Introduction Pneumonia remains the principal cause of death of children under 5 in developing countries. Evidence from nearly 20 studies associates exposure to pollution from biomass fuels with increased risk of acute lower respiratory infections (ALRI). However, all these studies have been observational designs, very few with exposure assessment, and with inconsistent case ascertainment and definition. To strengthen this evidence, a randomised controlled trial (RCT) is currently underway in Guatemala to measure the effect of an improved stove on ALRI incidence. This provides the first opportunity to study health effects of air pollution in a randomised intervention, largely free of confounding which typically complicates interpretation in environmental epidemiology. This paper describes the methods used for standardised case-finding. Method The sample includes 500 children in a poor rural area of north-western Guatemala. At recruitment, children were aged less than 4 months, or in utero. Each child is being followed to age 18 months. Following baseline questionnaires, a random 50% of homes received plancha stoves-a well–accepted local product known to reduce indoor air pollution by up to 80–90%. Case finding is carried out at three levels: (a) household visits, (b) referral to a study physician, and (c) referral to the district hospital. Fieldworkers trained in IMCI case recognition visit each home weekly, using standard questions and examination (including respiratory rate) to identify possible ALRI cases. This process is very sensitive, but not very specific. Anthropological work was undertaken to identify symptom terms in the local (Mam) language with correct meanings. Children meeting ALRI criteria are referred to a physician, based in a community centre: this helps to maintain blindness of the physician to the intervention/control status of each child's home. Physician assessment utilises standardised clinical criteria, based on prior WHO studies and re-enforced through clinical training sessions. Such sessions are also carried out at regular intervals to maintain consistency. All children with signs of ALRI are referred for chest X-ray (CXR), and RSV antigen testing and pulse oximetry (PO) are carried out. The use of CXR and PO provide additional ‘objective’ assessment of each child, and RSV testing will allow comparison of IAP risk in bronchiolitis and pneumonia cases. Severely ill children are admitted to hospital, and additional clinical information collected at discharge. All deaths are being assessed by verbal autopsy. Conclusion Primary case definition is determined by the study physician, combining clinical findings, CXR, and hospital information, with PO providing a measure of severity. Independent, blind assessment of CXRs and verbal autopsy reports will also be available. Experience with this system of case finding will be reported, including numbers of ALRI cases treated at home and admitted, and %RSV positive. Also analysed will be the differences in numbers and characteristics of ALRI cases defined by (a) IMCI criteria at weekly visit, (b) physician examination with CXR, and (c) CXR findings only. Practical issues in maintaining standardised procedures, and referring children for CXR and admission in a rural population fearful of the hospital will also be reported.
Read full abstract