Chlorinated Metabolites Research Articles

New Chlorinated Metabolites and Antiproliferative Polyketone from the Mangrove Sediments-Derived Fungus Mollisia sp. SCSIO41409

Two new chlorinated metabolites, 8-chlorine-5-hydroxy-2,3-dimethyl-7-methoxychromone (1) and 3,4-dichloro-1H-pyrrole-2,5-dione (3), and eight known compounds (2 and 4-9) were isolated from the mangrove sediments-derived fungus Mollisia sp. SCSIO41409. Their structures were elucidated by physicochemical properties and extensive spectroscopic analysis. The absolute configuration of stemphone C (4) was established for the first time by the X-ray crystallographic analysis. Compounds 3 and 4 showed different intensity of antimicrobial activities against several pathogenic fungi and bacteria, and antiproliferative activities against two human prostate cancer cell lines (IC50 values 2.77 to 9.60 μM). Further, stemphone C (4) showed a reducing PC-3 cell colony formation, inducing apoptosis and blocking the cell cycle at S-phase in a dose-dependent manner; thus, it could be considered as a potential antiproliferative agent and a promising anti-prostate cancer lead compound.

Chlovalicin B, a Chlorinated Sesquiterpene Isolated from the Marine Mushroom Digitatispora marina.

As part of our search for bioactive metabolites from understudied marine microorganisms, the new chlorinated metabolite chlovalicin B (1) was isolated from liquid cultures of the marine basidiomycete Digitatispora marina, which was collected and isolated from driftwood found at Vannøya, Norway. The structure of the novel compound was elucidated by spectroscopic methods including 1D and 2D NMR and analysis of HRMS data, revealing that 1 shares its molecular scaffold with a previously isolated compound, chlovalicin. This represents the first compound isolated from the Digitatispora genus, and the first reported fumagillin/ovalicin-like compound isolated from Basidiomycota. Compound 1 was evaluated for antibacterial activities against a panel of five bacteria, its ability to inhibit bacterial biofilm formation, for antifungal activity against Candida albicans, and for cytotoxic activities against malignant and non-malignant human cell lines. Compound 1 displayed weak cytotoxic activity against the human melanoma cell line A2058 (~50% survival at 50 µM). No activity was detected against biofilm formation or C. albicans at 50 µM, or against bacterial growth at 100 µM nor against the production of cytokines by the human acute monocytic leukemia cell line THP-1 at 50 µM.

Innovative mycoremediation technique for treating unsterilized PCDD/F-contaminated field soil and the exploration of chlorinated metabolites

Mycoremediation of unsterilized PCDD/F-contaminated field soil was successfully demonstrated by solid-state fermentation coupled with Pleurotus pulmonarius utilizing a patented incubation approach. The experiments were carried out in four setups with two as controls. The contaminated soil was homogenously mixed with solid inocula, 1:0.5 dry w/w, resulting in an initial concentration of 4432 ± 623 ng WHO-TEQ kg−1. After a 30-day incubation under controlled conditions, the overall removal (approx. 60%) was non-specific. The removal was attributed to degradation by extracellular ligninolytic enzymes and uptake into the fruiting tissue (~110 ng WHO-TEQ kg−1 of mushroom). Furthermore, less recalcitrant chlorinated metabolites were found, implying ether bond cleavage and dechlorination happened during the mycoremediation. These metabolites resulted from the complex interaction between P. pulmonarius and the indigenous microbes from the unsterilized soil. This study provides a new step toward scaling up this mycoremediation technique to treat unsterilized PCDD/F-contaminated field soil.

Hairy root transformation of Brassica rapa with bacterial halogenase genes and regeneration to adult plants to modify production of indolic compounds

