Between the 1860s and 1960s, sixteen colonie penali agricole were built in Italy, half of them on the island of Sardinia. As the tangible instances of a geopolitical project that intertwined penal and land reforms during a century of striking shifts in political regimes, they can be read as sites of intersecting colonialisms where domestic colonialism — in line with Barbara Arneil’s reading — mixed over time with elements of internal self-colonisation and settler colonialism. This essay provides a spatial analysis of the Sardinian agricultural penal colonies, framing them within similar experiences of domestic labour colonies in Europe: the 1840 penal colony at Mettray and the 1820s Dutch ‘Colonies of Benevolence’. It will elaborate on the role that large-scale spatial reasoning played at crucial moments of political transition in Italy. Borrowing from Gary Field’s insights, it will show how they were designed as germinal ‘institutions of dispossession’ set to accelerate what local historian Gian Giacomo Ortu calls the ‘ideological and moral offensive against feudalism, commonality and pastoralism’ in Sardinia. It will further discuss their impact in reshaping this rural domain in relation with the wider civilian agrarian plans of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries: Internal Colonisation, Fascist Plans of Reclamation and Repopulation, and post-war Agrarian Reform.
Read full abstract