Cheese Flavor Development Research Articles

Seasonal Evolution of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Peptide Contents in Cheeses Made from Ewe's Goat's or Cow's Milk

Proteolysis is the principal and most complex biochemical event occurring during the maturation of the majority of ripened cheese varieties. In addition to softening the cheese body, proteolysis influences the development of cheese flavour via the formation of amino acid and peptides which make a direct contribution to flavour. Goat, cow and sheep cheeses have been elaborated with raw milk and calf rennet. The extent of proteolysis was monitored over six months of ripening and means of HPLC peptide profile analysis. The influence of season on the changes in hydrophobic and hydrophilic peptides and the HO/HI ratio during the ripening of the cheeses were studied.

Isolation of lactic acid bacteria from Lighvan cheese, a semihard cheese made from raw sheep milk in Iran

The lactic acid bacteria contributing to Lighvan cheese ripening during the different stages of production were investigated. Isolated strains from different culture media were identified phenotypically to species and subspecies level. In total, 413 strains were isolated from raw milk, 1‐day‐old cheese and fully ripened cheese. The most abundant species belonged to Enterococcus faecium (87 isolates), Lactococcus lactis ssp. lactis (68 isolates), Enterococcus faecalis (55 isolates) and Lactobacillus plantarum (48 isolates). E. faecium, Lc. lactis and Lb. plantarum were the predominantly isolated strains from ripened cheese. Therefore, they may contribute considerably to the aroma and flavour development of Lighvan cheese.

Heterologous Production of Methionine-γ-Lyase from Brevibacterium linens in Lactococcus lactis and Formation of Volatile Sulfur Compounds

The conversion of methionine to volatile sulfur compounds (VSCs) is of great importance in flavor formation during cheese ripening and is the focus of biotechnological approaches toward flavor improvement. A synthetic mgl gene encoding methionine-gamma-lyase (MGL) from Brevibacterium linens BL2 was cloned into a Lactococcus lactis expression plasmid under the control of the nisin-inducible promoter PnisA. When expressed in L. lactis and purified as a recombinant protein, MGL was shown to degrade L-methionine as well as other sulfur-containing compounds such as L-cysteine, L-cystathionine, and L-cystine. Overproduction of MGL in recombinant L. lactis also resulted in an increase in the degradation of these compounds compared to the wild-type strain. Importantly, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis identified considerably higher formation of methanethiol (and its oxidized derivatives dimethyl disulfide and dimethyl trisulfide) in reactions containing either purified protein, whole cells, or cell extracts from the heterologous L. lactis strain. This is the first report of production of MGL from B. linens in L. lactis. Given their significance in cheese flavor development, the use of lactic acid bacteria with enhanced VSC-producing abilities could be an efficient way to enhance cheese flavor development.

IMPROVEMENT OF QUALITY OF RAS CHEESE MADE FROM PASTEURIZED MILK USING A SPECIAL SLURRY FROM EWE'S MILK

The present study was carried out as an at-tempt to improve the quality of Ras cheese made from pasteurized cow's milk using ewe's milk slurry to which proteases and lipases were added. The slurry was incubated at 30oC for one week, and then added either to the cheese milk prior to coag-ulation or directly to the cheese curd before press-ing. Cheeses were analysed for chemical, microbi-ological and organoleptic properties at 0, 15, 30, 60 and 90 d of ripening. Generally, the addition of slurry affected at least four parameters of interest for the flavour development. Cheese flavour devel-opment was accelerated, the proteolysis was en-hanced and casein breakdown was stimulated. Addition of slurry increased the levels of the total volatile fatty acids at each period of ripening, par-ticularly with addition of slurry to cheese curd. Ad-dition of slurry affected the microbiological quality of cheeses. Proteolytic and lipolytic bacterial counts increased throughout ripening, while yeast and moulds were no longer detectable in slurry added cheese after 30 d of ripening. Sensory eval-uation showed that the Ras cheeses made with the slurry received higher scores for flavor and body and texture than the control cheese over 90 d of ripening. These results suggested that the addition of ewe's milk slurry was necessary for develop-ment of sensory characteristics of the cheeses.

