Combinatorial Histone Codes Research Articles

Expeditious Extraction of Histones from Limited Cells or Tissue Samples and Quantitative Top-Down Proteomic Analysis.

Histones are the primary protein component of chromatin and are involved in virtually all DNA-templated processes. Histones are abundantly post-translationally modified by a variety of chromatin-modifying machinery. These post-translational modifications (PTMs) are recognized by a range of "reader" proteins, which recruit additional proteins to specific locations on chromatin and impart precise and powerful effects on gene regulation. Each PTM typically exerts a positive or negative effect on transcription, and recent studies have shown that histone PTMs function in a combinatorial histone code: that is, histone PTMs function in combination to exert precise DNA-templated regulation. Thus, there is a need to identify and understand proteoforms, or unambiguously defined single protein molecules with all combinations of modifications. Top-down proteomics is currently the only viable approach for identifying and quantitating histone proteoforms, and mass spectrometry instruments have become sufficiently powerful to perform these quantitative analyses in a robust and high-throughput fashion. These recent innovations have enabled new experimental directions in chromatin research but have also introduced temporal and other constraints. This has led us to develop the protocols described here, which increase throughput, reduce sample requirements, and maintain robust quantitation. Although originally designed for high-throughput quantitative top-down proteomics, the protocols described here are useful for a wide range of chromatin biology applications. Starting with small amounts of cells or tissue, we describe two basic protocols for exceptionally rapid and efficient nuclei isolation, acid extraction of histones, and high-performance liquid chromatography fractionation of histones into histone families. We additionally describe the quantitative top-down proteomic analysis of histone H4 proteoforms. © 2021 Wiley Periodicals LLC. Basic Protocol 1: Nuclei isolation and acid extraction of histones from mammalian cells in culture/tissues Basic Protocol 2: HPLC fractionation of histones and histone H4 HPLC-MS/MS Support Protocol: Preparation of intact H3 histone tails by Glu-C digestion.

A mass spectrometry-based assay using metabolic labeling to rapidly monitor chromatin accessibility of modified histone proteins

Histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) contribute to chromatin accessibility due to their chemical properties and their ability to recruit enzymes responsible for DNA readout and chromatin remodeling. To date, more than 400 different histone PTMs and thousands of combinations of PTMs have been identified, the vast majority with still unknown biological function. Identification and quantification of histone PTMs has become routine in mass spectrometry (MS) but, since raising antibodies for each PTM in a study can be prohibitive, lots of potential is lost from MS datasets when uncharacterized PTMs are found to be significantly regulated. We developed an assay that uses metabolic labeling and MS to associate chromatin accessibility with histone PTMs and their combinations. The labeling is achieved by spiking in the cell media a 5x concentration of stable isotope labeled arginine and allow cells to grow for at least one cell cycle. We quantified the labeling incorporation of about 200 histone peptides with a proteomics workflow, and we confirmed that peptides carrying PTMs with extensively characterized roles in active transcription or gene silencing were in highly or poorly labeled forms, respectively. Data were further validated using next-generation sequencing to assess the transcription rate of chromatin regions modified with five selected PTMs. Furthermore, we quantified the labeling rate of peptides carrying co-existing PTMs, proving that this method is suitable for combinatorial PTMs. We focus on the abundant bivalent mark H3K27me3K36me2, showing that H3K27me3 dominantly represses histone swapping rate even in the presence of the more permissive PTM H3K36me2. Together, we envision this method will help to generate hypotheses regarding histone PTM functions and, potentially, elucidate the role of combinatorial histone codes.

Sensitive and Precise Characterization of Combinatorial Histone Modifications by Selective Derivatization Coupled with RPLC-EThcD-MS/MS.

Deciphering the combinatorial histone codes has been a long-standing interest in the epigenetics field, which requires the reliable and robust characterization of the post-translational modifications (PTMs) coexisting on histones. To this end, weak cation exchange hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography is commonly used in middle-down liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry approaches for online separation of variously modified histone peptides. Here we provide a novel strategy that combines the selective histone peptide derivatization using N-hydroxysuccinimide propionate ester with reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) for the robust, sensitive, and reliable characterization of combinatorial histone PTMs. Derivatization amplifies the subtle physical differences between similarly modified histone peptides, thereby allowing baseline separation of these peptides by standard RPLC. Also, the sensitivity of MS is enhanced greatly by derivatization due to the increased peptide hydrophobicity and concentrated charge-state envelope during electrospray ionization. Furthermore, we systematically optimized the dual electron transfer and higher energy collision dissociation and achieved near-complete peptide sequence coverage in MS/MS spectra, allowing highly precise and reliable PTM identification. Using this method, we identified 311 and 293 combinations of histone H3 PTMs from the lymphoma cells Karpas-422 with/without drug treatment, confirming the advantages of our method in serving as a platform for profiling combinatorial histone PTMs.

