Purpose: Colorectal cancer (CRC) effects both genders roughly equally, being the third leading cause of cancer deaths in both women and men. However, emerging evidence indicates that adenomas may be much less frequent in women than men (e.g., Regula et al., NEJM 2006, Nguyen et al., Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2009). The lower adenoma yet approximately equivalent CRC rate has been termed the “women's CRC paradox”. This suggests decreased initiation and enhanced progression phases of colon carcinogenesis in women. From a molecular perspective, this effect appears to be pathognomonic for TGF β which acts as a tumor suppressor in early lesions and a proto-oncogene in more advanced lesions. Moreover, in the colon TGF β appears to be controlled by estrogen receptor β, providing a potential gender-specific link. In this study, we wanted to confirm the paradox in a well-defined dataset and assess TGF β role via activity detected through its surrogate marker, phospho-SMAD2/3. Methods: We queried our CRC translational research database to identify unselected patients with CRC resections and colonoscopy from 2006-2009. For tissue analysis, we assessed biopsies of uninvolved rectum from our pathology repository. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) were performed using standard techniques with a monoclonal antibody to phosphorylated SMAD 2/3(Cell Signaling, MA) and nuclear staining was scored by a GI pathologist blinded to gender. Results: Our cohort consisted of 130 patients with CRC and 1159 with colonoscopy for adenoma detection. As noted in figure 1, the number of CRCs were comparable between males and females. On the other hand, women had 64.9% of the number of total adenomas in men (p<0.01). Women also had a 36.2% decrease in advanced adenomas(p<0.01). Nuclear phospho-SMAD 2/3 was markedly elevated in the endoscopically-normal rectal mucosa of women and this 54% increase was highly statistically significant (p<0.001).FigureConclusion: We confirm the gender “paradox” with women having equal number of cancers but half the adenomas prevalence of men. Furthermore, we make the novel observation that women appear to have more marked TGF β signaling (gauged by phospho-SMAD 2/3) providing a biologically plausible mechanism for the “paradox”. Future studies will address the clinical consequences and biological underpinnings of this phenomena.
Read full abstract