Role of Cystathionine β-Lyase in Catabolism of Amino Acids to Sulfur Volatiles by Genetic Variants of Lactobacillus helveticus CNRZ 32

Catabolism of sulfur-containing amino acids plays an important role in the development of cheese flavor. During ripening, cystathionine beta-lyase (CBL) is believed to contribute to the formation of volatile sulfur compounds (VSCs) such as methanethiol and dimethyl disulfide. However, the role of CBL in the generation of VSCs from the catabolism of specific sulfur-containing amino acids is not well characterized. The objective of this study was to investigate the role of CBL in VSC formation by Lactobacillus helveticus CNRZ 32 using genetic variants of L. helveticus CNRZ 32 including the CBL-null mutant, complementation of the CBL-null mutant, and the CBL overexpression mutant. The formation of VSCs from methionine, cystathionine, and cysteine was determined in a model system using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry with solid-phase microextraction. With methionine as a substrate, CBL overexpression resulted in higher VSC production than that of wild-type L. helveticus CNRZ 32 or the CBL-null mutant. However, there were no differences in VSC production between the wild type and the CBL-null mutant. With cystathionine, methanethiol production was detected from the CBL overexpression variant and complementation of the CBL-null mutant, implying that CBL may be involved in the conversion of cystathionine to methanethiol. With cysteine, no differences in VSC formation were observed between the wild type and genetic variants, indicating that CBL does not contribute to the conversion of cysteine.

Comparative High-Density Microarray Analysis of Gene Expression during Growth of Lactobacillus helveticus in Milk versus Rich Culture Medium

Lactobacillus helveticus CNRZ32 is used by the dairy industry to modulate cheese flavor. The compilation of a draft genome sequence for this strain allowed us to identify and completely sequence 168 genes potentially important for the growth of this organism in milk or for cheese flavor development. The primary aim of this study was to investigate the expression of these genes during growth in milk and MRS medium by using microarrays. Oligonucleotide probes against each of the completely sequenced genes were compiled on maskless photolithography-based DNA microarrays. Additionally, the entire draft genome sequence was used to produce tiled microarrays in which noninterrupted sequence contigs were covered by consecutive 24-mer probes and associated mismatch probe sets. Total RNA isolated from cells grown in skim milk or in MRS to mid-log phase was used as a template to synthesize cDNA, followed by Cy3 labeling and hybridization. An analysis of data from annotated gene probes identified 42 genes that were upregulated during the growth of CNRZ32 in milk (P < 0.05), and 25 of these genes showed upregulation after applying Bonferroni's adjustment. The tiled microarrays identified numerous additional genes that were upregulated in milk versus MRS. Collectively, array data showed the growth of CNRZ32 in milk-induced genes encoding cell-envelope proteinases, oligopeptide transporters, and endopeptidases as well as enzymes for lactose and cysteine pathways, de novo synthesis, and/or salvage pathways for purines and pyrimidines and other functions. Genes for a hypothetical phosphoserine utilization pathway were also differentially expressed. Preliminary experiments indicate that cheese-derived, phosphoserine-containing peptides increase growth rates of CNRZ32 in a chemically defined medium. These results suggest that phosphoserine is used as an energy source during the growth of L. helveticus CNRZ32.

Evaluation of isolated starter lactic acid bacteria in Ras cheese ripening and flavour development

Eighteen cultures of starter lactic acid bacteria with or without added adjunct cultures, isolated from Egyptian dairy products, were evaluated in experimental Ras cheese for flavour development. Chemical composition of experimental cheeses was within the legal limit for Ras cheese in Egypt. All cultures used in this study had no effect on chemical composition of Ras cheese. Very significant variations in free amino acids, free fatty acids and sensory evaluation have been found among the cultures used in Ras cheesemaking. The levels of free amino acids and free fatty acids were correlated well with flavour development in Ras cheese. Seven of the tested cultures produced acceptable flavour and texture of Ras cheese. The highest overall score of flavour intensity, flavour and texture acceptability were in cheese made using YY47 lactic culture in addition to adjunct culture of Lactobacillus helveticus, Lactobacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei, Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. lactis and Enterococcus faecium. This culture can be recommended for Ras cheese manufacture using pasteurized milk.

