Transparent crystalline scintillators such as cerium-doped YAG or LuAG are widely used in X-ray imaging for the indirect detection of X-rays. The application of reflective coatings on the front side to improve the optical gain is common practice for flat panel detectors with CsI or Gd2O2S powder scintillators but still largely unknown for crystalline scintillators such as LuAG. This work shows experimentally and quantitatively how a black and reflective coating on the X-ray side of a 2 mm LuAG:Ce scintillator improves the image quality compared to a 2 mm LuAG:Ce scintillator without a coating. The measurements have been done for two different distances, with 2 m and 29.7 m on the BM18 beamline of the European Synchrotron. The Modulation Transfer Function (MTF) and the Signal-to-Noise-Ratio (SNR2) power spectrum as well as contrast-to-noise ratio are used for comparing image quality. Propagation-based phase contrast strongly enhances the SNR2 amplitudes (gain ≈10 from 2 m to 29.7 m object-detector distance) of the raw images’ spectrum independent of the scintillator coating. For both detector positions, the reflective coating is able to raise SNR2 by up to 80% through the improved optical gain, while black coating does the opposite (decrease SNR2 by 20%) with respect to no coating. With the tested optical setups, changes in MTF /sharpness between the coatings are minor. Comparing CNR2 in CT scans of a multi-material sample, in this case an electric motor, we observe the reflective coating yielding better material contrast for plastic and air. Application and effect of Wiener-deconvolution, along with Paganin-type phase retrieval, are also discussed in the context of CT image quality.