The introduction of Cone Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT) into the alveolar bone grafting protocol now allows surgeons to look at pre- and postoperative bony structures to determine surgical success. Until recently, pre- and postoperative assessment have been determined by 2-dimensional (2D) periapical and panoramic radiographs. CBCTs can now be used to volumetrically assess defects. Yet to date, no scale has been standardized to classify alveolar bone grafting levels postoperatively to determine the success of the procedure. This study aims to analyze pre- and postoperative cone bean CBCT scans to determine if variables such as cleft size, canine position, and bone grafting material can help predict surgical outcomes. A total of 79 patients (average 10.4 years) with non-syndromic complete unilateral cleft lip and palate had been treated with ABG and bone morphogenetic protein-2 with demineralized bone matrix (BMP2/DBM) versus iliac crest bone (ICB) were compared. Preoperative CBCT scans (n = 27) were available to determine the cleft width. The postoperative CBCT was analyzed by the Bergland scale score. A novel method for categorizing canine eruption separated post-graft patients into 5 groups. The cleft width might be correlated with bone graft outcomes, but limited to the sample size, with no statistical significance (n = 27, R2 = 0.378, P > .05). In total, 21 (26.6%) patients have supernumerary or impacted teeth in the cleft, but not related to bone graft outcomes. There is no statistical difference between the 4 surgeons’ cleft repair. The 2D modalities traditionally used to interpret SABG results possess inherent limitations of structure overlapping and distortion of the relationship of anatomy. Since the advent of the CBCT, 3D volumetric analysis has largely accounted for these errors. Yet to date, no scale standardized to the CBCT has been developed to assess SABG results.The authors' results suggest that graft outcomes correlate with pre-graft canine positions. An unerupted, high permanent canine vertical position will yield poor results, likely due to previously documented growth-inhibiting scarring of soft tissue, and the ideal timing of SABG may be when two-thirds of the canine crown is located below the palatal plane with the adjacent premolars not fully erupted. This may be due to the optimal timing for the canine to complete its eruption into the grafting site to influence the maintenance of the graft and periodontal support of the adjacent teeth. In a patient with complete unilateral cleft lip and palate, iliac crest bone graft tended to have better graft outcomes than BMP2/DBM in this sample. This may be attributed to BMP2/DBM's osteoconductive properties vs. ICB's osteogenic, osteoinductive, and osteoconductive properties. There was no evidence that cleft width correlates with the grafting outcome. However, results were limited to sample size.
Read full abstract