YtjE from Lactococcus lactis IL1403 Is a C-S Lyase with α,γ-Elimination Activity toward Methionine

Cheese microbiota and the enzymatic conversion of methionine to volatile sulfur compounds (VSCs) are important factors in flavor formation during cheese ripening and the foci in biotechnological approaches to flavor improvement. The product of ytjE of Lactococcus lactis IL1403, suggested to be a methionine-specific aminotransferase based on genome sequence analysis, was therefore investigated for its role in methionine catabolism. The ytjE gene from Lactococcus lactis IL1403 was cloned in Escherichia coli and overexpressed and purified as a recombinant protein. When tested, the YtjE protein did not exhibit a specific methionine aminotransferase activity. Instead, YtjE exhibited C-S lyase activity and shared homology with the MalY/PatC family of enzymes involved in the degradation of L-cysteine, L-cystine, and L-cystathionine. YtjE was also shown to exhibit alpha,gamma-elimination activity toward L-methionine. In addition, gas chromatographic-mass spectrometry analysis showed that YtjE activity resulted in the formation of H2S from L-cysteine and methanethiol (and its oxidized derivatives dimethyl disulfide and dimethyl trisulfide) from L-methionine. Given their significance in cheese flavor development, VSC production by YtjE could offer an additional approach for the development of cultures with optimized aromatic properties.

Cell membrane damage induced by lacticin 3147 enhances aldehyde formation in Lactococcus lactis IFPL730

Amino acid catabolism is mainly initiated in Lactococcus lactis by a transamination reaction that leads to the formation of α-keto acids. In addition, a novel α-keto acid decarboxylase enzyme, rare in lactic acid bacteria, responsible for the conversion of α-keto acids into aldehydes has been reported in L. lactis IFPL730. The effect of lacticin 3147-induced cell damage on both amino acid transamination and α-keto acid decarboxylation by L. lactis IFPL730 leading to the formation of aldehydes from amino acids was investigated. Cell membrane permeabilization induced by lacticin 3147 facilitated the diffusion of amino acids into the cells and thus, enhanced amino acid transamination and formation of α-keto acids. However, α-keto acid decarboxylation was not affected by cell membrane permeabilization since decarboxylation of α-keto acids in both control and lacticin 3147-treated cells were similar, suggesting that these substrates could freely diffuse inside the cells. Nevertheless, the formation of 2-methylbutyraldehyde from isoleucine was enhanced in lacticin 3147-treated cells. The increase in α-keto acids formation rate by L. lactis IFPL730 due to lacticin 3147-induced cell damage, led to a concomitant increase in the subsequent decarboxylation reaction that complete the metabolic pathway to aldehyde production from amino acids. The present study points out to the use of the food grade lacticin 3147 along with L. lactis IFPL730 as a valuable tool in the development of cheese flavour.

Autolysis of selected Lactobacillus helveticus adjunct strains during Cheddar cheese ripening

Cheddar cheeses were manufactured on a pilot scale (500 L vats) with three different Lactobacillus helveticus strains, which showed varying degrees of autolysis, added as adjuncts to the starter. Autolysis of adjunct strains was monitored by reduction in cell numbers, level of intracellular enzymes released into the cheese, and by the consequent changes in the degree of proteolysis and concentration of free amino acids in the cheese. The flavour profiles of the cheeses at 6 months were also determined. Significant variation in viability of the Lb. helveticus strains, which showed a positive correlation with the indicators of autolysis, was observed. However, cheese manufactured with the most autolytic strain did not receive the highest flavour scores. The results indicate that whereas autolysis of adjunct strains is an important factor in Cheddar cheese flavour development, other factors also contribute to the overall flavour improvement observed.

