The authors have previously investigated the effect of bed rest versus ambulation on maternal disease in patients with proteinuric hypertension. They found that complete bed rest appeared to have no advantage over “ambulation as desired.” In the present report, they examine the comparative effects of rest and ambulation on fetoplacental well-being and fetal outcome in the same patients. Forty patients were divided into two groups (rested and ambulatory) of 20 patients each. Initially, the human placental lactogen concentrations were similar in the two groups, but the estriol concentrations were an average of 155 nmol per liter lower in the ambulant group. The difference between the means is not quite significant at the 5 per cent level (t = 2.019). With both the human placenta lactogen and estriol assays, there was a tendency for values to rise more in the group of patients managed by complete bed rest, but none of the differences shown between the groups approached significance. Among the 40 patients who participated in the trial were 10 who had both elevated plasma urate concentrations (more than 0.25 mmol per liter before 32 weeks, or more than 0.35 mmol per liter from 32 weeks) and grossly small-for-date fetuses on clinical examination. Strict bed rest in these 10 patients seemed to be associated with development of severe preeclampsia and better fetal prognosis. Four patients' fetuses died in utero from simple placental insufficiency. Another intrauterine death was caused by placental abruption at 30 weeks in a mildly hypertensive patient in the ambulant group. An early neonatal death caused by a tentorial tear during a spontaneous vaginal delivery at term occurred in a patient in the rested group. In both of these patients, plasma urate concentration was normal, and there was no evidence of fetal growth retardation. Of the 10 patients with both hyperuricemia and growth-retarded fetuses, the five patients who were confined to bed developed the premonitory symptoms of eclampsia (increasing headache, visual disturbances, epigastric pain, and vomiting), whereas only one of the patients allowed to ambulate freely in the ward did so. The development of premonitory symptoms led to urgent delivery by cesarean section in all except one of these patients. This one patient had a uterine size equivalent to only 23 weeks at 26 weeks of gestation and was treated conservatively for preeclampsia until fetal death supervened and was followed shortly by the onset of labor. The three remaining macerated stillbirths were in the ambulatory group. All of the birth weights for the 10 patients were below the 10th centile. The trial took place during 1978 and 1979. Since then, all but one of the patients who lost their babies while on the trial have been delivered near term of healthy babies after entirely normotensive pregnancies. The exception is the patient whose stillbirth was due to abruptio placentae. This patient remains mildly hypertensive, and a further pregnancy ended in miscarriage at 18 weeks.
Read full abstract