This paper begins with a personal view of the consequences of introducing a number of CAL packages, associated with experiment-planning, into the physical chemistry teaching laboratory. That raises questions which lead to a study of some modes of presentation of textbook material which appear unsatisfactory. The first part of the paper concludes with a survey of previous criticisms of the physical chemistry syllabus, and of the largely ineffectual attempts at revision and reconstruction which ensued therefrom. The second part of the paper aims to demonstrate that a straight-forward approach combining elements of operational research with the experience of the CALCHEM Project of the National Development Programme in Computer Assisted Learning has real potential for syllabus reconstruction in the first-year teaching laboratory. A critique of the traditional version of one particular exercise, in terms of both intellectual content and student performance, points to the need to address a list of educational objectives. both global and specific. The case study which follows illustrates how such objectives were deduced from the inadequacies of student understanding of the phenomena in question, and how combining these exercise-specific objectives with the global objectives defines a general scheme, and thence a detailed procedure, for the experiment. Student response to two different ways of presenting this scheme and procedure is described. The oral tutorial mode is more effective than that using a comprehensive typescript. It is observed that student response appears to be adversely affected by the exercise being encountered in the context of traditional recipe-following assignments. It is nevertheless concluded that this reconstruction of a traditional experiment does enhance learning opportunities. Finally the occasional want of rigour in physical chemistry textbooks is juxtaposed to the traditional teaching laboratory approach, described as ritualistic rather than scientific, raising the question whether the connexion between the two might be the failure to formulate either global or exercise-specific learning objectives. It is claimed to have been demonstrated that the methodology here described does provide a feasible strategy for reconstructing the laboratory syllabus so as to render attainable at least the list of global learning objectives enumerated in the paper.
Read full abstract