Collective Case Study Research Articles

Check, Please! Supervisor-Learner Dyads Using "Checking" for Clinical Support During Indirect Supervision.

Indirect supervision is essential for granting autonomy to learners. Sometimes referred to as leaving the learner "unsupervised," there is growing recognition that learners and supervisors engage in clinical support through ongoing interactions, albeit at a distance. To understand how the complementary activities of asking for and providing clinical support at a distance come together as indirect supervision by identifying the natural language used between learners and supervisors. A collective case study of 15 attending physician-senior medical resident dyads from 2018 to 2023. Each case consisted of 2 full days of ethnographic observation of the resident on an internal medicine clinical teaching unit in one of three metropolitan hospitals; 2 end of day interviews with each dyad member; and a third interview with the attending after the 2-week rotation. Fifteen internal medicine residents (PGY-2 and PGY-3) who were scheduled to work for the first time with 15 attending physicians. Data collection was iterative with deductive and inductive analysis to identify patterns of communication. The language of "checking," such as checkpoints, checking on, and checking in, was central to communications within dyads. Indirect supervision included attendings using scheduled checkpoints and backstage oversight activities to check on the senior resident's patient care while expecting residents to access their support, as needed, by checking-in with them. Residents checked in with their attending to relay patient information updates, ask questions, and hint at needing their plans doublechecked; these communications had similar formats making them difficult to distinguish but functioned to preserve resident independence while accessing clinical support. Indirect supervision creates clinical support through ongoing communication between learners and supervisors at a distance. It is a collaborative process for mutual reassurance that safe patient care is being provided and that support is available when needed.

Using reflection and dialog feedback to promote the development of situated and dynamic pedagogical content knowledge

This study explores the reflection and dialog feedback of preservice teachers (PTs) in a one-semester chemistry teaching design and practice course with the aim of improving their situated and dynamic pedagogical content knowledge (PCK). Using a collective case study method, reflections and dialogs from 18 PTs across six teaching cycles were analyzed. The research results indicate that teaching reflection focuses on five themes: the diversity of student situations, the functionality of teaching contexts, the consistency of teaching content, the construction of teacher‒student dialog, and the progression of subject practice activities. The reflection of the PTs strengthened meaningful teaching content and corresponding specific skills, and effective dialog feedback provided external evaluation standards. The reflection prompted teachers to evaluate from multiple perspectives and levels and provided important insights to promote the development of situated and dynamic PCK. This study concludes with a discussion of the practical implications and potential for future research to develop a situated and dynamic PCK for PTs.

Students' Meaning‐Making of Nature of Science: Interaction Between Visual, Verbal, and Written Modes of Representation

ABSTRACTStudents' understanding of nature of science (NOS) has been largely examined primarily in written or verbal modes. The visual, verbal, and written modes are essential for students' meaning‐making of NOS. However, research has sidelined the interaction among these three modes in understanding students' collaborative discourse of NOS. Informed by theories of multimodality and social semiotics, this paper investigates the interactions between the visual, verbal, and written modes as groups of students engaged in explicit‐reflective multimodal representation during NOS instruction. Utilizing a collective case study approach, we planned NOS instruction with teachers, and videotaped how each focal group of students in two grade seven classes in Hong Kong constructed multimodal representations of NOS. Multimodal discourse analysis revealed that the three modes fulfill various purposes during students' co‐construction of multimodal representations of NOS. The interaction between the three modes facilitates meaning‐making of NOS in four ways: (a) students' re‐semiotization of discursive scientific practices into their multimodal ensembles; (b) bridging students' writing of scientific reports to scientists' social certification and dissemination; (c) connecting students' decontextualized meaning‐making to contextualized meaning‐making of methods and methodological rules; and (d) facilitating students' embodied semiosis in social organizations and interactions of science. Focusing on four episodes of co‐constructing multimodal representations of NOS, we illustrate how students' meaning‐making of NOS is multimodal in nature and how various modes have their own affordances. We discuss future research directions on how multimodality can facilitate students' meaning‐making of NOS.