During the last years halogenated compounds have drawn a lot of attention. Metabolites with one or more halogen atoms are often more active than their non-halogenated derivatives like indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and 4-Cl-IAA. Within this work, bacterial flavin-dependent tryptophan halogenase genes were inserted into Brassica rapa ssp. pekinensis (Chinese cabbage) with the aim to produce novel halogenated indole compounds. It was investigated which tryptophan-derived indole metabolites, such as indole glucosinolates or potential degradation products can be synthesized by the transgenic root cultures. In vivo and in vitro activity of halogenases heterologously produced was shown and the production of chlorinated tryptophan in transgenic root lines was confirmed. Furthermore, chlorinated indole-3-acetonitrile (Cl-IAN) was detected. Other tryptophan-derived indole metabolites, such as IAA or indole glucosinolates were not found in the transgenic roots in a chlorinated form. The influence of altered growth conditions on the amount of produced chlorinated compounds was evaluated. We found an increase in Cl-IAN production at low temperatures (8 °C), but otherwise no significant changes were observed. Furthermore, we were able to regenerate the wild type and transgenic root cultures to adult plants, of which the latter still produced chlorinated metabolites. Therefore, we conclude that the genetic information had been stably integrated. The transgenic plants showed a slightly altered phenotype compared to plants grown from seeds since they also still expressed the rol genes. By this approach we were able to generate various stably transformed plant materials from which it was possible to isolate chlorinated tryptophan and Cl-IAN.

Prenylated Indole Diterpene Alkaloids from a Mine-Soil-Derived Tolypocladium sp.

Ten new prenylated indole diterpene alkaloids, tolypocladin A-J (1-10), including four chlorinated metabolites, have been isolated from a culture of a mine-soil-derived fungus, Tolypocladium sp. XL115. The structures and absolute configurations of 1-10 were determined by spectroscopic analysis, ECD calculations, and comparison with known compounds. Compounds 1 and 8 displayed significant antimicrobial activities. In addition, compound 1 also showed weak cytotoxic activity against all tested human cancer cell lines and suppressed the growth and viability of the patient-derived HCC cells T1224.

A joint molecular networking study of a Smenospongia sponge and a cyanobacterial bloom revealed new antiproliferative chlorinated polyketides.

The bloom-forming cyanobacteria Trichodesmium sp. have been recently shown to produce some of the chlorinated peptides/polyketides previously isolated from the marine sponge Smenospongia aurea. A comparative analysis of extracts from S. aurea and Trichodesmium sp. was performed using tandem mass spectrometry-based molecular networking. The analysis, specifically targeted to chlorinated metabolites, showed that many of them are common to the two organisms, but also that some general differences exist between the two metabolomes. Following this analysis, six new chlorinated metabolites were isolated and their structures elucidated: four polyketides, smenolactones A-D (1-4) from S. aurea, and two new conulothiazole analogues, isoconulothiazole B (5) and conulothiazole C (6) from Trichodesmium sp. The absolute configuration of smenolactone C (3) was determined by taking advantage of the conformational rigidity of open 1,3-disubstituted alkyl chains. The antiproliferative activity of smenolactones was evaluated on three tumor cell lines, and they were active at low-micromolar or sub-micromolar concentrations.

Impact of sorption processes on PCE concentrations in organohalide-respiring aquifer sediment samples

The evaluation of groundwater contaminant e.g. tetrachloroethene (PCE) degradation processes requires complete quantification of and pathway analysis of the groundwater contaminant under investigation. For example the reduction of PCE concentrations in the groundwater by unknown dissolution and/or sorption processes will impede interpretation of the fate and behaviour of such contaminants. In the present study PCE dissolution and sorption processes during anaerobic microbial degradation of chlorinated ethenes were investigated. For this purpose, microcosms were prepared using sediment samples from a PCE-contaminated aquifer, which in previous studies had demonstrated anaerobic organohalide respiration of PCE. Solid/water distribution coefficients (kd) of PCE were determined and validated by loss-on-ignition (LOI) and PCE sorption experiments. The determined kd magnitudes indicated methodological congruency, yielding values for sediment samples within a range of 1.15±0.02 to 5.93±0.34L·kg−1. The microcosm experiment showed lower PCE concentrations than expected, based on spiked PCE and observed anaerobic microbial degradation processes. Nevertheless the amount of PCE spike added was completely recovered albeit in the form of lower chlorinated metabolites. A delay due to dissolution processes was not responsible for this phenomenon. Sorption to sediments could only partially explain the reduction of PCE in the water phase. Accordingly, the results point to reversible sorption processes of PCE, possibly onto bacterial cell compartments and/or exopolymeric substances.

