Reviewed by: Working Alternatives: American and Catholic Experiments in Work and Economy ed. by John C. Seitz and Christine Firer Hinze Nathan Schneider Working Alternatives: American and Catholic Experiments in Work and Economy. Edited by John C. Seitz and Christine Firer Hinze. New York, NY: Fordham University Press, 2020. 304 pp. $35.00. "There are years that ask questions and years that answer," Zora Neale Hurston once wrote. Although applying those words to Catholic social teaching (CST) requires dispatching them far from the context of the novel in which they appear, they are apt. Working Alternatives is a volume that grew out of a 2016 Fordham University conference on "Building Good Economies," a theme that echoes the ambition of Pope Leo XIII in Rerum Novarm (1891), the founding document of the modern CST tradition. Yet while Leo chiefly sought to present a distinctly Catholic answer to the period's conflicts of labor and capital, Working Alternatives dwells more among questions. The book contains frequent nods to the writings of recent popes, but these passages bear less of the thrill evident around insights coming from such less-Catholic realms as domestic-worker organizing, Tesla Motors, "regenerative capitalism," the New Age philosopher Ken Wilber, shamanism, and Patagonia (the company, not the place). There are stirring historical portraits, such as of 1940s interracial Christian communities in the U.S. South and a 1950s Catholic midwifery practice. But the more recent points of inspiration come largely from outside church settings—particularly if one recognizes the degree to which Pope Francis's Laudato Si' draws from the largely secular environmental-justice movement that long preceded it. [End Page 79] This is an observation, not a complaint. The editors organized the book around Father Joseph Carijn's "see, judge, act" method—also an influence on Francis—that privileges questioning and listening. The strongest chapters are those that seek to pull CST in new directions, to point to where the church should be looking. Sandra Sillivan-Dunbar puts Pope Benedict XVI into conversation with the discourse of the "care economy," while Kirsten Swinth reveals the violence of regarding women's work as non-economic, as Catholic understandings of gender complementarity tend to do. Michael Naughton, Nicholas Rademacher, Sandra Waddock, Michael Pirson, and Vincent Stanley point to examples of "social enterprise" (and other bywords for do-good firms)—manifestations, perhaps, of Pope Leo's hope for achieving an economic common good through virtuous leadership more than combative labor relations. While some chapters helpfully illustrate how Catholic concepts offer answers for contemporary dilemmas around work and education, the originality appears most in the passages that turn outward. Like Thomas Aquinas pouring over Greek, Muslim, and Jewish outsiders on behalf of the medieval church, Working Alternatives portrays present-day CST as busy with the task of absorption—although not yet the synthesis. How, then, might the church be called to act, to answer? Except in passing, the book largely bypasses one remarkable legacy of Catholics "building good economies": that of cooperative business. Catholics didn't invent cooperativism, but they saw others doing it, judged it good, and acted decisively to advance it. Responding to Pope Leo's call, twentieth-century Catholics seeded the North American credit union movement, the massive Mondragon worker cooperatives in Basque Country, the Italian social cooperative model, and countless agricultural and credit co-ops across the global south. Mondragon, for instance, has been widely studied and copied but never replicated at anything like its scale; the religious tradition behind it seems to have not only spiritual force but unique entrepreneurial powers as well. When CST is ready again for years that answer, it can be a dynamo. Between seeing and acting, the church must also judge. Beware when elevating a company like Tesla—which, despite its success in promoting electric vehicles, has undermined unionization drives and behaved callously regarding worker safety. Even the most shining social enterprise, anyway, might be an exception that serves to justify an unjust system and culture. There are few radical, systemic alternatives offered here that are equal to recent popes' withering critiques of capitalism and consumerism. Despite excellent chapters on New Deal-era racial exclusions and early experiments in integration, the...