Abstract ––Au-Ag mineralization occurrences in sphalerite ores of hydrothermal genesis are paradoxical in view of the incompatibility of these elements in sphalerite. The formation of sphalerite with Au and Ag impurities under hydrothermal crystallization of ZnS at 450 °C and 1 kbar pressure was studied experimentally. Sn impurity was taken as a source of point defects in crystals modelling the interaction of Au and Ag with vacancies. The Ag solubility in low-Fe sphalerite is estimated as 3.8 ± 0.7 μg/g, Au ̶ ≤ 0.6 μg/g. The main forms of Ag and Au occurrence in sphalerite are the inclusions of (Ag, Au)xS phases with x varies mainly from 1.8 to 2.0, and Au varies from 0.01 to 0.75 a.p.f.u. The primary forms of the elements in ores might be microinclusions (Ag, Au) 1.8-2.1S or close to (Ag, Au)S at higher fS2. In presence of Sn, solubilities of Au and Ag become higher. The behavior of Au corresponds to the substitution reaction Sn4+ + Au+ + v‒ ↔ 2Zn2+ in the presence of two types of vacancy defects (v–) ‒ the “inherent” vacancies dependent on the crystallization conditions and the vacancies accompanying Sn4+ incorporation. Ag entrance is seemingly more dependent on fS2 conditions and does not correlate with Sn. The extra vacancies arise because of metastable crystallization under the conditions of oversaturation of growth medium. This is supported by the spherulite morphology of growth products and the admixture of wurtzite ZnS form. The distribution and cocrystallization coefficients show an increasing trend for both precious metals (PM), due to which Au changes from incompatible to the category of highly compatible elements in sphalerite. The geochemical environments favorable for the formation of imperfect mineral crystals are considered. Such crystals are capable to uptake PMs and other incompatible in “ideal” crystal elements because of their interaction with vacancies, both constitutional (inherent to the substance) and non-equilibrium defects, and surficial nano-sized formations (nonautonomous phases). The evolution of these initially “invisible” forms of PM under metamorphic processes and remobilization of ore substance may result in Au and Ag escape and aggregation into microparticles.