Comprehensive Law Research Articles

Termination of Prosecution Based on Restorative Justice in Indonesia it is Associated with the Renewal Criminal Law

Criminal acts arise from various aspects of human activity, including the political, social and economic spheres. The success of law enforcement is traditionally measured by the ability to bring criminals to justice and impose appropriate penalties. However, in certain minor cases, such as theft, embezzlement, and fraud with minimal losses, the public questions the need for prosecution, as they believe that prosecution does not match the seriousness of the offense. The purpose of this study is to analyze the implications and effectiveness of prosecution discontinuation based on restorative justice in the Indonesian legal framework. Using a qualitative research approach, this study examines the regulatory structure and practical application of restorative justice in Indonesia. Data was collected through document analysis and interviews with legal practitioners to explore alignment of regulations with legal principles and community expectations. The research findings show that, although restorative justice offers a viable avenue to achieve peace between offenders and victims, its implementation in Indonesia is still limited, as it is not yet embedded in the broader criminal law system. Currently, peace agreements between the parties are only considered as a mitigating factor in the sentencing process. This research suggests that stronger legal legitimacy for restorative justice, such as the inclusion of restorative justice into the Draft Criminal Procedure Code is essential to adapt to the evolving legal culture and public expectations. The implications of this research highlight the need for comprehensive criminal law reform to ensure justice that aligns with societal values and contemporary legal standards.

Animal Welfare Perspectives Against the Backdrop of Animal Cruelty in Nigeria

Knowledge is crucial for improving animal welfare. People's perceptions, attitudes, and understanding may be a hindrance to adopting animal welfare-improving ideas which is crucial for developing effective animal welfare policies and advocacy in Nigeria. This study evaluates the current knowledge, attitudes, and perceptions of animal welfare among Nigerian residents. A cross-sectional survey using a structured questionnaire distributed via emails, social media platforms, and by personal contact. The survey collected data from 694 respondents across the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory of Nigeria over 6 months (November 2023 and June 2024). Descriptive statistics, reliability testing, and inferential statistical tests were performed using SPSS for windows. The result revealed that majority (60-87.3%) of the respondents had a good knowledge of what constitutes cruelty to animals. Also, 88.8% were aware that animals have right to freedoms that could enhance their welfare, and 96.1% agreed that freedom from hunger and thirst is reasonable for animals. The standard deviations were relatively low, suggesting consistent responses among participants. Respondents (87.3%) also supported the enforcement of animal cruelty laws and the enactment of comprehensive animal welfare laws in Nigeria. The high knowledge scores among Nigerian residents suggest a strong foundational understanding of animal welfare principles. It is recommended that despite the result continual advocacy and policy development are still necessary to shape the public attitudes, and perceptions to animal.

Federal Territory: Constitutional and Legal Regulation Development

This article examines the legal status of federal territories as public law entities in the Russian Federation, which emerged as a result of the 2020 constitutional reform. This article discusses issues related to constitutional terminology, the constitutional-legal status, and legal regulation of federal territories, along with an analysis of the practice implementation of the constitutional provisions governing these territories. The specific features of existing federal territories in the Russian Federation and in foreign countries are also reviewed. The necessity for further development of the novelty introduced by the Constitution of the Russian Federation regarding federal territories is underscored, including a discussion on the unique tax regime applicable to these territories. The article employs several scientific methods, including the comparative-legal method and the formal legal method, with additional methods such as analysis and synthesis also utilized. Conclusion: Despite the short period between the establishment of the first federal territory and the development of its legal framework, several distinctive characteristics have also emerged in Russian legislation. An analysis of Russian constitutional law reveals key features in the exercise of public authority in this new public law entity. When comparing approaches to public authority in other countries, the models of India, Brazil, and Canada were chosen for comparison. It was found that Russia’s form of public authority within federal territories is unique and does not fully align with any of the models seen in these foreign states. However, Russian legislation currently lacks a comprehensive law that regulates federal territories as a whole. At present, the only federal territory established in the Russian Federation is the Sirius federal territory, and its legal status is governed by the federal law “On the Federal Territory ‘Sirius’”. This highlights the need for further development of a broader normative framework that regulates the status of the federal territory. Such a framework would not only solidify the legal status of the Sirius federal territory but also provide for future federal territories yet to be formed

