AbstractKnowledge of the ecological mechanisms governing N2O cycling in marine sediments lags that of water columns and terrestrial soils, leaving much to be learned about how microbial community dynamics relate to variability in sediment N2O fluxes. The present study assesses these relationships across two distinct environments by focusing on the community structure and activity of N2O reducing microorganisms. The N2O sink capacity of minimally impacted Bermudian mangrove sediments was first estimated using trace‐level microsensors and profile interpretation modeling. Molecular data obtained from these sediments were then compared with those from the Northeast Subarctic Pacific (NESAP) outer continental margin, where previous measurements suggest considerable N2O effluxes. Net N2O uptake was observed for mangrove sediments under ambient and elevated dissolved inorganic nitrogen concentrations (−0.22 ± 0.15 to −0.30 ± 0.26 μmol N2O m−2 d−1), suggesting the microbial potential for N2O consumption exceeded the potential for production via combined nitrification and denitrification. Targeting of bacterial nosZI and nosII gene clusters for quantification using qPCR indicated higher abundance and expression of non‐denitrifier nosZII genes in mangrove sediments demonstrating net N2O uptake. Net N2O production in NESAP sediments was associated with higher abundance and expression of nosZI genes associated with canonical denitrifiers. These results suggest that organisms possessing atypical nosZII genes may act as important N2O scavengers in low‐nitrogen coastal sediments.