Involvement of a Branched-Chain Aminotransferase in Production of Volatile Sulfur Compounds in Yarrowia lipolytica

The enzymatic degradation of L-methionine and the subsequent formation of volatile sulfur compounds (VSCs) are essential for the development of the typical flavor in cheese. In the yeast Yarrowia lipolytica, the degradation of L-methionine was accompanied by the formation of the transamination product 4-methylthio-2-oxobutyric acid. A branched-chain aminotransferase gene (YlBCA1) of Y. lipolytica was amplified, and the L-methionine-degrading activity and the aminotransferase activity were measured in a genetically modified strain and compared to those of the parental strain. Our work shows that L-methionine degradation via transamination is involved in formation of VSCs in Y. lipolytica.

Texture and flavour development in Ras cheese made from raw and pasteurised milk

Texture, proteolysis and flavour development in Ras cheeses made from raw or pasteurised milk with two different thermophilic lactic cultures were monitored during ripening. Results showed that at day 1 of manufacture, the moisture content and pH were lower in raw milk cheese than in pasteurised milk cheeses. Levels of water-soluble nitrogen, casein breakdown, free amino groups and free fatty acids were higher in cheese made from raw milk than in that made from pasteurised milk. Textural characteristics, such as hardness, cohesiveness and chewines, increased in all treatments during the first 60 days of ripening due to the reduction in the moisture level during the second stage of salting (dry salting during the first 60 days of ripening). Cheese made from raw milk received the highest texture and flavour scores by panellists.

The Addition of Propionibacterium freudenreichii to Raclette Cheese Induces Biochemical Changes and Enhances Flavor Development

Two mixtures of Propionibacterium freudenreichii commercial strains were tested as adjunct cultures in pasteurized milk Raclette cheese to investigate the ability of propionibacteria (PAB) to enhance flavor development. Cheese flavor was assessed by a trained sensory panel, and levels of free amino acids, free fatty acids, and volatile compounds were determined. The PAB level showed a 1.4 log increase within the ripening period (12 weeks at 11 degrees C). Eye formation, which was not desired, was not observed in PAB cheeses. PAB fermented lactate to acetate and propionate and produced fatty acids by lipolysis, branched chain volatile compounds derived from isoleucine and leucine catabolism and some esters. One of the experimental cheeses received the highest scores for odor and flavor intensity and was characterized by higher frequencies of detection for some minor notes ("propionic"and "whey" odor, "sweet" taste). PAB can therefore be considered as potential adjunct cultures to enhance or modify cheese flavor development.

Propionibacterium freudenreichii strains quantitatively affect production of volatile compounds in Swiss cheese

Cheese flavour is the result of a complex mixture of volatile compounds, originating mainly from the enzymatic degradation of curd components by cheese microflora during cheese ripening. Directing cheese flavour development requires knowledge on inter- and intra-species con- tributions to flavour development, i.e. identification of the volatile (flavour) compounds produced by each strain. The aim of this study was to identify the volatile compounds produced in Swiss cheese by Propionibacterium freudenreichii, one of the species essential for the development of the characteristic flavour of this type of cheese. The volatile profile of compounds obtained from small- scale (1/100) Swiss cheeses, with or without P. freudenreichii, were compared (three strains tested, in association with three thermophilic lactic starters, i.e. twelve cheeses, manufactured in duplicate). Neutral volatile compounds, extracted by dynamic headspace, and free fatty acids were identified using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. The concentrations of all carboxylic acids and 14 of 58 neutral compounds were significantly higher in the presence of propionibacteria (PAB). The three PAB strains tested produced the same volatile compounds, but observed quantitative differen- ces were strain-dependent. Propionic acid and four propionate esters were detected only in the pre- sence of PAB. Moreover, cheeses with PAB contained two- to three- fold higher levels of free fatty acids derived from lipolysis and five- to fifty- fold higher levels of branched-chain compounds deri- ved from isoleucine catabolism (2-methylbutanal, 2-methylbutanol and 2-methylbutanoic acid) and from leucine catabolism (3-methylbutanoic acid). Lactic starters induced significant variations in the concentrations of some of the compounds produced by PAB, such as methylbutanoic acids and free fatty acids, which varied by 2.0 and 1.4, respectively, as a function of the lactobacilli strains. PAB strains affect the concentration of varied volatile compounds and could therefore have distinct contribu- tions to the formation of Swiss cheese flavour. Propionibacterium freudenreichii / volatile compound / Swiss cheese

