Chiral-induced Spin Selectivity Effect Research Articles

Multistate Switching of Spin Selectivity in Electron Transport Through Light-Driven Molecular Motors

It was established that electron transmission through chiral molecules depends on the electron’s spin. This phenomenon, termed the chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect has been observed in chiral molecules, supramolecular structures, polymers and metal-organic films. Which spin is preferred in the transmission depends on the handedness of the system and the tunneling direction of the electrons. Molecular motors based on overcrowded alkenes show multiple inversions of helical chirality under light irradiation and thermal relaxation. We show here multistate switching of spin selectivity in electron transfer through first generation molecular motors based on the four accessible distinct helical configurations, measured by magnetic-conductive atomic force microscopy. The efficient spin polarization observed in the photostationary state of the right-handed motor coupled with the modulation of spin selectivity through the controlled sequence of helical states opens opportunities to tune spin selectivity on-demand with high spatio-temporal precision. An energetic analysis correlates the spin injection barrier with the extent of spin polarization.

Correlation between Ferromagnetic Layer Easy Axis and the Tilt Angle of Self Assembled Chiral Molecules

The spin–spin interactions between chiral molecules and ferromagnetic metals were found to be strongly affected by the chiral induced spin selectivity effect. Previous works unraveled two complementary phenomena: magnetization reorientation of ferromagnetic thin film upon adsorption of chiral molecules and different interaction rate of opposite enantiomers with a magnetic substrate. These phenomena were all observed when the easy axis of the ferromagnet was out of plane. In this work, the effects of the ferromagnetic easy axis direction, on both the chiral molecular monolayer tilt angle and the magnetization reorientation of the magnetic substrate, are studied using magnetic force microscopy. We have also studied the effect of an applied external magnetic field during the adsorption process. Our results show a clear correlation between the ferromagnetic layer easy axis direction and the tilt angle of the bonded molecules. This tilt angle was found to be larger for an in plane easy axis as compared to an out of plane easy axis. Adsorption under external magnetic field shows that magnetization reorientation occurs also after the adsorption event. These findings show that the interaction between chiral molecules and ferromagnetic layers stabilizes the magnetic reorientation, even after the adsorption, and strongly depends on the anisotropy of the magnetic substrate. This unique behavior is important for developing enantiomer separation techniques using magnetic substrates.

An Ideal Spin Filter: Long-Range, High-Spin Selectivity in Chiral Helicoidal 3-Dimensional Metal Organic Frameworks.

An enantiopure, conductive, and paramagnetic crystalline 3-D metal-organic framework (MOF), based on Dy(III) and the l-tartrate chiral ligand, is proved to behave as an almost ideal electron spin filtering material at room temperature, transmitting one spin component only, leading to a spin polarization (SP) power close to 100% in the ±2 V range, which is conserved over a long spatial range, larger than 1 μm in some cases. This impressive spin polarization capacity of this class of nanostructured materials is measured by means of magnetically polarized conductive atomic force microscopy and is attributed to the Chirality-Induced Spin Selectivity (CISS) effect of the material arising from a multidimensional helicity pattern, the inherited chirality of the organic motive, and the enhancing influence of Dy(III) ions on the CISS effect, with large spin-orbit coupling values. Our results represent the first example of a MOF-based and CISS-effect-mediated spin filtering material that shows a nearly perfect SP. These striking results obtained with our robust and easy-to-synthesize chiral MOFs constitute an important step forward in to improve the performance of spin filtering materials for spintronic device fabrication.

Influence of Electronic Structure Modeling and Junction Structure on First-Principles Chiral Induced Spin Selectivity.

We have carried out a comprehensive study of the influence of electronic structure modeling and junction structure description on the first-principles calculation of the spin polarization in molecular junctions caused by the chiral induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect. We explore the limits and the sensitivity to modeling decisions of a Landauer/Green's function/two-component density functional theory approach to CISS. We find that although the CISS effect is entirely attributed in the literature to molecular spin filtering, spin-orbit coupling being partially inherited from the metal electrodes plays an important role in our calculations on ideal carbon helices, even though this effect cannot explain the experimental conductance results. Its magnitude depends considerably on the shape, size, and material of the metal clusters modeling the electrodes. Also, a pronounced dependence on the specific description of exchange interaction and spin-orbit coupling is manifest in our approach. This is important because the interplay between exchange effects and spin-orbit coupling may play an important role in the description of the junction magnetic response. Our calculations are relevant for the whole field of spin-polarized electron transport and electron transfer, because there is still an open discussion in the literature about the detailed underlying mechanism and the magnitude of physical parameters that need to be included to achieve a consistent description of the CISS effect: seemingly good quantitative agreement between simulation and the experiment can be caused by error compensation, because spin polarization as contained in a Landauer/Green's function/two-component density functional theory approach depends strongly on computational and structural parameters.

