MY CONTRIBUTION to this symposium on pulmonary fibrosis will be short, since my only object is to try to correlate the x-ray, pathological, and clinical findings. I believe that Dr. Mallory2 has made a distinct contribution to our knowledge of pulmonary fibrosis and when we accept his group of cases it changes our previous ideas of classification. From the clinician's standpoint there are now four groups of cases in which varying degrees of pulmonary fibrosis play an important part: first, those with known etiology (tuberculosis, silicosis, and radiation therapy); second, the group with either asthma or emphysema, where the fibrosis seems to be the result of organizing pneumonia; third, Dr. Mallory's cases of fibrosing granulomata; and fourth, a miscellaneous group of unusual conditions. From the standpoint of the practitioner of internal medicine, the group with “senile emphysema” is probably the largest and most important. The age of onset is usually in the fifty's. Acute respiratory infection is often the apparent inciting factor. Dyspnea with exertion is the outstanding symptom, and there are varying degrees of chronic bronchial infection and bronchial spasm. In many of these cases of emphysema, as well as in a large proportion of those with extensive fibrosis, cor pulmonale (right-sided heart failure) plays a definite part, but the severity of symptoms is often independent of the degree of pulmonary fibrosis, and cor pulmonale of alarming proportions may occur in cases with very little scar tissue. Many cases of asthma also fall into this group One of our favorite cases of clinical “idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis” was that of a woman who had had asthma since childhood; from the postmortem standpoint, this was classified as asthma with very extensive organized pneumonia. In reviewing the slides recently Dr. Mallory did not admit it to the group of fibrosing granulomata. In practically all of these cases of asthma and emphysema, such fibrosis as develops seems to be the result of organized pneumonia. The third group is one which in the past we have called “idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis,” but Dr. Mallory has shown that the majority of these cases can be placed in a group of granulomata of the lung which histologically resemble sarcoid disease. For the time being I believe that many cases in which we can safely rule out organized pneumonia should be considered as fibrosing granulomata. This leaves for the fourth group a few miscellaneous unusual cases. We have, for example, cases resembling “fibrosis,” which have proved to be bronchiolectasis, where there is a marked dilatation of the smaller bronchioles with very little dilatation or infection in the larger bronchi. Now let us go back to Dr. Mallory's approach to the problem of “idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis” and his 6 cases of a granulomatous process, histologically similar to sarcoid disease, which have gone on to pulmonary fibrosis with resulting death.
Read full abstract