The synthesis of copper nanoparticles (CuNPs) was accomplished by using a rapid, green, and versatile argon plasma reduction method that involves solvent extraction. With this method, a plasma-solid state interaction forms and CuNPs can be synthesized from copper(II) sulfate using a low-pressure, low-temperature argon plasma. Characterization studies of the CuNPs revealed that when a metal precursor is treated under optimal experimental conditions of 80 W of argon plasma for 300 s, brown CuNPs are synthesized. However, when those same brown CuNPs are placed in Milli-Q water for a period of 10 days, oxidation occurs and green CuNPs are formed. Confirmation of the chemical identity of the CuNPs was performed by using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. The results reveal that the brown CuNPs are predominantly Cu0 or what we refer to as CuNPs, while the green CuNPs are a mixture of Cu0 and Cu(OH)2 NPs. Upon further characterization of both brown and green CuNPs with scanning electron microscopy (SEM), the results depict brown CuNPs with a rod-like shape and approximate dimensions of 40 nm × 160 nm, while the green CuNPs were smaller in size, with dimensions of 40-80 nm, and more of a round shape. When testing the antibacterial activity of both brown and green CuNPs, our findings demonstrate the effectiveness of both CuNPs against Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus bacteria at a concentration of 17 μg/mL. The inactivation of S. aureus and E. coli 7-day-old biofilms required CuNP concentrations of 99 μg/mL. SEM images of treated 7-day-old S. aureus and E. coli biofilms depict cell membranes that are completely damaged, suggesting a physical killing mechanism. In addition, when the same concentration of CuNPs used to inactivate biofilms were tested with human fibroblasts, both brown and green CuNPs were found to be biocompatible.