Take a cue from nature: Promoting electrocatalytic watersplitting with a helping hand of hemoglobin

Electrocatalytic water splitting is a promising approach to generating hydrogen from water. In order to enhance water splitting efficiency, it is essential to promote gas revolution from catalysts surface, reduce the over-potential of oxygen evolution (OER), and inhibit the production of the hydrogen peroxide by-product. To realize them, in this work, we take a cue from nature to promote water splitting activity of hollow porous Fe3O4 microspheres (M−Fe3O4) with the aids of hemoglobin. Hemoglobin monolayer was self-assembled on the surface of M−Fe3O4 catalysts. It transported newly-generated oxygen molecules away from catalysts surface and exhibited chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect during OER reaction. Owing to the “helping hand” of hemoglobin, the OER onset potential of hollow porous Fe3O4 microspheres reduced by 100 mV and the current density was enhanced 2 folds. The results indicate a new strategy for designing earth-abundant catalysts which combine the merits of oxygen transferring and CISS effect for electrocatalytic water splitting.

Spin-dependent electron transport along hairpinlike DNA molecules

The chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS), demonstrated in diverse chiral molecules by numerous experimental and theoretical groups, has been attracting extensive and ongoing interest in recent years. As the secondary structure of DNA, the charge transfer along DNA hairpins has been widely studied for more than two decades, finding that DNA hairpins exhibit spin-related effects as reported in recent experiments. Here, we propose a setup to demonstrate directly the CISS effect in DNA hairpins contacted by two nonmagnetic leads at both ends of the stem. Our results indicate that DNA hairpins present pronounced CISS effect and the spin polarization could be enhanced by using conducting molecules as the loop. In particular, DNA hairpins show several intriguing features, which are different from other chiral molecules. First, the local spin currents can flow circularly and assemble into a number of vortex clusters when the electron energy locates in the left/right electronic band of the stem. The chirality of vortex clusters in each band is the same and will be reversed by switching the electron energy from the left band to the right one, inducing the sign reversal of the spin polarization. Interestingly, the local spin currents can be greater than the corresponding spin component of the source-drain current. Second, both the conductance and the spin polarization can increase with molecular length as well as dephasing strength, contrary to the physical intuition that the transmission ability of molecular wires should be poorer when suffering from stronger scattering. Third, we unveil the optimal contact configuration of efficient electron transport and that of the CISS effect, which are distinct from each other and can be controlled by dephasing strength. The underlying physical mechanism is illustrated.

Chiral Induced Spin Selectivity Gives a New Twist on Spin-Control in Chemistry.

ConspectusThe electron’s spin, its intrinsic angular momentum, is a quantum property that plays a critical role in determining the electronic structure of molecules. Despite its importance, it is not used often for controlling chemical processes, photochemistry excluded. The reason is that many organic molecules have a total spin zero, namely, all the electrons are paired. Even for molecules with high spin multiplicity, the spin orientation is usually only weakly coupled to the molecular frame of nuclei and hence to the molecular orientation. Therefore, controlling the spin orientation usually does not provide a handle on controlling the geometry of the molecular species during a reaction. About two decades ago, however, a new phenomenon was discovered that relates the electron’s spin to the handedness of chiral molecules and is now known as the chiral induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect. It was established that the efficiency of electron transport through chiral molecules depends on the electron spin and that it changes with the enantiomeric form of a molecule and the direction of the electron’s linear momentum. This property means that, for chiral molecules, the electron spin is strongly coupled to the molecular frame. Over the past few years, we and others have shown that this feature can be used to provide spin-control over chemical reactions and to perform enantioseparations with magnetic surfaces.In this Account, we describe the CISS effect and demonstrate spin polarization effects on chemical reactions. Explicitly, we describe a number of processes that can be controlled by the electron’s spin, among them the interaction of chiral molecules with ferromagnetic surfaces, the multielectron oxidation of water, and enantiospecific electrochemistry. Interestingly, it has been shown that the effect also takes place in inorganic chiral oxides like copper oxide, aluminum oxide, and cobalt oxide. The CISS effect results from the coupling between the electron linear momentum and its spin in a chiral system. Understanding the implications of this interaction promises to reveal a previously unappreciated role for chirality in biology, where chiral molecules are ubiquitous, and opens a new avenue into spin-controlled processes in chemistry.