Determination of carbon isotope enrichment factors of cis‐dichloroethene after precursor amendment

Bacterial reductive dechlorination of the groundwater contaminant tetrachloroethene (PCE) involves the formation of lower chlorinated metabolites. Metabolites can be instantaneously formed and consumed in this sequential process; quantification and validation of their isotopic effects conventionally rely on separate laboratory microcosm studies. Here, we present an evaluation method enabling the determination of the carbon isotope enrichment factor (ε) for the intermediate cis-dichloroethene (cis-DCE) by a single laboratory microcosm study initially amending the precursor PCE only. Environmental samples harboring organohalide-respiring bacteria were incubated under anaerobic conditions and then successively and repeatedly amended with PCE and cis-DCE in two separate laboratory microcosm studies. Reductive dechlorination was monitored by analyzing liquid samples using Purge-and-Trap gas chromatography isotope ratio mass spectrometry GC/MS-C/IRMS. The prerequisites of the presented evaluation method are mass and δ-value balancing. The evaluation method was validated by agglomerative hierarchical classification of Rayleigh plot data points. The sample-sensitive range of εcis-DCE extended from -10.6 ± 0.2‰ to -26.8 ± 0.6‰ (R2 ≥98%). The maximum standard deviations of εcis-DCE were ±1.8‰ for single microcosms, ±1.8‰ for replicates and ±1.0‰ for the compiled replicate data of PCE and cis-DCE amendments. A linear regression of the εcis-DCE for replicates obtained by each amendment study showed a slope of 95% (5 of the 7 data points are within a 95% confidence interval), demonstrating factor congruency and the practicability of the evaluation method. We found metabolite degradation and formation to be sequential but also stepwise during bacterial reductive dechlorination. The stepwise phases of the degradation of the intermediate eliminate the impact of instantaneous precursor degradation. These stepwise sections were used to determine εcis-DCE -values. Our results showed the validity of εcis-DCE -values over a wide range at initial precursor degradation (PCE). The presented evaluation method could substantially decrease lab costs for microcosm studies designed for εcis-DCE determinations. Moreover, the results indicated that the evaluation method can be applied to other PCE-metabolites.

Chlokamycin, a New Chloride from the Marine-derived Streptomyces sp. MA2-12

A new chlorinated metabolite designated chlokamycin (1), was isolated along with ikarugamycin (2) from the culture broth of the marine-derived Streptomyces sp. MA2–12. The structure of 1 was elucidated based on spectroscopic analyses (1D and 2D NMR data and ROESY correlations). Chlokamycin moderately inhibited the growth of Jurkat cells and HCT116 cells with IC50 values of 24.7 and 33.5 μM, respectively.

New chlorinated xanthone and anthraquinone produced by a mangrove-derived fungus Penicillium citrinum HL-5126.

Two new chlorinated metabolites 4-chloro-1-hydroxy-3-methoxy-6-methyl-8-methoxycarbonyl-xanthen-9-one (1) and 2'-acetoxy-7-chlorocitreorosein (2), together with three known compounds (3-5), were obtained from the EtOAc extract of the endophytic fungus Penicillium citrinum HL-5126 isolated from the mangrove Bruguiera sexangula var. rhynchopetala collected in the South China Sea. Their structures were elucidated by the detailed analysis of comprehensive spectroscopic data. All compounds were evaluated for their antibacterial and topoisomerase I inhibitory activities. Compound 2 exhibited antibacterial activity against Vibrio parahaemolyticus with an MIC value of 10 μm.

Automated Detection of Natural Halogenated Compounds from LC-MS Profiles-Application to the Isolation of Bioactive Chlorinated Compounds from Marine-Derived Fungi.

A collection of culture extracts obtained from several marine-derived fungal strains collected on the French Atlantic coast was investigated by high performance liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry (HPLC-HRMS) in order to prospect for halogenated compounds and to identify potentially new ones. To achieve a fast, automated, and efficient data analysis, a bioinformatics tool named MeHaloCoA (Marine Halogenated Compound Analysis) was developed and included into R. After extraction of all the peaks from the metabolic fingerprints and their associated mass spectra, a mathematical filter based on mass isotopic profiles allowed the selective detection of halogenated (Cl and Br) molecules. Integrating MeHaloCoA into a dereplication approach allowed the identification of known and new halogenated compounds in a competitive amount of time. Subsequent targeted purification led to the isolation of several chlorinated metabolites, including two new natural products with bioactive potential, griseophenone I and chlorogriseofulvin, from a marine-derived Penicillium canescens strain.

