The evolution of female multiple mating is still a largely debated field. Among the benefits that have been proposed to explain this risky behaviour is the replenishment of sperm reserves. Apart from an increase in total sperm number, it can be an expression of post-copulatory mate choice or can be directed towards the uptake of fresh sperm. Using fresh sperm for fertilization instead of sperm aged by storage in the female genital tract may avoid a lowered fertilization capacity, an increase in deleterious effects or a skewed offspring sex ratio. We investigated the influence of sperm age on female fitness in the grasshopper Chorthippus parallelus, a species where females mate multiply. After copulation, females store sperm over the course of weeks until fertilization. An average ejaculate of 250 000 spermatozoa exponentially declined with time within the female's spermatheca. The number of days since copulation better explained the variation in actual sperm number than the number of pods or eggs laid. We investigated differences in female fitness parameters in two treatments. In the first, females were mated only once, while in the second, females always had freshly ejaculated sperm available. Although in our experiment, multiply mated females had heavier offspring than singly mated females, egg number per pod, hatching and fertilization success, their composite effects and offspring sex ratio did not vary with respect to season or sperm age. We therefore reject the hypothesis that the reason for remating in females of this species is the uptake of fresh sperm.