Enantiospecific Response in Cross-Polarization Solid-State Nuclear Magnetic Resonance of Optically Active Metal Organic Frameworks.

We report herein on a NMR-based enantiospecific response for a family of optically active metal-organic frameworks. Cross-polarization of the 1H-13C couple was performed, and the intensities of the 13C nuclei NMR signals were measured to be different for the two enantiomers. In a direct-pulse experiment, which prevents cross-polarization, the intensity difference of the 13C NMR signals of the two nanostructured enantiomers vanished. This result is due to changes of the nuclear spin relaxation times due to the electron spin spatial asymmetry induced by chemical bond polarization involving a chiral center. These experiments put forward on firm ground that the chiral-induced spin selectivity effect, which induces chemical bond polarization in the J-coupling, is the mechanism responsible for the enantiospecific response. The implications of this finding for the theory of this molecular electron spin polarization effect and the development of quantum biosensing and quantum storage devices are discussed.

Reinforced Room-Temperature Spin Filtering in Chiral Paramagnetic Metallopeptides.

Chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS), whereby helical molecules polarize the spin of electrical current, is an intriguing effect with potential applications in nanospintronics. In this nascent field, the study of the CISS effect using paramagnetic chiral molecules, which could introduce another degree of freedom in controlling the spin transport, remains so far unexplored. To address this challenge, herein we propose the use of self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of helical lanthanide-binding peptides. To elucidate the effect of the paramagnetic nuclei, monolayers of the peptide coordinating paramagnetic or diamagnetic ions are prepared. By means of spin-dependent electrochemistry, the CISS effect is demonstrated by cyclic voltammetry and electrochemical impedance measurements for both samples. Additionally, an implementation of the standard liquid-metal drop electron transport setup has been carried out, and this process helped to demonstrate the peptides' suitability for solid-state devices. Remarkably, the inclusion of a paramagnetic center in the peptide increases the spin polarization as was independently proved by different techniques. These findings permit the inclusion of magnetic biomolecules in the CISS field and pave the way to their implementation in a new generation of (bio)spintronic nanodevices.

Spin-Dependent Enantioselective Electropolymerization

The electro-oxidative polymerization of an enantiopure chiral 3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene monomer, performed using spin-polarized currents, is shown to depend on the electron spin orientation. The spin-polarized current is shown to influence the initial nucleation rate of the polymerization reaction. This observation is rationalized in the framework of the chiral-induced spin selectivity effect.

Vibration-enhanced spin-selective transport of electrons in the DNA double helix

The spin-selective transport through helical molecules has been a hot topic in condensed matter physics, because it develops a new research direction in spintronics, \emph{i.e.}, chiro-spintronics. Double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) molecules have been considered as promising candidates to study this topic, since the chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect in dsDNA was observed in experiment. Considering that the dsDNA molecules are usually flexible in mechanical properties, vibration may be one of important factors to influence the CISS effect. Here, we investigate the influences of electron-vibration interaction (EVI) on the spin-selective transport in dsDNA molecules. We uncover that the EVI not only enhances the CISS effect and the spin polarization ($P_s$) in dsDNA, but also induces a series of new spin-splitting transmission modes. More interesting, these vibration-induced transmission spectra tend to host the same $P_s$ values as those of the original spin-splitting transmission modes, making the $P_s$ spectra to display as a continuous platform even in the energy gap. Our work not only provides us a deep understanding into the influence of vibrations on the CISS effect in helical molecules, {but also puts forwards a feasible route to detect the vibration-induced spin-polarized transport in low-dimensional molecular systems

Magneto-Optical Detection of Photoinduced Magnetism via Chirality-Induced Spin Selectivity in 2D Chiral Hybrid Organic-Inorganic Perovskites.