The level of attitude of managers and employees towards the goals and concepts of comprehensive quality law management system in hospitals

Comprehensive quality management should be considered as a management system that ensures the correct and continuous execution of work at all levels of the hospitals. This system is a direct way to sustain progress and a coherent and comprehensive effort that is used to continuously improve all aspects of a hospitals activities to achieve competitive advantages. The emphasis of the comprehensive quality management system is on increasing the satisfaction of customers or consumers through the management of methods. This system thinks about the continuous improvement of the hospitals activities through individual managers and employees, and finally the effort to improve the performance of all hospitals levels. raises This research is based on the purpose of an applied research from the point of view of the descriptive correlation method. The studies that have been done so far have presented methods and tools of comprehensive quality management to evaluate and implement this system in both industrial and commercial hospitals. are These studies identified dimensions and factors of comprehensive quality management for its evaluation and study. These tools help both researchers and managers to implement comprehensive quality management in the hospitals.

On the legal issues of the Shiprider Program

As an essential tool for the United States to pursue its maritime interests, the Shiprider Program has become the legal basis for the United States to carry out global comprehensive maritime law enforcement cooperation. However, the United States Coast Guard (hereafter USCG) has over-expanded its maritime jurisdiction by breaking through the limitations of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (hereinafter UNCLOS) in its law enforcement activities. The USCG’ activities in the South China Sea may jeopardize other countries’ maritime rights and interests and homeland security, aggravating the maritime disputes in those regions. Therefore, this paper proposes to clarify the applicable law and improve the responsibility mechanism for the Shiprider Program to ensure that the activities of the USCG are in line with the corresponding provisions of the UNCLOS.

The evolution of EU–US cybersecurity law and policy: on drivers of convergence

ABSTRACT The digitalisation of the economy increases the vulnerability of both economies in the EU and the US, as does its transborder dimension. Cyber policy has evolved over time on both sides of the Atlantic. The EU began initially to emphasise cybercrime regulation but its focus upon cybersecurity now dominates, similar to the US. The internal market has evolved as a rationale for regulation in the EU and to similar effect a market-led approach dominates in the US. While in the EU a comprehensive cybersecurity law has been adopted, the US lacks a uniform federal cybersecurity law. Despite many domestic divergences, there is considerable similarity between the US and the EU. Substantively, these divergences have not inhibited convergence. Geopolitical considerations as to cyber have accelerated an ongoing process, driven by the transborder nature of cyber security and the global leadership of the EU and the US.

The Urgency of Implementing a Cyber Notary in Indonesia: A Comparative Study with The United States

Introduction: Current technological developments have an influence on all aspects of human life, including government administration. Notaries are non-governmental public officials who provide public services in providing good governance for the community. However, notarial services in Indonesia are carried out conventionally, which slows down notarial services. Different things happened in America. America is a country that has advanced technology.Purposes of the Research: The aim of this research is to analyze the urgency of implementing cyber notary in Indonesia, find differences in legal regulations and application of law regarding cyber notary in Indonesia and America and find the right solution in organizing cyber notary in Indonesia.Methods of the Research: The research used normative juridical method with secondary data from primary legal sources including various laws and acts like Law Number 2 of 2014, Law Number 30 of 2014, and others related to notarial acts, personal data protection, and blockchain technology in California and Illinois.Results of the Research: The research reveals Indonesia lacks comprehensive laws for cyber notaries. Learning from the US, which has established regulations, Indonesia needs to revise its Notary Law to incorporate cyber notaries and uphold principles of good governance.

