Dynamic ultrasound elastography is a method commonly used to quantify the mechanical parameters, such as shear elasticity modulus, and shear viscosity modulus, of biological tissues. Basically, the method employs four processing techniques, in order to estimate the mentioned parameters, denominated: phase velocity dispersion, PVD, attenuation-velocity, AV, complex shear elasticity modulus, CSM, and shear wave velocity, SV. The accuracy and precision of estimated values for and depend on the processing technique and the purpose of this paper is to compare the results obtained with PVD, AV, CSM and SV processing techniques by means of two cases: computer simulation and experiments. In the first case, the processing techniques were evaluated, via simulation, at different conditions for the signal-to-noise-ratio of the ultrasound RF echo signal used to probe the medium with vibrations due to the propagation of shear wave, the vibration amplitude and the viscoelastic properties of the medium itself. The corresponding results are expressed as the magnitudes of the mean and standard deviation of the relative error. In the second case, experiments were conducted based on a dynamic elastographic system with a cylindrical shear wave induced by a repetitive acoustic radiation force, with pulse repetition frequency of 50 Hz. A 4.98 MHz pulse-echo ultrasound system was used to probe the medium, a 3% gelatin phantom, traversed by the shear wave and the received RF echo signals were processed using the four techniques to yield the phantom values of and The results from computer simulation indicate that, in general, the CSM and AV techniques presented highest accuracy and precision. The experimental results obtained in this study are consistent with the values reported in the literature and the values of the shear elasticity modulus estimated by the four processing techniques did not differ significantly.
Read full abstract