This research explores the properties of bionanocomposite films prepared by binding recombinant resilin-like protein (res) consisting of the exon 1 resilin sequence from Drosophila melanogaster, engineered to include a cellulose binding domain (CBD), to cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs). The optimal binding of res-CBD to CNCs was 1:5 by mass, and the resulting res-CBD-CNCs remained colloidally stable in water. Res-CBD-CNCs were solventcast into transparent, free-standing films, which were more hydrophobic than neat CNC films, with water contact angles of 70–80° compared to 35–40° for the latter. In contrast to the multi-domain orientation typical of chiral nematic CNC films, res-CBD-CNC and CBD-CNC films exhibited long-range, uniaxial orientation that was apparently driven by the CBD moiety. Glycerol was studied as an additive in the films to determine whether the addition of a wet component to solvate the recombinant protein improved the mechanical properties of the res-CBD-CNC films. In comparison to the other films, res-CBD-CNC films were more elastic with added glycerol, in the range of 0.5–5 wt% (i.e., the films responded more elastically to a given strain and/or were less plastically deformed by a given mechanical load), but became less elastic at 25 wt% glycerol. Overall, films made of res-CBD-CNCs plus 0.5 wt% glycerol displayed improved mechanical properties compared to neat CNC films, with an increase in toughness of 150% and in elasticity of 100%.