Microbial dechlorination of HCB, PCP, PCB180, HCH and PCE in a Yangtze Three Gorges Reservoir enrichment culture, China

Highly chlorinated pollutants are often found in river sediments, such as in the Yangtze River. In this study, the transformation of hexachlorobenzene, pentachlorophenol, polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB), hexachlorocyclohexane and perchloroethene was demonstrated in a mixed microbial culture enriched from Xiangxi River sediment [a tributary of Yangtze River belonging to the Three Gorges Reservoir (TGR)] which contained halo-respiring bacteria. Reductive dehalogenation by the Yangtze bacteria resulted in the formation of lower chlorinated metabolites, such as tri- and dichlorobenzenes, tri- and dichlorophenols, vinyl chloride and ethene. In case of PCB180, the lesser chlorinated metabolite PCB146 was detected and is recommended for future monitoring programs. Increased gene copy numbers of dechlorinating bacteria, e.g. Dehalococcoides spp. and Desulfitobacterium spp., were observed after the transformation of the chlorinated pollutants. In conclusion, the study demonstrates the capability of Yangtze River bacteria to dechlorinate several important chlorinated pollutants, indicating efficient pollutant turnover in the TGR area.

Effects of growth substrate on triclosan biodegradation potential of oxygenase-expressing bacteria

Triclosan is an antimicrobial agent, an endocrine disrupting compound, and an emerging contaminant in the environment. This is the first study investigating triclosan biodegradation potential of four oxygenase-expressing bacteria: Rhodococcus jostii RHA1, Mycobacterium vaccae JOB5, Rhodococcus ruber ENV425, and Burkholderia xenovorans LB400. B. xenovorans LB400 and R. ruber ENV425 were unable to degrade triclosan. Propane-grown M. vaccae JOB5 can completely degrade triclosan (5mgL−1). R. jostii RHA1 grown on biphenyl, propane, and LB medium with dicyclopropylketone (DCPK), an alkane monooxygenase inducer, was able to degrade the added triclosan (5mgL−1) to different extents. Incomplete degradation of triclosan by RHA1 is probably due to triclosan product toxicity. The highest triclosan transformation capacity (Tc, defined as the amount of triclosan degraded/the number of cells inactivated; 5.63×10−3ng triclosan/16S rRNA gene copies) was observed for biphenyl-grown RHA1 and the lowest Tc (0.20×10−3ng-triclosan/16S rRNA gene copies) was observed for propane-grown RHA1. No triclosan degradation metabolites were detected during triclosan degradation by propane- and LB+DCPK-grown RHA1. When using biphenyl-grown RHA1 for degradation, four chlorinated metabolites (2,4-dichlorophenol, monohydroxy-triclosan, dihydroxy-triclosan, and 2-chlorohydroquinone (a new triclosan metabolite)) were detected. Based on the detected metabolites, a meta-cleavage pathway was proposed for triclosan degradation.

Destruction of mixture of tri-hexa-chlorinated biphenyls by Rhodococcus genus strains

Destruction of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) by strain-destructors Rhodococcus sp. B7a and Rhodococcus sp. G12a has been studied. It was shown that these strains destruct 78-95% of PCB mixture containing tri-hexa-chlorinated biphenyls. Rhodococcus destruct all components of the mixture of tri-, tetra-, penta-, and hexa-chlorinated biphenyls without accumulation of toxic chlorinated metabolites. The studied bacteria destruct PCB that are the most stable for oxidation, such as 2,5,2',5'-CB; 3,4,3',4'-CB; and 2,4,5,2',4',5'-CB. The most perspective strains are R. rubber P25, Rhodococcus sp. B7a and Rhodococcus sp. G12a whose metabolic potential can be used for biotechnological refinement of the environment from highly toxic pollutants.