Bureaucratic Law Transformation and Trade Union Fragmentation in Thailand and Japan in the Context of Free Trade

To achieve economic development, a country must cooperate with other nations. This often involves a partnership where one country provides workers, while foreign investors contribute significant capital. To sustain such trade relationships, bureaucratic reform is sometimes necessary. These reforms aim to enhance administrative efficiency and economic competitiveness but can also lead to the fragmentation of trade unions, which impacts workers' protection and rights. This research explores the transformation of bureaucratic law and trade union fragmentation in Thailand and Japan within the context of free trade. A qualitative comparative study method was employed to analyze the effects of these reforms in both countries. In Thailand, reforms aimed at simplifying the licensing process and reducing regulations have been successful in attracting foreign investment and accelerating economic growth. However, they have also increased job uncertainty and weakened social protection. In Japan, while traditional labor unions persist, the increasing fragmentation has resulted in uneven worker protection. This analysis reveals that the social and economic effects of these changes are complex and require careful policy consideration to balance economic growth with worker protection. The study recommends comprehensive labor law reforms, increased social dialogue, and stronger support for new trade unions to ensure fair and sustainable worker protections in both countries.

Changes in Smoking Patterns in Turkey Before and After the Ban on Loose Cigarettes: An Ecological Perspective From Global Tobacco Surveillance Data.

Loose or individual cigarettes sold without packaging pose a unique challenge for tobacco control, which is the leading cause of premature and preventable mortality worldwide. This study aims to assess the changes in smoking patterns following the ban on loose cigarettes in 2008 in Turkey. Gender-stratified trend analysis of smoking patterns before and after the ban on loose cigarettes was done using the Global Tobacco Surveillance data (adults: Global Adult Tobacco Survey (GATS) 2008, 2012, and 2016; youth: Global Youth Tobacco Survey (GYTS) 2003, 2005, 2009, 2012, and 2017) from Turkey. The trends in smoking patterns were triangulated with the introduction of the loose cigarette ban and other laws in Turkey. From GATS 1 in 2008 to GATS 2 in 2012, there were initial declines in adult smoking patterns, including current smoking and daily smoking, with increased quit intentions. However, these trends were reversed by the time of the GATS 3 in 2016, when both current smoking and daily smoking measures were higher, especially among females. Monthly cigarette expenses consistently increased across all survey years. Among youths, the overall prevalence increased sharply from 6.9% in 2003 to 23% in 2005, then decreased to 8.4% in 2009, again increased to 10.4% in 2012, and finally returned to 7.7% in 2017. Triangulation of these trends against the implementation of the loose cigarette ban in 2008 produced no clear association between the ban and smoking patterns. The overall marginal decline in smoking behaviors over two decades in Turkey needs to be fast-tracked, specifically the rise of smoking among the female population, which needs to be addressed through evidence-based tobacco control interventions. The loose cigarette ban was implemented as part of a comprehensive tobacco control law, and the GATS or GYTS data is not sufficient to assess the effect of this provision. The tobacco control effort in Turkey should collect evidence for changes in smoking patterns following the implementation of tobacco interventions, which is also a mandate of the Global Tobacco Surveillance System (GTSS).

Vibration suppression in SDOF systems coupled to a nonlinear energy sink under colored noise

