In mammals, the germ line is essential for early folliculogenesis, and thus germ cell deficient animals fail to maintain ovarian differentiation. However, in teleosts, the roles of germ cells in the regulation of sex determination and differentiation are less well understood. Recent reports suggest that germ cell numbers influence ovary fate determination in zebrafish. Fish that lack germ cells or have only a single transplanted primordial germ cell (PGC) develop as phenotypic males. However, as sex determination and gonadal differentiation differ among teleost species, this phenomenon may be restricted to zebrafish or juvenile undifferentiated gonochoristic species. Here, we examined whether germ cells are necessary for gonadal differentiation in goldfish, a gonochoristic species that possesses XX-XY genetic sex determination. Our first step was to isolate the dead end (dnd) gene, which is necessary for the proper migration and survival of PGCs, and to design an anti-sense morpholino (MO) to this gene. Then, we compared germ cell development at 5 months in uninjected controls and in fish derived from embryos injected with dnd-MO at the 1-4 cell stage. In contrast to zebrafish, goldfish without germ cells developed either an ovary or a testis. Two types of gonad were identified: one was flat, wide and transparent, the other was narrow and string-like. Histological analysis showed the former to be an "empty ovary" with a clear ovarian cavity, while the latter was an "gempty testis" with a tubular structure. Thus, germ cells are not essential for gonadal fate determination in goldfish. In a subsequent experiment, we tested whether function was restored to these empty gonads in germline chimeras produced by transplanting a single PGC. Donor PGCs from embryos with an albino phenotype were labeled using gfp-nos1 3'UTR mRNA injected at the 1-4 cell stage. The embryos were enzymatically dissociated at the early somite stage and a single PGC was transplanted into each host embryo (wild type phenotype), which had been injected with dnd-MO. These germline chimeras developed either an ovary or a testis with a fully mature gonad on one side and an empty gonad on the other, showing the typical features of single PGC-transplanted chimeras. Cross breeding with male chimeric and female albino fish yielded 100% albino offspring, indicating that complete germ line replacement had occurred and the PGC-transplanted chimeras had recovered gonadal function. These findings suggest that, in goldfish, phenotypic sex is determined by somatic cells that express the relevant genes under genetic sex control rather than an interaction between germ cells and somatic cells. The generation of germline chimeras provides a valuable approach to investigating the contribution of germ cells to sex determination and differentiation, gonad formation and gametogenesis in teleosts, because of the ability to completely replace the germ line. (platform)
Read full abstract