Identification and Functional Analysis of the Gene Encoding Methionine-γ-Lyase in Brevibacterium linens

The enzymatic degradation of L-methionine and subsequent formation of volatile sulfur compounds (VSCs) is believed to be essential for flavor development in cheese. L-methionine-gamma-lyase (MGL) can convert L-methionine to methanethiol (MTL), alpha-ketobutyrate, and ammonia. The mgl gene encoding MGL was cloned from the type strain Brevibacterium linens ATCC 9175 known to produce copious amounts of MTL and related VSCs. The disruption of the mgl gene, achieved in strain ATCC 9175, resulted in a 62% decrease in thiol-producing activity and a 97% decrease in total VSC production in the knockout strain. Our work shows that L-methionine degradation via gamma-elimination is a key step in the formation of VSCs in B. linens.

The effect of microbial lipase on the lipolysis during the ripening of Tulum cheese

The effect of microbial lipase enzyme addition on the ripening of Tulum cheese was investigated. Commercial microbial lipase (Piccantase A) was added to milk before rennet addition at a level of 0, 0.04, 0.06 and 0.11 g L −1 of cheese milk. Free fatty acids (FFA) (C 2–C 18:1) were analysed in the samples during the ripening period. Total solids, fat, salt, total nitrogen, titratable acidity, acidity index, total free fatty acids of cheeses slightly increased during the ripening period. Total FFAs and volatile FFA contents in cheeses were affected by the level of microbial lipase and their contents were increased significantly during the ripening period ( P < 0.01). The relative amounts of volatile FFAs varied with ripening time and lipase levels. The addition of lipase to cheese milk could be recommended for the acceleration of flavour development in Tulum cheese over a short ripening period.

Overexpression of Lactobacillus casei D-hydroxyisocaproic acid dehydrogenase in cheddar cheese.

Metabolism of aromatic amino acids by lactic acid bacteria is an important source of off-flavor compounds in Cheddar cheese. Previous work has shown that alpha-keto acids produced from Trp, Tyr, and Phe by aminotransferase enzymes are chemically labile and may degrade spontaneously into a variety of off-flavor compounds. However, dairy lactobacilli can convert unstable alpha-keto acids to more-stable alpha-hydroxy acids via the action of alpha-keto acid dehydrogenases such as d-hydroxyisocaproic acid dehydrogenase. To further characterize the role of this enzyme in cheese flavor, the Lactobacillus casei d-hydroxyisocaproic acid dehydrogenase gene was cloned into the high-copy-number vector pTRKH2 and transformed into L. casei ATCC 334. Enzyme assays confirmed that alpha-keto acid dehydrogenase activity was significantly higher in pTRKH2:dhic transformants than in wild-type cells. Reduced-fat Cheddar cheeses were made with Lactococcus lactis starter only, starter plus L. casei ATCC 334, and starter plus L. casei ATCC 334 transformed with pTRKH2:dhic. After 3 months of aging, the cheese chemistry and flavor attributes were evaluated instrumentally by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry and by descriptive sensory analysis. The culture system used significantly affected the concentrations of various ketones, aldehydes, alcohols, and esters and one sulfur compound in cheese. Results further indicated that enhanced expression of d-hydroxyisocaproic acid dehydrogenase suppressed spontaneous degradation of alpha-keto acids, but sensory work indicated that this effect retarded cheese flavor development.