Sequential Reductive and Oxidative Biodegradation of Chloroethenes Stimulated in a Coupled Bioelectro-Process

This article for the first time demonstrates successful application of electrochemical processes to stimulate sequential reductive/oxidative microbial degradation of perchloroethene (PCE) in mineral medium and in contaminated groundwater. In a flow-through column system, hydrogen generation at the cathode supported reductive dechlorination of PCE to cis-dichloroethene (cDCE), vinyl chloride (VC), and ethene (ETH). Electrolytically generated oxygen at the anode allowed subsequent oxidative degradation of the lower chlorinated metabolites. Aerobic cometabolic degradation of cDCE proved to be the bottleneck for complete metabolite elimination. Total removal of chloroethenes was demonstrated for a PCE load of approximately 1.5 μmol/d. In mineral medium, long-term operation with stainless steel electrodes was demonstrated for more than 300 days. In contaminated groundwater, corrosion of the stainless steel anode occurred, whereas DSA (dimensionally stable anodes) proved to be stable. Precipitation of calcareous deposits was observed at the cathode, resulting in a higher voltage demand and reduced dechlorination activity. With DSA and groundwater from a contaminated site, complete degradation of chloroethenes in groundwater was obtained for two months thus demonstrating the feasibility of the sequential bioelectro-approach for field application.

Discovery of New Chlorinated Briaranes from Junceella fragilis

Abstract Four briarane-type diterpenoids, including two new chlorinated metabolites, fragilides F (1) and G (2), along with two known compounds, junceellonoid D (3) and juncin Z (4), were isolated from the gorgonian coral Junceella fragilis. The structures of new briaranes 1 and 2 were elucidated by spectral data analysis and the absolute configuration of 1 was directly determined by a single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis. The relationships between proton chemical shifts and conformations of the methylenecyclohexane ring in briaranes possessing a C-11/20 carbon–carbon double bond are described. Briarane 4 was found to exhibit significant cytotoxicity toward the CCRF-CEM tumor cells.

Application of Electrolysis to Stimulate Microbial Reductive PCE Dechlorination and Oxidative VC Biodegradation

A novel approach was applied to stimulate biodegradation of chloroethenes bya coupled bioelectro-process. In a flow-through column system, microbial dechlorination of tetrachloroethene to cis-dichloroethene, vinyl chloride, and ethene was stimulated by hydrogen produced by water electrolysis. Dechlorinating bacteria (Dehalococcoides spp. and Desulfitobacterium spp.) and also methanogens and homoacetogens were detected in the anaerobic column. Simultaneously, oxidative biodegradation of lower chlorinated metabolites (vinyl chloride) was stimulated by electrolytic oxygen formation in the corresponding aerobic column. The process was stable for more than 100 days and an average removal of approximately 23 micromol/d PCE and 72 micromo/d vinyl chloride was obtained with a current density of 0.05 mA/cm2. Abiotic electrochemical degradation of the contaminants was not observed. Microbial dechlorination correlated with the current densities in the applied range of 0.01-0.05 mA/cm2. The results are promising for environmental applications, since with electrolysis hydrogen and oxygen can be supplied continuously to chloroethene degrading microorganisms, and the supply rates can be easily controlled by adjusting the electric current.

The Metabolism and Dechlorination of Chlorotyrosine in Vivo

During inflammation, neutrophil- and monocyte-derived myeloperoxidase catalyzes the formation of hypochlorous acid, which can chlorinate tyrosine residues in proteins to form chlorotyrosine. However, little is known of the metabolism and disposition of chlorotyrosine in vivo. Following infusion of deuterium-labeled [D(4)]chlorotyrosine into Sprague-Dawley rats, the major urinary metabolites were identified by mass spectrometry. 3-Chloro-4-hydroxyphenylacetic acid was identified as the major chlorinated metabolite of chlorotyrosine and accounted for 3.6 +/- 0.3% of infused [D(4)]chlorotyrosine. The striking observation was that approximately 40% (39 +/- 1%) of infused [D(4)]chlorotyrosine was dechlorinated and excreted in the urine as deuterated 4-hydroxyphenylacetic acid, a major metabolite of tyrosine. 1.1 +/- 0.1% of infused [D(4)]chlorotyrosine was excreted as [D(4)]tyrosine. To determine whether protein-bound chlorotyrosine could undergo dechlorination, chlorinated albumin was incubated with liver homogenate from mutant rats, which did not synthesize albumin. There was approximately 20% decrease in the chlorotyrosine content over 1 h. This study is the first to describe the dechlorination of chlorotyrosine as the major metabolic pathway to eliminate this modified amino acid in vivo.