Navigating sustainability and resilience: a collective case study of four indian communities

Navigating sustainability and resilience: a collective case study of four indian communities

How Parenting Facilitates Adolescents’ Tricultural Identity Development: A Mixed Methods Collective Case Study of Tridimensionally Acculturating Black Jamaican Immigrant Families

This article presents a mixed methods collective case study of the role of maternal socialization in shaping the tricultural identity development of Jamaican immigrant adolescents in the United States, who are known to acculturate tridimensionally. Seven Black adolescents (14–18 years; four male) completed online surveys and their Jamaican-born mothers completed online interviews during the dual COVID-19 and Whiteness pandemics. In-depth mixed methods case analyses and cross-case comparisons revealed both particulars and universals. Across all cases, adolescents had strong Jamaican private identities shaped by steady proximal and remote enculturation into Jamaican culture, and mothers’ skillful authoritative parenting supported their autonomy in acquiring and navigating U.S. cultural affiliations. Case particulars grouped adolescents into four profiles with one case fitting two profiles. 1) “Triculturals” had strong Jamaican or multicultural socialization with positive psychological and academic adaptation, but differing multicultural identity conflict. 2) “Reluctant Majority Culture Assimilators” had high achievement but differing psychological adaptation with mothers whose socialization first involved accepting their teens’ African American identities. 3) “Majority Culture Rejectors” had high belonging and no psychological distress but low average grades with maternal socialization that promoted the American Dream master narrative and resisted the alternative narrative of negative linked fate of ethnic minorities. 4) Finally, “Minority Culture Assimilators” had low multicultural identity conflict but differing psychological and academic adaptation and were being socialized by their mothers to resist being either victim or perpetrator of racial discrimination by harnessing cultural variability to play up and play down cultural identities and by avoiding use of ethnic-racial generalizations.

The troublesome nature of learning to teach critical thinking: Using Threshold Concepts Theory to support Teacher Education

Teaching critical thinking is fundamental for students’ academic success and helps to equip them for life after university. There are some studies which discuss teachers’ perceptions of the barriers regarding the teaching of critical thinking. However, more empirical evidence is needed about the actual challenges which educators experience when learning to teach it. Using the lens of threshold concepts theory, this small-scale collective case study examines the barriers encountered by 14 HE educators in the UK, as they experimented with teaching critical thinking in their disciplinary contexts. Educators identified the troublesome and transformative nature of learning to do so experienced through shortcomings in curricula, learning environment and ways of thinking and practising. These findings suggest that the process of learning to teach critical thinking could be a threshold concept of higher education which supports educators to think differently about how to teach this subject. It provides initial considerations for professional development programmes and resources to support educators to overcome their barriers and learn to teach criticality within their disciplines.

Barriers to Change: A Collective Case Study of Four Universities’ Efforts to Advance Faculty Diversity and Inclusion

Barriers to Change: A Collective Case Study of Four Universities’ Efforts to Advance Faculty Diversity and Inclusion

Opening doors to coach education in masters sport for lifelong sport participation

ABSTRACT Coach education directors of sport organizations are responsible for developing coaches to support quality sport participation. While adults comprise an increasingly larger cohort in many sport organizations, their programming, including coaching and coach education, is marginalized. The purpose of this collective case study was to outline directors’ perceptions of challenges and interests regarding lifelong sport participation through their perspectives of adult-oriented professional development for coaches in their sport organizations. Five directors of coach education attended webinars on coaching Masters sport and then engaged in follow-up interviews. Data were reflexively thematically analyzed. The results indicated that directors acknowledge differences in coaching adults and youth but a coaching focus on youth and high performance. They discussed the benefits of supporting Masters sport through quality coaching for lifelong sport participation and valued adult-oriented coaching approaches. Lifelong sport pathways could advance with shifts toward supporting Masters sport with quality coach education.

Design of a reverse logistics network for medical waste considering location and routing decisions

Medical waste generated in healthcare facilities is categorized as hazardous due to its infectious, toxic, or radioactive properties, posing substantial risks to human health and the environment. This research proposes a bi-objective Mixed-Integer Linear Programming model for designing reverse logistics networks that enable both economical and safe medical waste management. Said model determines optimal quantity, depot locations, and routes for transporting waste from its generating points (hospitals) to the treatment and disposal sites (depots).This research addresses a bi-objective location routing problem, with multiple depots, time windows, capacity constraints, and variated waste types, across a multi-period horizon. It is innovative because no previous works have successfully dealt with such a combination of pragmatic features. The Location Routing Problem is an already well-known NP-Hard problem, with the additional aforementioned features further adding to its complexity. Thus, a genetic algorithm to solve large-sized realistic instances within reasonable computing times had been developed.Numerical experiments considered 20 random instances contrasting exact and approximate solution approaches. Also, a medical waste collection case study of a public hospital network in Atlántico Department, Colombia, delivering a Pareto frontier solution set, was introduced. The results demonstrated the efficacy of the proposed genetic algorithm in successfully addressing small instances of the problem, delivering outcomes comparable to the Mixed-Integer Linear Programming model. Furthermore, it yields good-quality solutions in a reduced computational time for larger instances deemed unfeasible for the Mixed-Integer Linear Programming model.This article contributes to both scientific literature and practitioners by presenting a decision-making tool designed to address the medical waste reverse logistics challenge under realistic scenarios. It approaches the issue from a bi-objective standpoint, jointly considering economic factors and biomedical safety. Additionally, the article introduces realistic and pertinent assumptions that have not been explored in previous literature.