Changes in lipid fractions and sensory properties of Idiazabal cheese induced by lipase addition.

This work studied the addition of an adequate lipase to enhance lipolysis reactions and the development of piquant flavour and sharp odour in Idiazabal cheese, as an alternative to the use of lamb rennet paste. Cheeses were manufactured from bulk raw ewes' milk in 50 l vats with commercial bovine rennet and 80 lipase units of pregastric or 180 lipase units of fungal lipase and ripened for 180 days. A higher lipolytic activity was induced by lipase addition promoting strong changes in odour and flavour attributes. Both fungal and pregastric lipases increased the content of total free fatty acids (FFA), but the fungal lipase released mainly medium- and long-chain FFA. In contrast, the pregastric lipase preferably released short-chain FFA. Diglyceride (DG) content was considerably higher in cheeses made with added pregastric lipase compared with those made with fungal lipase or with no lipase. Monoglycerides (MG) were detected only in cheeses made with either lipase added, reaching comparable concentrations after ripening for 180 days. The cheeses made with pregastric lipase had the highest scores for odour and flavour intensity, and sharp and rennet odours, desirable attributes for the Idiazabal cheese made with lamb rennet paste. None of the texture attributes were significantly influenced by the concentrations of MG and DG in the cheeses made with either lipase. Thus, the pregastric lipase was more appropriate than the fungal lipase to develop a more traditionally-flavoured Idiazabal cheese.

Varied volatile compounds are produced by Propionibacterium freudenreichii in Emmental cheese

Directing cheese flavour development requires to know the respective contribution of each of the cheese microflora. Volatile (flavour) compounds produced by Propionibacterium freudenreichii, the main secondary flora of Emmental cheese were identified by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry in mini Emmental cheeses, and in pure cultures of propionibacteria grown in cheese aqueous phase (juice). Selected compounds were quantified. Propionibacteria significantly influenced the amount of 57 out of the 69 volatiles identified in juice. Short-chain carboxylic acids (acetic, propionic, butanoic, hexanoic, and isovaleric acids), esters (mainly esters of acetic and propionic acids), and some ketones and alcohols were more abundant in the presence of propionibacteria, whereas most aldehydes were less abundant. Most of these volatiles were branched-chain compounds. In cheese, the fingerprint of propionibacteria on the volatile profile, despite being less pronounced, showed similar trends as in juice. Carboxylic acids and esters are the most probable cheese flavour-active compounds produced by propionibacteria.

Purification and characterization of a branched-chain amino acid aminotransferase from Lactobacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei CHCC 2115.

Purification and characterization of an aminotransferase (AT) specific for the degradation of branched-chain amino acids from Lactobacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei CHCC 2115. The purification protocol consisted of anion exchange chromatography, affinity chromatography and hydrophobic interaction chromatography. The enzyme was found to exist as a monomer with a molecular mass of 40-50 kDa. The AT converted isoleucine, leucine and valine at a similar rate with alpha-ketoglutarate as the amino group acceptor; minor activity was shown for methionine. The enzyme had pH and temperature optima of 7.3 and 43 degrees C, respectively, and activity was detected at the pH and salt conditions found in cheese (pH 5.2, 4% NaCl). Hg2+ completely inhibited the enzyme, and the inhibition pattern was similar to that for pyridoxal-5'-phosphate-dependent enzymes, when studying the effect of other metal ions, thiol- and carbonyl-binding agents. The N-terminal sequence of the enzyme was SVNIDWNNLGFDYMQLPYRYVAHXKDGVXD, and had at the amino acid level, 60 and 53% identity to a branched-chain amino acid AT of Lact. plantarum and Lactococcus lactis, respectively. The results suggest that Lact. paracasei subsp. paracasei CHCC 2115 may contribute to development of flavour in cheese. The findings of this work contribute to the knowledge of transamination performed by cheese-related bacteria, and in the understanding and control of amino acid catabolism and the production of aroma compounds.