The recent convergence of chiral molecules with metal halide perovskite frameworks gives rise to an interesting family of chiral systems: two-dimensional, chiral hybrid organic-inorganic perovskites (chiral-HOIPs). While possessing photovoltaic properties of traditional HOIPs, this class of materials is endowed with chirality through its organic ligands in which the degeneracy of the electron spin in charge transport is broken. That is, the chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect manifests, making it a promising platform to bridge opto-spintronic studies and the CISS effect. In this work, chiral-HOIP/NiFe heterostructures are studied by means of the magneto-optical Kerr effect using a Sagnac interferometer. Upon illumination of the chiral-HOIPs, the Kerr signal at the chiral-HOIP/NiFe interface changes, and a linear dependence of the response on the magnetic field is observed. The sign of the slope was found to depend on the chirality of the HOIPs. The results demonstrate the utility of chiral-HOIP materials for chiral opto-spintronic applications.

Highly Distorted Chiral Two-Dimensional Tin Iodide Perovskites for Spin Polarized Charge Transport.

Incorporating chiral organic molecules into organic/inorganic hybrid 2D metal-halide perovskites results in a novel family of chiral hybrid semiconductors with unique spin-dependent properties. The embedded chiral organic moieties induce a chiroptical response from the inorganic metal-halide sublattice. However, the structural interplay between the chiral organic molecules and the inorganic sublattice, as well as their synergic effect on the resulting electronic band structure need to be explored in a broader material scope. Here we present three new layered tin iodide perovskites templated by chiral (R/S-)methylbenzylammonium (R/S-MBA), i.e., (R-/S-MBA)2SnI4, and their racemic phase (rac-MBA)2SnI4. These MBA2SnI4 compounds exhibit the largest level of octahedral bond distortion compared to any other reported layered tin iodide perovskite. The incorporation of chiral MBA cations leads to circularly polarized absorption from the inorganic Sn-I sublattice, displaying chiroptical activity in the 300-500 nm wavelength range. The bandgap and chiroptical activity are modulated by alloying Sn with Pb, in the series of (MBA)2Pb1-xSnxI4. Finally, we show that vertical charge transport through oriented (R-/S-MBA)2SnI4 thin films is highly spin-dependent, arising from a chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect. We demonstrate a spin-polarization in the current-voltage characteristics as high as 94%. Our work shows the tremendous potential of these chiral hybrid semiconductors for controlling both spin and charge degrees of freedom.

Efficient Spin Selectivity in Self-Assembled Superhelical Conducting Polymer Microfibers.

Chiral materials, natural or synthetic, have been widely studied since Pasteur's separation of enantiomers over a century ago. The connection between electron transmission and chirality was, however, established recently where one spin was preferably selected by the chiral molecules, displaying a typical chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect. Currently, this CISS effect was mainly demonstrated in the molecular-scale devices. Herein, we explored this effect in a microscale device where an efficient spin selectivity was found in the self-assembled superhelical conducting polyaniline (PANI) microfibers. A spin-selective efficiency up to 80% (not magnetoresistance) was achieved when spins traversed the ca. 2-6 μm-long helical channels at room temperature. Importantly, the long-range ordering of chiral PANI molecules is crucial to observe this efficient spin selectivity, whereas no selective transmission was found in the "amorphous" chiral PANIs. This efficient spin selectivity was subsequently rationalized by using an extended Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model where the Rashba spin-orbit coupling was considered. We expect these results could inspire the research of organic spintronics by using molecularly ordered, self-assembled, and chiral π-conjugated materials.

Analytic Model of Chiral-Induced Spin Selectivity.

Organic materials are known to feature long spin-diffusion times, originating in a generally small spin–orbit coupling observed in these systems. From that perspective, chiral molecules acting as efficient spin selectors pose a puzzle that attracted a lot of attention in recent years. Here, we revisit the physical origins of chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) and propose a simple analytic minimal model to describe it. The model treats a chiral molecule as an anisotropic wire with molecular dipole moments aligned arbitrarily with respect to the wire’s axes and is therefore quite general. Importantly, it shows that the helical structure of the molecule is not necessary to observe CISS and other chiral nonhelical molecules can also be considered as potential candidates for the CISS effect. We also show that the suggested simple model captures the main characteristics of CISS observed in the experiment, without the need for additional constraints employed in the previous studies. The results pave the way for understanding other related physical phenomena where the CISS effect plays an essential role.

Insight into the Origin of Chiral-Induced Spin Selectivity from a Symmetry Analysis of Electronic Transmission.

The chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect, which describes the spin-filtering ability of diamagnetic structures like DNA or peptides having chiral symmetry, has emerged in the past years as the central mechanism behind a number of important phenomena, like long-range biological electron transfer, enantiospecific electrocatalysis, and molecular recognition. Also, CISS-induced spin polarization has a considerable promise for new spintronic devices and the design of quantum materials. The CISS effect is attributed to spin-orbit coupling, but a sound theoretical understanding of the surprising magnitude of this effect in molecules without heavy atoms is currently lacking. We are taking an essential step into this direction by analyzing the importance of imaginary terms in the Hamiltonian as a necessary condition for nonvanishing spin polarization in helical structures. On the basis of first-principles calculations and analytical considerations, we perform a symmetry analysis of the key quantities determining transport probabilities of electrons of different spin orientations. These imaginary terms originate from the spin-orbit coupling, and they preserve the Hermitian nature of the Hamiltonian. Hence, they are not related to the breaking of time-reversal symmetry resulting from the fact that molecules are open systems in a junction. Our symmetry analysis helps to identify essential constraints in the theoretical description of the CISS effect. We further draw an analogy with the appearance of imaginary terms in simple models of barrier scattering, which may help understanding the unusually effective long-range electron transfer in biological systems.

Effect of Chiral Molecules on the Electron's Spin Wavefunction at Interfaces.

Kelvin-probe measurements on ferromagnetic thin film electrodes coated with self-assembled monolayers of chiral molecules reveal that the electron penetration from the metal electrode into the chiral molecules depends on the ferromagnet’s magnetization direction and the molecules’ chirality. Electrostatic potential differences as large as 100 mV are observed. These changes arise from the applied oscillating electric field, which drives spin-dependent charge penetration from the ferromagnetic substrate to the chiral molecules. The enantiospecificity of the response is studied as a function of the magnetization strength, the magnetization direction, and the handedness and length of the chiral molecules. These new phenomena are rationalized in terms of the chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect, in which one spin orientation of electrons from the ferromagnet penetrates more easily into a chiral molecule than does the other orientation. The large potential changes (>kT at room temperature) manifested here imply that this phenomenon is important for spin transport in chiral spintronic devices and for magneto-electrochemistry of chiral molecules.

Comment on “Spin-dependent electron transmission model for chiral molecules in mesoscopic devices”

In a model presented in Yang et al. [Phys. Rev. B 99, 024418 (2019)] it was stated that in the linear regime spin selectivity cannot be measured when using two contacts configuration, and that the results observed when studying the chiral-induced spin-selectivity effect are not consistent with this statement. Here we claim that the results cited clearly indicate nonlinearity and therefore the spin selectivity observed is valid observation.

Highly Efficient and Tunable Filtering of Electrons' Spin by Supramolecular Chirality of Nanofiber-Based Materials.

Organic semiconductors and organic-inorganic hybrids are promising materials for spintronic-based memory devices. Recently, an alternative route to organic spintronic based on chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) is suggested. In the CISS effect, the chirality of the molecular system itself acts as a spin filter, thus avoiding the use of magnets for spin injection. Here, spin filtering in excess of 85% in helical π-conjugated materials based on supramolecular nanofibers at room temperature is reported. The high spin-filtering efficiency can even be observed in nanofibers assembled from mixtures of chiral and achiral molecules through chiral amplification effect. Furthermore and most excitingly, it is shown that both "up" and "down" orientations of filtered spins can be obtained in a single enantiopure system via the temperature-dependent helicity (P and M) inversion of supramolecular nanofibers. The findings showcase that materials based on helical noncovalently assembled systems are modular platforms with an emerging structure-property relationship for spintronic applications.

Spin-Dependent Electron Transport through Bacterial Cell Surface Multiheme Electron Conduits.

Multiheme cytochromes, located on the bacterial cell surface, function as long-distance (>10 nm) electron conduits linking intracellular reactions to external surfaces. This extracellular electron transfer process, which allows microorganisms to gain energy by respiring solid redox-active minerals, also facilitates the wiring of cells to electrodes. While recent studies have suggested that a chiral induced spin selectivity effect is linked to efficient electron transmission through biomolecules, this phenomenon has not been investigated in extracellular electron conduits. Using magnetic conductive probe atomic force microscopy, Hall voltage measurements, and spin-dependent electrochemistry of the decaheme cytochromes MtrF and OmcA from the metal-reducing bacterium Shewanella oneidensis MR-1, we show that electron transport through these extracellular conduits is spin-selective. Our study has implications for understanding how spin-dependent interactions and magnetic fields may control electron transport across biotic-abiotic interfaces in both natural and biotechnological systems.