English-medium teachers as policymakers through critical translingual literacy instruction

AbstractMany classrooms include students who use multiple languages other than the school-sanctioned or teacher’s language(s). This study asks how English-medium teachers develop language ideologies that support critical translingual literacy instruction. Using a collective case study, we ask how five English-medium teachers in a U.S. graduate course name and act on their language ideologies through literacy instruction. The cross-case analysis indicates the teachers’ language ideologies viewed students’ L1 use as a source of pride/identity and as a way to promote equity and social justice. These ideologies supported critical translingual literacy instruction through classroom actions (incorporating new texts, initiating family engagement, and positioning students as experts). Implications illustrate the need for literacy teacher education to focus on language ideologies, using literacy instruction as a powerful vehicle to effect language policy. Thus, focusing on critical translingual literacy instruction can support English-medium teachers to act as both literacy and language policymakers.

Investigating Preservice Teachers’ Conceptualizations of Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching Through Video Analysis

Mathematics Preservice Teachers’ (M-PSTs) conceptions of Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching (MKT) enhance their reflective skills because they utilize such conceptions to reflect on how to contextualize content knowledge during secondary mathematics teaching. While previous studies suggested M-PSTs develop MKT, including pedagogical content knowledge by analyzing teaching in video lessons, how M-PSTs enhance their conceptions of MKT through such analysis is underexplored. I used a collective case study approach to investigate how four secondary M-PSTs conceptualized MKT when they analyzed and discussed teaching represented in a video lesson using the MKT framework. The findings indicated that the M-PSTs often described teacher knowledge either as purely pedagogical or solely content knowledge in their initial analyses of the video lesson. After engaging in a discussion that introduced the MKT framework, the M-PSTs began to illustrate how a teacher’s content knowledge influenced her instructional decisions and actions. Through this discussion, M-PSTs began identifying MKT as professional content knowledge unique to teaching and, thus, distinguished MKT from generic pedagogical or content knowledge. I argue that the language and concepts offered through the framework enhanced the M-PSTs’ conceptions of MKT and suggest that the instructional activities from this study contribute to developing M-PSTs as reflective practitioners.

AI in the newsroom: a collective case study about newsworker-AI collaboration in the German newspaper industry

ABSTRACT The adoption of AI in newsrooms can fundamentally change journalistic processes. Nowadays, AI is increasingly able to fulfil journalistic tasks, evolving the roles and interaction of newsworkers and AI. Given its high impact, the question arises how AI and newsworkers can collaborate productively in the newsroom to maintain or even improve journalistic quality. This study analyses newsworker-AI collaboration at four German newspaper publishers through the lens of Human-Machine Communication (HMC). Based on the data, a model for the evaluation of newsworker-AI collaboration is developed and validated. The results show that the interaction intensity between newsworkers and AI as well as the creation of knowledge in the newsroom can be identified as relevant evaluation criteria for newsworker-AI collaboration.

Strategic and Tactical Marketing Strategies for Regional Public Universities to Address the Enrollment Cliff

ABSTRACT This qualitative collective case study, framed by resource dependence theory, explored strategic and tactical marketing strategies perceived to be important in addressing the predicted decrease in enrollments in 2025–2037, described as the enrollment cliff, facing higher education institutions in the U.S. The study settings were regional public universities in the Southeast U.S. Participants were a purposeful sample of 15 chief marketing officers from these institutions. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews, document analysis, and field notes. Data were analyzed using Creswell and Poth’s data analysis spiral. The strategies identified included brand positioning, targeting specific student populations, cultivating new audiences, and utilizing additional marketing tools and testing their impact. The findings highlighted ways that marketing could mitigate enrollment declines. These include emphasizing brand positioning, targeting specific student populations, cultivating new audiences, and utilizing a number of marketing tools in an effective marketing mix to help address the predicted enrollment declines.