This study analyzes the stochastic vibration suppression and optimization of the single-degree-of-freedom (SDOF) system equipped with the cubic stiffness nonlinear energy sink (NES) under colored noise excitation. Two theoretical methods are proposed: an integrated method (denoted as EL-ELM) that combines evolutionary Lyapunov theory with the equivalent linearization method, and the other is an empirical formula. Using EL-ELM, the coupled nonlinear system is simplified to an equivalent linear stochastic system, allowing for a theoretical analysis of the impact of NES structural parameters on suppression performance and the precise determination of optimal parameter configurations for the best suppression effects. Subsequently, based on the results from the EL-ELM and the response data, an empirical formula has been developed that clearly describes the comprehensive laws governing the optimal NES parameters as they vary with vibration system parameters and stochastic excitation. Through error analysis and comparison of the two methods, it is found that the empirical formula significantly outperforms EL-ELM in terms of accuracy and computational cost, but it is contingent on solid prior knowledge. This study explores the influence of NES structural parameters on the system’s dynamic response and energy, further validating the effectiveness of the proposed methods in identifying optimal structural parameters. The phenomenon of targeted energy transfer (TET) under different NES structural parameters is also explained. The methodologies introduced in this study have strengthened the theory of vibration suppression. Specifically, the empirical formula excels in accuracy and computational efficiency by effectively using prior knowledge. The EL-ELM method, owing to its theoretical insights, is vital for analyzing complex stochastic nonlinear models. Combining these approaches offers guidance for advancing vibration control in theoretical and practical domains.

Secondhand smoke exposure among adolescents in the gulf cooperation council countries: analysis of global youth tobacco surveys

This study aimed to analyze patterns and predictors of secondhand smoke (SHS) exposure among adolescents (12–16 years old) in Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates. Nationally representative data from the most recent Global Youth Tobacco Survey in each country were analyzed (N = 17,220). SHS exposure at home, in public places, and at school was assessed. Descriptive statistics summarized exposure prevalence overall and by sex. Multivariable logistic regression examined factors associated with each SHS exposure’s outcome. The results showed that SHS exposure was high overall, with exposure at home and school ranging from 12.7 to 20.7%, respectively, in Oman to 39.4% and 36.7%, respectively, in Kuwait. Almost half of the adolescents reported exposure to SHS in public places, with a prevalence of 40.8% in Saudi Arabia to 65.9% in Kuwait. The prevalence of exposure varied between countries, with the highest rates occurring in Kuwait. Girls had higher exposure at home, while boys had higher exposure in public and at school. Factors associated with higher exposure included parental smoking, friend smoking, and tobacco advertising. The belief that SHS is harmful was associated with lower home exposure. In conclusion, adolescents in the Gulf Cooperation Council countries are exposed to concerning levels of SHS, especially in public places. These findings underscore the urgent need for stronger tobacco control policies, including comprehensive smoke-free laws covering all public venues, to protect youth from SHS exposure. Additionally, the results support the development of targeted interventions promoting smoke-free homes and social norms against smoking.

Instrumental and legal nature of early release on parole from serving a sentence

The article is devoted to the study of the peculiarities of the content of early release on parole as a comprehensive criminal law remedy. It is stated that the functional purpose of conditional early release on parole from serving a sentence is to achieve the goals necessary for society. From the point of view of the instrumental theory of law, it is determined that early release on parole from serving a sentence constitutes a specific system of criminal law means by which the goals of criminal law regulation are achieved. According to the information and psychological orientation, such legal means are divided into stimulating and restrictive. It is found that legal facts, subjective rights, legitimate interests, benefits and incentives are the forms of manifestation of legal means-incentives. It is substantiated that legal incentives, directly orienting an individual to achieve beneficial consequences for him/her, are the most powerful incentive factor, and their application in the case of early release on parole from serving a sentence may be associated with both ordinary lawful behavior which does not exceed the general requirements and excessive performance of duties by a convicted person and is expressed in the form of elimination of restrictions determined by the criminal sentence applicable to a convicted person. The article emphasizes that legal remedies-restrictions are associated with unfavorable conditions for realization of interests of subjects, are focused on negative legal motivation and reduction of negative activity of subjects of law, and their forms of manifestation are legal facts, prohibitions, suspensions, legal obligations, penalties, etc. A legal restriction on early release on parole from serving a sentence is a prohibition in the form of a passive legal obligation of a convicted person not to commit any new criminal offense during the unexpired part of the previously imposed sentence. It is generalized that legal means-incentives and legal means-restrictions should be considered in an inseparable interrelation, since they are paired legal categories, i.e., internally dialectically interrelated and mutually supporting each other in the process of criminal law regulation. Thus, the author concludes that the instrumental and legal nature of early release on parole from serving a sentence as a complex criminal law tool is dialectically complex, since it combines directly opposite and at the same time internally unified criminal law means of influencing social relations.

