This work represents an initial effort to describe expectations and attitudes that might contribute to variation in the caregiving role as it relates to feeding young children. The study also investigates the impact of performance contexts on attitudes about one aspect of caregiving—feeding. One hundred twenty-four primary caregivers of typically developing infants from 4 to 28 months were interviewed about their expectations for developmental milestones related to feeding and their attitudes about how a parent should respond to different meal-time behaviors of children. Reliability of the instruments was explored. Test-retest reliability of caregiver expectations for when milestones were expected, as captured on Feeding Skills Development, ranged from good (.87) to poor (not significant). Reliability of attitudes captured by the second instrument, Feeding Stories, ranged from moderate to poor. The multidimensional contributions of temporal and social contexts on the attitudes of caregivers about feeding practices were examined. The older the participant the more relaxed approach to what and when a baby ate. The pattern of association of social context and parental value was different for participants who were African American and those who were white. Results are discussed in the light of possible factors that contribute to caregivers' ideas about their young child with special needs and feeding issues. It is suggested that these thoughts might frame how the caregiver responds to feeding intervention suggestions.