Ingestion of multiple carbohydrate (CHO) types (e.g., dextrose+fructose) during exercise can increase CHO oxidation rates compared to ingesting a single CHO (e.g., dextrose), and may improve endurance performance. It has been reported that adding protein to a multiple-CHO beverage increased cycling time to exhaustion compared to a single CHO beverage alone. However, it is unclear whether the improved performance was due to the multiple CHOs or the addition of protein. PURPOSE: This study aimed to determine whether the addition of 1.2% protein to a 3% multiple-CHO beverage improved performance and muscle strength recovery in 2 same-day time trials compared to an isocaloric multiple CHO-only beverage. METHODS: 11 cyclists (39.9±11.8 y; VO2max 53.7±6.9 ml/kg/min) performed 3 trials, a familiarization trial and 2 randomly ordered, double-blinded experimental trials. Each trial consisted of a pre-trial leg strength measurement, 40km time trial (TT), 30 min recovery, 10km TT, and post-trial leg strength testing. Subjects ingested 275 mL of a multiple-CHO (MCO) or multiple-CHO+protein (MCP) beverage at 7 time points during the protocol. Blood glucose, lactate, heart rate (HR) and rating of perceived exertion (RPE) were measured. Leg strength was assessed using a custom Isometric Leg Strength System. Continuous variables were analyzed with paired t-tests. Repeated measures were analyzed with repeated measures ANOVA. RESULTS: No significant differences were found between MCO and MCP in 40km TT time (82.3±2.6 vs 82.8±2.8 min, respectively, p=0.32) and power output (233.3±16.0 vs 231.6±16.7 W, p=0.55) nor in 10km time (24.4±0.9 vs 24.5±1.1 min, p=0.61) or power output (238.2±16.7 vs 237.3±17.7 W, p=.83). No differences were found in leg strength recovery (pre-post trial) as well (p=0.22). Blood glucose, lactate, HR, and RPE were also not different between treatments. CONCLUSION: While addition of protein to CHO has been shown to improve TTE, it may not be beneficial in shorter race events. We speculate that in this study, exercise time and intensity were not great enough to deplete glycogen stores or cause muscle damage. Differences in experimental design likely explain the conflicting findings among studies.
Read full abstract