Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) is a known hematologic malignancy associated with a growing incidence and post-treatment relapse. Hence, finding a reliable diagnostic biomarker for CLL is crucial. Circular RNAs (circRNAs) represent a new class of RNA involved in many biological processes and diseases. This study aimed to define a circRNA-based panel for the early diagnosis of CLL. To this point, the list of the most deregulated circRNAs in CLL cell models was retrieved using bioinformatic algorithms and applied to the verified CLL patients' online datasets as the training cohort (n = 100). The diagnostic performance of potential biomarkers represented in individual and discriminating panels, was then analyzed between CLL Binet stages and validated in individual sample sets I (n = 220) and II (n = 251). We also estimated the 5-year overall survival (OS), introduced the cancer-related signaling pathways regulated by the announced circRNAs, and provided a list of possible therapeutic compounds to control the CLL. These findings show that the detected circRNA biomarkers exhibit better predictive performance compared to current validated clinical risk scales, and are applicable for the early detection and treatment of CLL.