Auxiliary Substrates for Elimination of Trichloroethene, Monochlorobenzene, and Benzene in a Sequential Anaerobic–Aerobic GAC Biobarrier

Sequential anaerobic-aerobic barrier is a novel concept for groundwater bioremediation. Trichloroethene (TCE), monochlorobenzene (MCB), and benzene (BZ) were used as model contaminants representing contaminant cocktails frequently found in the contaminated subsurface. The autochthonous microflora from a contaminated field was inoculated to eliminate model contaminants in a set of sequential anaerobic–aerobic granulated activated carbon (GAC) columns and batch studies. In the anaerobic column, the TCE was reductively dechlorinated through cis-dichloroethene (cis-DCE), vinyl chloride (VC), and ethene (ETH). Ethanol and sucrose as auxiliary substrates were added to donate electrons. In the second stage, MCB, BZ, and the lower chlorinated metabolites of TCE degradation, i.e. cis-Dichloroethene (cisDCE) and vinyl chloride (VC), were oxidatively degraded with addition of hydrogen peroxide and nitrate. This paper examines the influence of auxiliary substrates on the biological degradation of model pollutants. In the anaerobic barrier, the auxiliary substrates supply should be maintained low but stoichiometrically adequate for supporting reductive dechlorination. Supplying higher amount of auxiliary substrates provoked competitive reactions in anaerobic conditions, such as sulfate reduction and methanogenesis. If the auxiliary substrates are not utilized completely in the anaerobic phase, the remaining compounds flow into the aerobic phase. This led to unwanted conditions, i.e. oxidation of auxiliary substrates instead of pollutant elimination, and a higher consumption of electron acceptors. In the aerobic barrier, in particular, ethene proved to be a suitable auxiliary substrate for cometabolic degradation of cisDCE.

Pubertal development in female Wistar rats following exposure to propazine and atrazine biotransformation by-products, diamino-S-chlorotriazine and hydroxyatrazine.

We showed previously that the chlorotriazine herbicide, atrazine (ATR), delays the onset of pubertal development in female rats. ATR and its biotransformation by-products are present in soil and groundwater. Since current maximum contaminant levels are set only for ATR, it is important to determine whether these by-products can also alter pubertal development and possibly pose a cumulative exposure hazard. We evaluated the effects of two ATR by-products, diamino-s-chlorotriazine (DACT) and hydroxyatrazine (OH-ATR), and a structurally similar chlorotriazine, propazine (PRO), on female pubertal development. Rats were gavaged from postnatal days (PNDs) 22 through PND 41 with DACT (16.7, 33.8, 67.5, 135 mg/kg), OH-ATR (22.8, 45.7, 91.5, 183 mg/kg), or PRO (13, 26.7, 53, 106.7, 213 mg/kg). The dose range for each chemical was selected as the molar equivalent of ATR (12.5, 25, 50, 100, 200 mg/kg). The females were monitored daily for vaginal opening (VO) and killed on PND 41. DACT, a by-product of ATR that occurs in the environment and is also the primary chlorinated metabolite of ATR in animal tissue, delayed VO by 3.2, 4.8, and 7.6 days compared to the controls (33.1 +/- 0.4 (SE) days of age) following exposure to 33.8, 67.5, and 135 mg/kg, respectively. The no effect level (NOEL) for DACT (16.7 mg/kg) was identical to the equimolar NOEL for ATR (25 mg/kg). Although the body weight (BW) on PND 41 was reduced by the high dose of DACT (8.4% reduction), this reduction did not exceed the criteria for selecting the maximum tolerated dose (e.g., a dose that causes >10% decrease in BW at necropsy). None of the lower doses of DACT caused a significant difference in BW gain. Additionally, 33.8, 67.5, and 135 mg/kg of DACT significantly increased the BW on the day of VO. PRO (107 or 213 mg/kg) delayed VO by 4 days but did not alter the BW on PND 41. While no significant delays in pubertal development were observed in two separate dose-response studies with doses ranging up to 183 mg/kg (OH-ATR), a minor but statistically significant delay in the onset of puberty in a pilot study using OH-ATR raises the possibility that an effect might occur following exposure to higher doses. However, it is clear from these data that OH-ATR has a much lower potency when compared with equimolar doses of DACT and PRO. Together, these data demonstrate that PRO and DACT can delay the onset of puberty in the female rat at doses equimolar to ATR and provide the scientific basis for the use of additivity in the upcoming risk assessments.