Werner Aderhold. (Neue Ausgabe samtlicher Werke, Ser. 5: Orchesterwerke, Bd. 3.) Kassel: Barenreiter, 1997. [Zur Edition, p. vii-viii; Vorwort, p. ix-xvii; facsims., p. xix-xxv; score, 63 p.; Anhang, p. 67-77; und Lesarten, p. 81-91. Cloth. ISMN M-006-49705-8; BA 5542. DM 175.] Franz Schubert. Nr. 4 in c, D 417. Herausgegeben von Arnold Feil und Douglas Woodfull-Harris. Urtext der Neuen Schubert-Ausgabe. Kassel: Barenreiter, c1998. [Editorial note in Ger., Eng., 1 p.; score, 106 p. ISMN M-006-49902-1; BA 5604. DM 59.] Franz Schubert. Nr. 6 in C, D 589. Herausgegeben von Arnold Feil und Douglas Woodfull-Harris. Urtext der Neuen Schubert-Ausgabe. Kassel: Barenreiter, c1998. [Editorial note in Ger., Eng., 1 p.; score 119 p. ISMN M-006-49914-4; BA 5646. DM 59.] Franz Schubert. Symphony in D Major (1820/21), D 708A. Reconstructed and instrumentated [sic] from the short score by Gunter Elsholz. Bad Soden, Germany: Gunter Elsholz (ParkstraBe 46a, D-65812 Bad Soden), c2000. [Introd. in Ger., Eng., p. i-ii; divergences from Schubert's short score draft, p. iii-iv; score, p. 1-232; facsim. reprod. of the sketch, p. A-J.] Franz Schubert. Symphony in D Major (1828), D 936A. Version for string orchestra realised by Gunter Elsholz. Bad Soden, Germany: Gunter Elsholz (ParkstraBe 46a, D-65812 Bad Soden), c1994. [Pref. in Ger., Eng., 7 p.; score, p. 1-112; facsim. reprod. of the sketch, p. A-K.] The slow emergence of the Neuc Schubert-Ausgabe suddenly gains impetus with the appearance of Franz Schubert's symphonies nos. 4-6 and the Unfinished in B minor. At first, the Unfinished may in fact not be recognized as such, since the title is withheld (not being Schubert's) and the identification on the spine announces the work as Sinfonie Nr. 7. No, this is not the Symphony in E Major, D. 729, widely known as the Seventh. Nor is it the Great C-Major Symphony, known to us as the Ninth, but since the early nineteenth century alternatively numbered as the Seventh. The Neue Schubert-Ausgabe has its rationale for numbering the Unfinished as the Seventh, since it alone of the fragmentary symphonies includes movements wholly completed by Schubert, which is not true of the D. 729 work, nor of the other four fragmentary symphonies (D. 2B, D. 615, D. 708A, and D. 936A). On the other hand, some might argue that a structurally complete sketch mapping every bar of all four movements (D. 729) is as much a Schu bert symphony as is the B-minor half-symphony. But there are more practical considerations: among them, is the musical world prepared to expunge the memory of the Great as no. 9, or its alternative designation as no. 7, and now think of it as no. 8? This is what the Neue Schubert-A usgabe presumably expects. In the more than quarter of a century that Barenreiter Verlag has adopted this designation, very few publishers, recording companies, radio stations, or concert promoters have seen fit to follow suit. At the Leeds International Schubert Conference, 2000, I was recently reminded of some of the problems facing the makers of scholarly Schubert editions by one of the key figures of the Neue Schubert-A usgabe, Walther Durr. What matters here most is that these new volumes of the Schubert edition continue to maintain the high standards of editing and presentation encountered in their earlier companion volumes--they are discreetly handsome, and what lies between the covers reflects the same rigorous aspirations. The apparatus of scholarship also remains at the same level, with an extensive foreword, selected pages from sources in facsimile, and Quellen und Lesarten comprising a discussion of sources, editorial principles, and critical commentary (all in German only). …
Read full abstract