BOOK REVIEWS 57 Book Reviews·He PRAIRIE SCHOOL IN THE CARIBBEAN Thomas S. Marvel, Antonin Nechodoma, Architect, 1877-1928: The Prairie School in the Caribbean. Gainesville, Florida: University Press of Florida, 1994, 220 pp., 194 b&w illustrations. Edward E. Crain, Historic Architecture in the Caribbean Islands. Gainesville, Florida: University Press of Florida, 1994, 256 pp., 450 b&w illustrations, 64 color plates. Nicholas N.Patricios, Building Marvelous Miami. Gainesville, Florida: University Press of Florida, 1994, 325 pp., 253 b&w illustrations. Antonin Nechodoma, Architect, 1877-1928: The Prairie School in the Caribbean Antonin Nechodoma is probably an unknown figure to all but a few Frank Lloyd Wright scholars and the handful of scholars who study the architecture of Puerto Rico and the Caribbean. Even among these groups little isknown concerning this intriguing architect who brought the architecture of the Prairie School lo the Caribbean. Thomas Marvel, however, reveals Nechodoma to be an architect worthy of our attention. Marvel's book is similar to Robert Twombly's 1979 biography of Frank Lloyd Wright, with the chapters organized into discrete chronological divisions containing a blend of architectural, cultural, and personal history. Unlike Twombly, who faced an almost overwhelming mountain of information concerning the careerand personal lifeof Mr. Wright, Marvel had topainstakingly reconstruct the life and career of Antonin Nechodoma from limited evidence which often yielded more questions than answers. This difficulty notwithstanding, the author provides unique and valuable insights regarding the importation of architectural ideals into the Caribbean and the nature of architectural practice in the early 20th century. Marvel traces Nechodoma's life from his immigration to Chicago in 1882, at age 10, through his early career as a building contractor in Chicago, to his disappearance from that city in l 905 and his sudden emergence as an architect in South Florida and the Caribbean in 1906, then follows the architect's career until his untimely death in 1928. The first chapter focuses on Nechodoma's childhood in Chicago and his career as a building contractor. The next two chapters address his abrupt depa1ture from Chicago in 1905/06 and his appearance as an architect, first in Jacksonville, Florida, then in San Juan, Puerto Rico, and finally in the Dominican Republic where he practiced from 1908 to 1912. Chapters four and five trace his architectural career in Puerto Rico from 1912 to 1923. This is Nechodoma's most prolific period; it represents his mature development as an architect. Chapter six focuses on three residences designed between 19I6 and I918. Although Marvel gives these works special attention because they represent Nechodoma 's "best effort.s," more impo1tant to his study of Nechodoma is that all three buildings derived their designs from the Ausgefuhrte Bauten u11d Entwii,fevonFrankLfoydWright of 1910,commonly known as the Wasmuth Folio. The final two chapters address Nechodoma 's last few years of practice before his tragic death in an automobile accident, and contain a conclusion in which Marvel addresses the "Dilemma of Nechodoma." Marvel's 'dilemma' is how to judge and evaluate this remarkable man. How did Nechodoma acquire his architectural knowledge and training? How should he be assessed and understood? What questions should be asked of his career and works? This dilemma is, of course, similar to that which all scholars face. 1nthis case, however, although some assessments orjudgments are difficull to make due to ascarcity of info1mation, Marvel's clear and unabashed infatuation with Nechodoma and his architecture prevents him from critically examining his subject. The result is a work which, while providing a wealth of information on this unknown regional figure, lacks a true critical distance and perspective. Although Marvel manages to raise many questions which he fails to answer, this fault may be forgiven because he has served architectural historians well by producing a work which has the potential to stimulate anew body of research into the architecture of Puerto Rico and to other regional followers of Frank Lloyd Wright. Among the questions raised by Marvel is one concerning Nechodoma's architectural training and education. His family immigrated to the United States from Bohemia and settled in ARRIS Volume 7 199t Chicago's Bohemian west side neighborhood. Nechodoma thus grew up in an area which possessed a strong ethnic...
Read full abstract