A Study of Theoretical Justifications for Mandatory ESG Disclosure in Korea

The growing global focus on sustainable development and Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors necessitates robust disclosure legislation, including in South Korea, where corporate conglomerates, or chaebols, dominate the economy. This research underscores the critical need for comprehensive ESG disclosure laws, supported by Stakeholder Theory, Sustainability Theory, and Legitimacy Theory, within the Korean context. Stakeholder Theory emphasizes the accountability of chaebols to diverse groups beyond shareholders, advocating for transparent ESG practices that align with societal expectations. Sustainability Theory highlights the importance of aligning corporate actions with long-term national sustainability goals, such as Korea's Green New Deal, to enhance environmental and social resilience. Legitimacy Theory supports the notion that transparent ESG disclosures build local and global legitimacy, fostering trust and compliance with evolving standards. This study explores the intersection of these theories, demonstrating how mandatory ESG disclosures can enhance corporate governance, support sustainable business practices, and improve market competitiveness. By legislating comprehensive ESG disclosure requirements, Korea can ensure long-term value creation, stakeholder engagement, and alignment with global sustainability trends. This research provides a theoretical foundation for policy-makers, suggesting that robust ESG disclosure laws are essential for promoting transparency, accountability, and sustainable economic growth in Korea.

“Digital Personal Data Protection Act”—A Strudel Served Raw!

The good news is that personal data privacy law has become a reality in India. The bad news is 95% of the public is ignorant of the same, 3% do not know what it entails and the rest 2% are voraciously engaged in an intellectual feud. Privacy as a concomitant of natural or inalienable rights has been recognized in the western hemisphere since the 18th century. In India, the legislative history of the doctrine can be traced to the trilogy of cases during the 1950’s. It was only post 1978, that the apex court of the country passed a slew of judgements recognizing the right to privacy as an essential part of the right to “protection of life and personal liberty” embodied under the Indian Constitution and thereby bestowing the fundamental right status. On August 24, 2017, a nine-judge Constitution bench of the Supreme Court of India (Puttaswamy judgment) re-wrote history as it not only recognized and reconfirmed the fundamental right status of “ right to privacy” but also laid the foundation of data protection law in the country. August 11, 2023, marks a historic date in the legislative annals of digital India, as the country enacted the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (“DPDP Act” or “Act”) after more than half a decade of deliberations. At a time when technology has become the defining paradigm of every business, the DPDP Act seeks to lay the foundation for developing a strong data privacy regime in the country. The Act in its new avatar is quite different from its predecessors proposed earlier. Ironically, the regulations themselves have set ajar a host of challenges, issues and steeplechases, which can barely be fathomed at this moment. In addition, the DPDP Act is yet to be notified or implemented by the Central Government. The key question this paper discusses is whether this seemingly endless period of deliberations culminated into a robust and comprehensive law or is it simply a Strudel served raw! To answer this question, the paper first charts the history of the concept with a chronological approach on a global platform. The second part of the paper charts the pre-DPDP era in India. The third part recapitulates the DPDP Act (in the present form) in a nutshell, while the fourth part dissects the DPDP Act highlighting certain potentially problematic features of this law. Lastly, the paper will examine what can be done to influence the development of a robust and sustainable data protection regime in the country in the years to come. Keywords: Data Privacy, DPDP Act, Indian Privacy Law, Origin of Privacy Laws

Revitalizing municipal solid waste recycling: Review of current U.S. policies and potential directions for the circular economy

Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) recycling is a pivotal pillar in waste reduction and sustainable resource management. However, the United States (U.S.) is behind its schedule for the national recycling rate goal of 50% by 2030, which California is almost achieving. To this end, we review and compare the national and California recycling policies. Our analysis reveals that while there have been some positive changes toward sustainable waste management practices, significant gaps remain, particularly in the lack of a comprehensive national recycling law. The current federal allocation of funds has also been inadequate for achieving the national goal. Therefore, we identify policy options to grow toward a national policy and funding for recycling infrastructure and education. Using California as a model, we provide federal law options to balance recyclable supply and demand. These options are paired with future U.S. MSW policy and research directions.