Principals’ sense-making and sense-giving of their professional role tensions: School leaders’ professionalism and creative mediation strategies during Covid-19 crisis

School principals are located at the interface between competing demands by a wide spectrum of stakeholders leading to tensions and ambiguities in their role. Understanding principals’ role tensions within organizational and occupational professionalism during Covid-19 crisis is of considerable importance for improving the capacity of school leadership. This qualitative study examines Israeli principals’ considerations and creative mediation strategies while facing competing accountabilities via the theoretical framework of sense-making and sense-giving in times of crisis. Using a collective case study design, data were collected via semi-structured interviews with 16 elementary and high school principals and policy documents, and analyzed thematically via ATLAS.ti software. The analysis surfaced three strategies and two considerations: (1) school leaders’ sense-making processes yielding protective mediation strategies based on retaining moral discretion; and (2) school leaders’ sense-giving processes transferring collaborative and contrived mediation strategies based on establishing the school's moral-professional cultural orientation. The contribution of this study to the research literature suggests contrived mediation as an innovative school leaders’ strategy. We provide practical implications within training and professional development programs for school leaders advocating principalship mentoring valuing uniqueness to experienced and novice principals.

Exploring Cross-Cultural Teacher Perspectives on Student Engagement in Virtual Learning Environments During The COVID-19 Pandemic

The rapid transition to emergency remote teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic posed challenges for teachers, students, and higher education institutions, impacting students' learning and engagement in the learning process. Based on Self-Determination Theory, this paper employs a collective case study research methodology to examine teachers' strategies for supporting students' learning and engagement in virtual learning environments during emergency remote teaching in the pandemic era, with the goal of offering guidelines to assist teachers in fostering student learning and engagement in these virtual settings. The inductive thematic analysis of eight semi-structured interviews with teachers from Spain, Oman, Nigeria and Cambodia revealed some challenges faced by teachers in engaging their students in virtual environments and some teaching and support strategies that teachers adopted to enhance students’ engagement in virtual classrooms. The study synthesised a set of strategies for teachers in higher education to support students’ engagement and learning in online environments. Teachers’ autonomy, structure and involvement support strategies had a behavioural, emotional, cognitive, and agentic engagement on students’ learning process. The paper discussed limitations and future research endeavours in online teaching and learning and students’ engagement.

THE PROBLEM OF DEPENDENCE ON SOCIAL WELFARE BENEFITS IN THE EXPERIENCE OF SOCIAL WORKERS

ABSTRACT: Aim: To learn and understand the problem of dependence on social assistance of clients of this institution on the basis of professional experience of social workers. Methods: The research used a qualitative research method - a collective case study. A total of 15 problem-focused and partially guided individual interviews were conducted with social workers, in three selected provinces in Poland. Results: The research shows that the phenomenon of clients' dependence on social welfare benefits is an important professional challenge experienced by social workers. According to the respondents, the social welfare system in Poland only partially activates the wards to take independent action to overcome difficult life situations, which further contributes to the creation and perpetuation of claimant and passive attitudes towards social welfare institutions. Coclusion: The presented results of the research prompt reflection on the role and function of social welfare benefits granted. The activities of social welfare institutions should aim to maximize the independence of their clients through social and professional activation, mobilization of human forces inherent in the environment, and revealing, stimulating and consolidating these forces. Oryginality: The article represents an area of analysis that is not often discussed in the scientific space. There is a lack of studies or research reports on this topic. The text presented here is one of the first to address the issue of research in the field of social welfare addiction of its clients from the perspective of professional social services. Keywords: social assistance, social worker, addiction, helplessness, exclusion, marginalization, passivity, entitlement.

“Understand What the Feelings of the Student Must Be:” Newcomer Youths’ High School Integration Experiences

The present study was grounded in a social constructionist epistemology with an integrative social justice lens. It highlights the perspectives of one group – that of newcomer youth – from a collective case study exploring the phenomenon of school integration across multiple collaborators in one designated high school. As school integration is a central component in the lives and experiences of newcomer youth, this study aimed to provide insights and lessons learned directly from this group as they were integrating into a high school in Western Canada. In line with the epistemology and research design, the research prioritized participant voices with the goal of affecting change within the designated high school. The central research question guiding this study was: How do participants perceive and describe their experiences of integrating into high school? To address this question, semi-structured, qualitative interviews were conducted with 13 newcomer high school students between the ages of 15 and 19. Upon conducting a thematic analysis on the interview transcripts, five salient themes were developed, including (a) the stress of acculturation, (b) language transition, (c) making connections, (d) navigating academics, and (e) renegotiating life. In this manuscript, the inter-relationship between these themes is discussed in a manner that captures the complex, multifaceted process of school integration. Relatedly, implications are presented.

'Do it afraid': An arts-based reflexive collective case study exploring youth responses to post-concussion communication changes in daily life.

