We study the relative effectiveness of two multi-unit forces, A and B, fighting a successive series of duels between randomly selected pairs of opposing units. A duel consists of a series of games - each of at most s units of time - and the duel terminates as soon as one of the two duelists is hit. A new independent duel then starts, and so on. Each force is characterized by a common probability distribution function representing the time required by a single unit of the force to hit a non-firing unit of the other force in a game of unbounded duration. The relative effectiveness of force A with respect to force B is expressed by the exchange rateR(s), defined as the expected number of units of force B hit by a single unit of force A until unit A itself is hit. We derive a general characterization of R{s) and develop analytic results for several choices of pairs of families of time-to-hit distributions. We show that the shape of the distributions can strongly affect the outcome of the duels and that this e...