AbstractThe analysis of a particular type of fauna, such as marine mammals, is best understood when all categories of fauna represented are studied. Detailed analysis of a portion of an assemblage, while interesting, can contribute to misleading interpretations of prehistoric human behaviour. Faunal assemblages from coastal shell middens in southern California and Oregon provide examples of the analysis of marine mammals and their relative importance in prehistoric subsistence, economy, and culture change. While marine mammals were important for subsistence and comprise a high proportion of the bones identifiable to the species level in these assemblages, these animals were less important than fish and shellfish in the diet and probably played a limited role in culture change in these regions. Previous studies that suggest a central role for marine mammals in cultural evolution in western North America provide minimal information on other fauna, and use limited analytical methods. Quantification methods that require species level identification (such as minimum number of individuals [MNI]) can exclude much of the faunal data available from dense coastal middens, and may over emphasize some portions of the assemblage, notably large mammals. Analysis at taxonomic levels higher than species and use of several quantification techniques, including meat weight estimates, may help alleviate some of these methodological problems and lead to a better understanding of the role of marine mammals in prehistoric economies. Copyright © 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Read full abstract