The value of a highly oscillatory integral is typically determined asymptotically by the behavior of the integrand near a small number of critical points. These include the endpoints of the integration domain and the so-called stationary points or saddle points---roots of the derivative of the phase of the integrand---where the integrand is locally nonoscillatory. Modern methods for highly oscillatory quadrature exhibit numerical issues when two such saddle points coalesce. On the other hand, integrals with coalescing saddle points are a classical topic in asymptotic analysis, where they give rise to uniform asymptotic expansions in terms of the Airy function. In this paper we construct Gaussian quadrature rules that remain uniformly accurate when two saddle points coalesce. These rules are based on orthogonal polynomials in the complex plane. We analyze these polynomials, prove their existence for even degrees, and describe an accurate and efficient numerical scheme for the evaluation of oscillatory integrals with coalescing saddle points.