An integrative approach to understanding the combinatorial histone code at functional elements

The rapid advancement of genomic technology has revealed the enormous complexity and combinatorial nature of chromatin modifications. To facilitate interpretation of the combinatorial nature of chromatin, we have developed a novel method to integrate all chromatin datasets into distinct nucleosome types (nucleosome alphabet). We have applied this approach to Saccharomyces cerevisiae, generating a nucleosome alphabet, which forms chromatin motifs when mapped back to the genome. By applying novel chromatin alignment and global word search approaches, we have defined distinctive chromatin motifs for introns, origins of replication, tRNAs, antisense transcripts, double-strand-break hotspots and DNase hypersensitive sites, and can distinguish genes by expression level. We have also uncovered strong associations between transcription factor binding and specific types of nucleosomes. Our results demonstrate the uses and functionality of defining a chromatin alphabet and provide a unique and novel framework for exploring chromatin architecture. mjbuck@buffalo.edu Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Quantitative proteomic tools for analyzing histone modifications

Histones are small proteins that package DNA into chromosomes, and a large number of studies have showed that several single post-translational modification sites on the histones are associated with both gene activation and silencing. Nevertheless, what type of effect distinct combinations of simultaneously occuring histone modifications (Histone Codes or patterns) have upon cellular events is poorly understood. The main reason for this lack of knowledge is that robust high-throughput methods for quantitative characterization or even qualitative identification of combinatorial Histone Codes by any standard biological, immunological or physical technique do not exist. We plan to specifically address this deficiency by developing novel mass spectrometry based proteomic methods and accompanying bioinformatics to quantitatively characterize molecular level descriptions of combinatorial Histone Codes, and apply these methods to study how these dynamic Histone Codes influence gene expression under different biological conditions. Here we present initial proteomics data that describes: (i) high-throughput comparison of histone modifications from multiple cellular states (ii) developing mass spectrometry methods for quantitative tracking of combinatorial Histone Codes (iii) monitoring in vivo Histone Code dynamics, and (iv) investigating the role of Histone Code interpreting proteins in recognizing distinct Histone Codes. Ultimately, we will work towards the goal of taking any defined part of the genome and accurately quantifying the Histone Codes, detecting all the non-histone proteins that reside on these distinct pieces of chromatin, and then mapping this proteomic data back to specific genomic locations, therefore taking a proteomic snapshot of what that chromosome landscape looks like during any nuclear event. These studies in combination with biological experiments will help provide a systems biology outlook on gene expression that will lay down the basic scientific foundation to advance several applications, such as stem cell reprogramming and cancer progression.

Finding combinatorial histone code by semi-supervised biclustering

BackgroundCombinatorial histone modification is an important epigenetic mechanism for regulating chromatin state and gene expression. Given the rapid accumulation of genome-wide histone modification maps, there is a pressing need for computational methods capable of joint analysis of multiple maps to reveal combinatorial modification patterns.ResultsWe present the Semi-Supervised Coherent and Shifted Bicluster Identification algorithm (SS-CoSBI). It uses prior knowledge of combinatorial histone modifications to guide the biclustering process. Specifically, co-occurrence frequencies of histone modifications characterized by mass spectrometry are used as probabilistic priors to adjust the similarity measure in the biclustering process. Using a high-quality set of transcriptional enhancers and associated histone marks, we demonstrate that SS-CoSBI outperforms its predecessor by finding histone modification and genomic locus biclusters with higher enrichment of enhancers. We apply SS-CoSBI to identify multiple cell-type-specific combinatorial histone modification states associated with human enhancers. We show enhancer histone modification states are correlated with the expression of nearby genes. Further, we find that enhancers with the histone mark H3K4me1 have higher levels of DNA methylation and decreased expression of nearby genes, suggesting a functional interplay between H3K4me1 and DNA methylation that can modulate enhancer activities.ConclusionsThe analysis presented here provides a systematic characterization of combinatorial histone codes of enhancers across three human cell types using a novel semi-supervised biclustering algorithm. As epigenomic maps accumulate, SS-CoSBI will become increasingly useful for understanding combinatorial chromatin modifications by taking advantage of existing knowledge.Availability and implementationSS-CoSBI is implemented in C. The source code is freely available at http://www.healthcare.uiowa.edu/labs/tan/SS-CoSBI.gz.

Antibody recognition of histone post-translational modifications: emerging issues and future prospects

Antibody recognition of histone post-translational modifications: emerging issues and future prospects

The significance, development and progress of high-throughput combinatorial histone code analysis.

The physiological state of eukaryotic DNA is chromatin. Nucleosomes, which consist of DNA in complex with histones, are the fundamental unit of chromatin. The post-translational modifications (PTMs) of histones play a critical role in the control of gene transcription, epigenetics and other DNA-templated processes. It has been known for several years that these PTMs function in concert to allow for the storage and transduction of highly specific signals through combinations of modifications. This code, the combinatorial histone code, functions much like a bar code or combination lock providing the potential for massive information content. The capacity to directly measure these combinatorial histone codes has mostly been laborious and challenging, thus limiting efforts often to one or two samples. Recently, progress has been made in determining such information quickly, quantitatively and sensitively. Here we review both the historical and recent progress toward routine and rapid combinatorial histone code analysis.