Concussion and communication researchers have yet to study how post-concussion communication changes affect youths' daily lives. The lack of attention paid to how young people respond to communication changes during concussion recovery constitutes a significant gap in current concussion management research and practices. To explore how youth respond to the effects of post-concussion communication changes in their daily life, including (1) daily routines, (2) relationships with family members, (3) relationships with peers and (4) participation in school/work and community activities. Five youths (16-25 years) and three family members participated in this arts-based reflexive collective case study. Ecocultural theory provided the theoretical framework for study design, data collection and analysis. Cases consist of (1) pre-interview demographic information, (2) three 60-90-min virtual interviews, (3) optional family member interviews, (4) multi-media arts-based participant-generated materials representing participants' experiences of communication change and concussion, and (5) researcher observations, discussions and reflexive journal entries. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to analyse the data. Analysis yielded four themes that illustrate the ways youth navigated and adapted to post-concussion communication changes: (1) navigating changes in communication tasks, daily roles, and identity; (2) re-negotiating relationships and emotional reactions; (3) seeking control and learning to let go during recovery; and (4) helping youth adapt to post-concussion communication changes. The study findings deepen our understanding of the impact of post-concussion communication changes on youths' daily lives and underscore considerations critical to the development ofcommunication-focused concussion education programs and interventions tailored specifically for youth. What is already known on the subject Youth is a critical period of social and emotional development. Communication is integral to identity, relationships, participation in daily activities and well-being. Concussions can affect speech clarity, fluency, understanding and use of language, and social interactions. Re-engaging in routine activities and pre-injury roles can be challenging for youth experiencing communication changes as part of complex concussion recoveries. What this paper adds to the existing knowledge Findings from this research illuminate how youth navigate and adapt to communication changes post-concussion and support the development of youth-focused communication education programs, assessments and interventions. Youth participants actively managed their recoveries by developing innovative strategies to support their communication during daily activities, learning about communication, practicing communication tasks sequentially, and facing fears. Youth also reframed and challenged narrow views of 'normal communication'. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work? Findings highlight the need for more youth- and communication-focused education materials and programs within youth concussion management protocols. Information about the specific ecological and sociocultural factors youth encounter during concussion recovery is needed to develop targeted communication-focused education and intervention programs for youth and their families to mitigate risks of isolation, loneliness, and mental health concerns and increase youths' participation in family, community and cultural life. By learning from youth about how communication changes affected their participation in daily activities, identity and relationships, clinicians can provide information and interventions to reduce adverse listener reactions and help young people feel supported and understood.

Psychological Coaching for Performing Artists: Perceptions of and Reflections on Finding Ways to Manage Performance Anxiety

Performance anxiety is a major issue for performing artists. This qualitative paper extends our recent mixed-methods collective case study showing the beneficial effects of psychological interventions for managing performance anxiety, tailored in individual coaching settings. Here, we report on participants’ experiences of being coached, their understanding of how and why the interventions were effective, and the researcher-coach's experiences. Ten performing artists received five individual coaching sessions and were interviewed about their experiences pre- and post-intervention. A qualitative synthesis of transcripts of sessions and interviews, and of the coach's field notes and journal entries, was conducted. Findings suggest that change mechanisms have to be understood in the context of participants’ enhanced self-awareness during coaching, and the process of co-creating solutions and building a coaching relationship through mutual understanding and appreciation. While disentangling mechanisms and effects may not always be possible, we discuss useful strategies in coaching performing artists to manage performance anxiety.

Perspectives of service providers on vocational rehabilitation for mental health service users in Namibia: a qualitative study

Purpose Chronic mental illness disrupts the ability to work, often resulting in the need for vocational rehabilitation in which occupational therapists play a role. Namibia does not have an occupational therapy vocational rehabilitation practice framework for service users with chronic mental illness. This study explored the contextual factors that should be considered for a vocational rehabilitation practice framework in Namibia. Materials and methods A qualitative collective case study design was utilized. In-depth interviews were conducted with nine mental health service providers that were purposively selected from two study sites. An inductive thematic analysis of data was done using ATLAS.ti. Results The need for collaborative advocacy for service users to raise awareness and engage stakeholders such as family members, employers and policy makers was highlighted. Vocational rehabilitation resources needed include sheltered workshops, financial resources and trained human resources. Recognition that vocational rehabilitation services are too limited to meet the needs of mental health service users. A vocational rehabilitation policy and strategy is required. Supported employment and self-employment are potential strategies that should be considered. Conclusion Vocational rehabilitation for service users with chronic mental illness is limited in Namibia and there is a need to collaboratively improve the service.