The electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) is a promising approach to valorizing CO2. Ti3C2TX as a support material has received significant interest in enhancing CO2RR performance for tuning the electronic structure. However, there has been relatively less focus on changes to the Ti3C2TX electronic structure induced by loading catalysts onto the Ti3C2TX. Because Ti3C2TX has an intrinsic activity for both CO2RR and the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), electronic structure changes can affect the balance between CO2RR and HER selectivity. Therefore, tuning the electronic structure of Ti3C2TX can control the competition between CO2RR and HER and tune the selectivity and activity. Herein, we report that Ti3C2TX’s electronic structure can be tuned by the Ag+ loading method via redox interactions, tuning the reaction selectivity and activity for CO2RR. To illustrate this effect, we compare the CO2RR performance of in-situ formed Ag nanoparticles (NPs) on Ti3C2TX (0.9Ag-IS-Ti3C2TX) with physically mixed Ag NPs and Ti3C2TX (0.9Ag/P/Ti3C2TX). Here, ‘0.9’ refers to the molar ratio between Ag precursor and Ti3C2Tx, and ‘IS’ vs. ‘P’ refers to in-situ formed vs. physically mixed Ag NPs. 0.9Ag-IS-Ti3C2TX demonstrates a higher oxidation state for Ti and a higher proportion of Ti-O bonds than 0.9Ag/P/Ti3C2TX. Compared to 0.9Ag/P/Ti3C2TX, 0.9Ag-IS-Ti3C2TX exhibits higher CO Faradaic efficiency (FE), rising from 8.1 % with a partial current density of −2.0 mA cm−2 to 49.6 % with a partial current density of −20.1 mA cm−2 at −1.4 V vs. RHE (reversible hydrogen electrode). To harness this effect, we demonstrate control over the CO: H2 ratio of syngas formed from CO2RR over our Ti3C2TX-supported catalysts. Further electrochemical anodic oxidation experiments reveal the critical oxidation potential of Ti3C2TX (0.8 V vs. RHE) and show that HER can be partially suppressed by partial oxidation of Ti3C2TX. This work highlights the importance of considering the changes in Ti3C2TX (and other) supports when supporting catalysts for CO2RR and other electrochemical reactions.