Introduction: Type, severity, timing, and clinical course of acute rejection each influence the impact of a rejection episode, and if renal function recovers fully, there appears to be no survival disadvantage (CTS-Study, Opelz). With modern immunosuppressive regimens, the overall incidence of acute rejection may no longer be the most accurate surrogate marker for long-term kidney graft survival. We investigated the specificity of (subclinical) chronic inflammatory responses (SCAR) induced either by not successful treated rejection episodes, by using different CNI's or ongoing activated innate immune responses. We used the high sensitive parameter for inflammation, indoleamine 2,3 dioxygenase (IDO), in patients after renal transplantation in correlation to graft survival and graft function. Patients and methods: In a retro- (A, n=224, up to 12 years) and prospective study (B, n=124, up to 3 years) of renal transplant recipients we evaluated the IDO behavior for the long-term run. Both groups were comparable concerning the basic demographic data (age, time on dialysis, PRA and waiting time). Estimation of IDO was performed via kynurenine measurement. Results: IDO in normal controls (n=257) was 2,5±0,4 μmol/L Kyn, in stabile renal transplanted patients (n=248) 5,8 ±1,8μmol/L. We identified in both groups already end of the first week posttransplant a statistically significant difference (A:17,2 vs. 7,0 (week 1, median, p< .005; 8,1vs.4,8 (w.6, median, p< .001; B:12,3 vs. 7,0 (w.1, median, p< .001); 6,7 vs. 4,2 (w.6, median, p< .001)) in the IDO levels between patients with/without acute rejection. Patients with an IDO-level > 5, 5 in the follow up (min.3 weeks) and after rejection treatment showed a significant lower graft survival. In the cohort A (IDO < 5,0) 1/5/10 year graft survival was 98/88/69% compared to 88/57/34% (survival data death censored). There was no difference between both CNI's. Rejection rate in A was allover 18%, in B 19,5 % (BPAR). Patients with induction or polyclonal rejection treatment showed lower IDO levels and a better long-term survival. Conclusion: Supported by recent publications we found that chronic transplant nephropathy may not be related solely to CNI toxicity. Our data supporting the results, that not the rejection episode itself is leading to a reduced long-term outcome but a subclinical ongoing inflammatory processes. Once the rejection episode is treated successfully - meaning the reestablishment of the inflammatory homeostasis - the chance for a long graft survival is still given. IDO monitoring might be a helpful tool to identify very early subclinical acute rejection, the best rejection treatment and the optimization of immunsuppressive regimen in sense of rejection prophylaxis.
Read full abstract