Quantitative Proteomics for Analyzing the Histone Code

Several single histone modifications are associated with both gene activation and silencing, but what type of effect distinct combinations of simultaneously occurring histone modifications (Histone Codes or patterns) have upon cellular events is poorly understood. Additionally, most recent research describes histone modifications as static events. The main reason for this lack of knowledge is that techniques for quantitative characterization or even qualitative identification of combinatorial Histone Codes in dynamic fashion by any method do not readily exist. We have specifically addressed this deficiency by developing novel mass spectrometry based methods for rapid comparison of dynamically changing histone modifications from multiple cellular states including quantitative tracking of hundreds of combinatorial Histone Codes in a single experiment. These studies in combination with biological experiments will help provide a systems‐wide outlook that will lay down the basic scientific foundation to advance several areas of chromatin biology.

High Throughput Characterization of Combinatorial Histone Codes

We present a novel method utilizing "saltless" pH gradient weak cation exchange-hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography directly coupled to electron transfer dissociation (ETD) mass spectrometry for the automated on-line high throughput characterization of hypermodified combinatorial histone codes. This technique, performed on a low resolution mass spectrometer, displays an improvement over existing methods with an approximately 100-fold reduction in sample requirements and analysis time. The scheme presented is capable of identifying all of the major combinatorial histone codes present in a sample in a 2-h analysis. The large N-terminal histone peptides are eluted by the pH and organic solvent weak cation exchange-hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography gradient and directly introduced via nanoelectrospray ionization into a benchtop linear quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer equipped with ETD. Each polypeptide is sequenced, and the modification sites are identified by ETD fragmentation. The isobaric trimethyl and acetyl modifications are resolved chromatographically and confidently distinguished by the synthesis of mass spectrometric and chromatographic information. We demonstrate the utility of the method by complete characterization of human histone H3.2 and histone H4 from butyrate-treated cells, but it is generally applicable to the analysis of highly modified peptides. We find this methodology very useful for chromatographic separation of isomeric species that cannot be separated well by any other chromatographic means, leading to less complicated tandem mass spectra. The improved separation and increased sensitivity generated novel information about much less abundant forms. In this method demonstration we report over 200 H3.2 forms and 70 H4 forms, including forms not yet detected in human cells, such as the remarkably highly modified histone H3.2 K4me3K9acK14acK18acK23acK27acK36me3. Such detail provided by our proteomics platform will be essential for determining how histone modifications occur and act in combination to propagate the histone code during transcriptional events and could greatly enable sequencing of the histone component of human epigenomes.

Deciphering the combinatorial histone code

A new mass spectrometry (MS) approach has been developed, allowing combinatorial analysis of histone H3.2 post-translational modifications that may provide the key to unlocking the histone code.

Distinct regulation of histone H3 methylation at lysines 27 and 9 by CpG methylation in Arabidopsis

Transcriptional activity and structure of chromatin are correlated with patterns of covalent DNA and histone modification. Previous studies have revealed that high levels of histone H3 dimethylation at lysine 9 (H3K9me2), characteristic of transcriptionally silent heterochromatin in Arabidopsis, require hypermethylation of DNA at CpG sites. Here, we report that CpG hypermethylation characteristic of heterochromatin specifically prevented H3K27 trimethylation (H3K27me3). H3K27 mono- and dimethylation mark silent heterochromatin independently of DNA methylation. Upon loss of CpG methylation, there was target-specific enrichment of H3K27me3 in heterochromatin that correlated with transcriptional reactivation. Moreover, using the kyp mutant affected in H3K9me2, we showed that changes in H3K27me3 occurred independently of the levels of H3K9me2. Therefore, CpG methylation provides distinct and direct information for a specific subset of histone methylation marks. The observed independence of the regulation of H3K9 and H3K27 methylation by CpG methylation refines the recently proposed combinatorial histone code involving these two marks.

Dual histone H3 methylation marks at lysines 9 and 27 required for interaction with CHROMOMETHYLASE3.

Both DNA methylation and post-translational histone modifications contribute to gene silencing, but the mechanistic relationship between these epigenetic marks is unclear. Mutations in two Arabidopsis genes, the KRYPTONITE (KYP) histone H3 lysine 9 (H3K9) methyltransferase and the CHROMOMETHYLASE3 (CMT3) DNA methyltransferase, cause a reduction of CNG DNA methylation, suggesting that H3K9 methylation controls CNG DNA methylation. Here we show that the chromodomain of CMT3 can directly interact with the N-terminal tail of histone H3, but only when it is simultaneously methylated at both the H3K9 and H3K27 positions. Furthermore, using chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis and immunohistolocalization experiments, we found that H3K27 methylation colocalizes with H3K9 methylation at CMT3-controlled loci. The H3K27 methylation present at heterochromatin was not affected by mutations in KYP or in several Arabidopsis PcG related genes including the Enhancer of Zeste homologs, suggesting that a novel pathway controls heterochromatic H3K27 methylation. Our results suggest a model in which H3K9 methylation by KYP, and H3K27 methylation by an unknown enzyme provide a combinatorial histone code for the recruitment of CMT3 to silent loci.