The recently introduced VIST chromoendoscopy technique allows for detailed analysis of surface and vascular pattern morphology. The aim of this study was to create a new and unique classification for differentiating colorectal polyps using the VIST technology and to assess its interobserver concordance. In addition, we aimed to evaluate the accuracy of the new classification for optical diagnosis and histology prediction of colon polyps. A digital library containing 26 videos/still images from 26 histologically confirmed polyps with VIST was first evaluated by seven endoscopists from five different countries in order to identify possible descriptors. In the second step, the descriptors were categorized using a modified Delphi methodology to propose the VALID-classification. In the third step, the seven endoscopists independently reviewed a new dataset comprising of 45 videos/still images, and provided for each a diagnosis based on the VALID-classification. The interobserver agreement of the VALID-classification’s individual descriptor was then assessed, and its accuracy in predicting colorectal polyp histology was evaluated. Using a modified Delphi process, the endoscopists agreed on summarizing 8 descriptors into three main domains. Those include polyp surface pattern morphology (regular, yes/no; irregular, yes/no; ulcerated, yes/no), and pit pattern morphology (regular, yes/no; tubular appearance, yes/no; villous appearance, yes/no; tubulovillous appearance, yes/no, no pits visible yes/no). Interobserver reliability calculated in Gwet’s AC1 for the polyp surface and pit pattern morphology were 0.78 (0.57,0.82, 95%CI, the same as below) and 0.56 (0.46,0.67) respectively. The accuracy of the classification in predicting diagnosis (Non-neoplasia, Adenoma and Cancer) was 0.90 (0.84, 0.94), while the one in predicting the histology type (Hyperplastic Polyp, Tubular Adenoma, Tubulovillous Adenoma, Villous Adenoma and Cancer) was 0.70 (0.63, 0.77). The new VALID-classification was developed allowing for prediction of colorectal polyp histology using the newly introduced VIST-chromoendoscopy technique. A good concordance was shown among the observers and a rather high accuracy of the VALID-classification has also been demonstrated in the initial video/still-image evaluation. Further in vivo trials are required to validate this new classification in a clinical setting.
Read full abstract