Энергетика, экономика и право в Арктической зоне России

The article examines the correlation of interconnected areas: energy, economics and law. It was emphasized that energy resources for solving the strategic tasks of the state are effective areas for the development of economic activity in the Arctic zone of Russia. It is emphasized in the Arctic that the profit mechanism is associated with the production of hydrocarbons on the Arctic shelf. Important problems of the structure of the infrastructure complex and environmental protection during the extraction of minerals on the shelf by methods of new technologies are touched upon. It is justified that strategic directions as an economy and law should be combined to adopt a special legal regime for all subjects of the Arctic zone of Russia. An array of regulatory legal acts on economic activity in the Arctic has been investigated. It is proposed to adopt a comprehensive federal law for the development of the country’s economy in relation to raw materials energy.

RENEWABLE ENERGY DEVELOPMENT TOWARDS SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS: A REVIEW IN THAILAND AND THE PHILIPPINES’ LAWS AND POLICIES

Background and Purpose: Renewable energy (RE) plays a significant role in providing sustainable and clean energy as well as mitigating climate change. With the increased energy demand to support the growth of the economic sector, Thailand and the Philippines have moved towards improved energy cooperation, where renewable energy is an important subject matter in line with Target 7 of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Thailand and the Philippines have embarked on renewable energy projects and introduced numerous laws and policies to incentivise such an agenda. Nevertheless, the contribution of renewable energy in these countries' energy portfolios remains insignificant. Thus, this study aims to examine the current renewable energy laws and policies in Thailand and the Philippines, in assisting these countries to achieve the SDGs. Methodology: This study used a library-research methodology including statutory and conceptual approaches that focus on the laws and policies on renewable energy in Thailand and the Philippines. The utility of conceptual analysis is to understand the concepts and relevance of renewable energy and SDGs in the philosophies of environment, sustainability and law. Findings: Despite the fact RE provides opportunities in respect to socioeconomic development, energy access, energy security, and climate change mitigation, the existence of barriers to RE development leads to obstacles in accelerating RE’s share in the energy mix in Thailand and the Philippines. Comprehensive laws and policies to support renewable energy development are required to address these challenges. Nevertheless, legal frameworks are only one aspect that contributes to RE development. Governments' support through various incentives including financial and economic instruments are critical to navigating the transition toward a cleaner and affordable energy sector. Contributions: This study enhances the body of knowledge by examining the initiative for renewable energy development, advocating for comprehensive legal frameworks, and emphasizing the societal importance of government support to drive RE's role in sustainable development in Thailand and the Philippines. Keywords: Renewable energy, legal framework, policy, Thailand, Philippines. Cite as: Ghazali, F., Abdul Shukor, S. F., & Karim, R. (2024). Renewable energy development towards sustainable development goals: A review in Thailand and the Philippines’ laws and policies. Journal of Nusantara Studies, 9(2), 1-33. http://dx.doi.org/10.24200/jonus.vol9iss2pp1-33

Second-Hand Tobacco Smoke Exposure: Results of Particulate Matter (PM2.5) Measurements at Hospitality Venues in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

In Ethiopia, a comprehensive smoke-free law that bans smoking in all public areas has been implemented since 2019. This study aimed to evaluate compliance with these laws by measuring the air quality and conducting covert observations at 154 hospitality venues (HVs) in Addis Ababa. Indoor air quality was measured using Dylos air quality monitors during the peak hours of the venues, with concentrations of particulate matter <2.5 microns in diameter (PM2.5) used as a marker of second-hand tobacco smoke. A standardized checklist was used to assess compliance with smoke-free laws during the same peak hours. The average PM2.5 concentrations were classified as good, moderate, unhealthy for sensitive groups, unhealthy for all, or hazardous using the World Health Organization's (WHO) standard air quality index breakpoints. Only 23.6% of the venues complied with all smoke-free laws indicators. Additionally, cigarette and shisha smoking were observed at the HVs. Overall, 63.9% (95% confidence interval: 56-72%) of the HVs had PM2.5 concentrations greater than 15 µg/m3. The presence of more than one cigarette smoker in the venue, observing shisha equipment in the indoor space, and the sale of tobacco products in the indoor space were significantly associated with higher median PM2.5 concentration levels (p < 0.005). Hazardous level of PM2.5 concentrations-100 times greater than the WHO standard-were recorded at HVs where several people were smoking shisha and cigarettes. Most HVs had PM2.5 concentrations that exceeded the WHO average air quality standard. Stricter enforcement of smoke-free laws is necessary, particularly for bars and nightclubs/lounges.

Milestone of China's Foreign-Related Legislation – A Review of the Law of the People's Republic of China on Foreign Relations

The Law of the People's Republic of China on Foreign Relations is China's first foundational and comprehensive law in the field of foreign relations. This law promotes the rule of law both domestically and internationally in a coordinated manner, significantly enhancing the legal framework governing China's conduct of foreign affairs. It also makes substantial progress in the strategic development of foreign-related legislation, advancing the overall foreign-related legal system and integrity, quality and timeliness of specific legislation. Bearing distinct Chinese characteristics and reflecting the ethos of our era, this law stands as a milestone in the legislative history of China.

Compliance with tobacco advertising and promotion laws at points-of-sale in Ethiopia: an observational study in 10 cities

BackgroundEthiopia enacted a comprehensive tobacco control law in 2019, which bans tobacco advertising and promotion activities. However, compliance with these laws at points-of-sale (PoS) has not been studied, resulting in a lack of research evidence on how the regulations are implemented. The purpose of the study was to assess compliance with tobacco advertising and promotion laws at PoS in 10 cities in Ethiopia.MethodsMulti-stage cluster sampling was used to select 1468 PoS (supermarkets, minimarkets, merchandise stores, regular shops, permanent kiosks, khat shops, street vendors, and food and drink wholesalers). Data were collected using standardized observational checklists. Tobacco advertising and promotion indicators were used to compute indoor and outdoor compliance. Poisson regression models with log link function and robust variance were used to assess factors associated with open display of cigarette packages and indoor non-compliance.ResultsThe average indoor compliance rate was 92.9% (95% CI:92.3–93.5). Supermarkets had the highest compliance (99.7%), while permanent kiosks showed the lowest compliance (89.8%). The highest average indoor compliance was observed at PoS in Addis Ababa (98.0%). About 60% of PoS were fully compliant in indoors. Indoor open display of cigarette packages was prevalent (32.5%, 95% CI:30.0-35.1). The average outdoor compliance was 99.6% (95% CI:99.5–99.7). Outdoor full compliance was 96.5%. Open display of cigarettes was significantly higher in permanent kiosks (adjusted prevalence ratio (adjPR) 6.73; 95% CI: 3.96–11.42), regular shops (adjPR 5.16; 95% CI: 3.05–8.75), and khat shops (adjPR 2.06; 95% CI: 1.11–3.83), while indoor non-compliance was significantly higher in these same types of PoS.ConclusionsWhile outdoor compliance rates were relatively high, the lower indoor compliance rates particularly due to the high prevalence of open cigarette package displays indicates a major area for improvement in enforcing anti-tobacco advertising and promotion laws.