Understanding the City: Contemporary and Future PerspectivesJ. Eade and C. Mele (Eds)Blackwell, Oxford, 2002, ISBN 0-631-22406-8 (hb), ISBN 0-631-22407-6 (pb)In a whole number of ways this is an exciting time to be writing about cities. Throughout the world the shape, form and feel of cities is being reworked, re-imagined and re-functioned in ways that are simultaneously familiar and confusing. While cities retain their established role as key command and control centres, and many older urban centres are clearly still organized around well established, recognizable, symbolic economies, at the same time the vast majority of urban growth is concentrated in places that lack many of the key attributes of the traditional city. These new urban spaces lack a sense of form and centre, their boundaries are vague if not non-existent, and their sense of collective memory is ill formed. And if the urban spaces being built seem different, so too are the ways in which people are going about making a home in their cities. Cheap air travel, advances in telecommunications, the universalization of the automobile, the evolution of an all-embracing consumer culture, along with the rise of a genuinely post-traditional society is helping to create individuals and communities whose attachments are as distributed and complex as the urban spaces they populate.Understanding the City aims to offer a series of cutting edge essays on how urban scholars are seeking to understand these new contemporary urbanisms. It also aims to convey a sense of the excitement and intellectual energy driving contemporary urban studies. Certainly the book brings together an impressive group of scholars: Michael Peter Smith, Sophie Watson, Ruth Fincher, Mark Gotidiener, Peter Marcuse, Chris Pickvance, Kay Anderson, Jane M. Jacobs and Sophie Boby-Gendrot to name a few. These are all heavy weight thinkers. Yet as a statement about what is happening in our cities, and the most innovative ways we might try and understand them Understanding the City is disappointing. It is hard to isolate exactly what the source of this disappointment is. Understanding the City does contain a number of excellent chapters. Paul Lubeck and Bryana Britts' discussion of the emergence of a distinctively modern Muslim urban public culture in Cairo and elsewhere in the Middle East and North Africa is both thorough and thought provoking. Similarly, Smriti Srinivas' examination of the spiritual and historical Bangalores that are enfolded within the much more familiar story of Bangalore as a micro-electronic boomtown is an exemplary piece of urban scholarship. Nor are the chapters contributed by the more established scholars without interest. Michael Peter Smith offers a carefully argued, theoretically astute, discussion of the need to understand globalization as always being bound up in important ways with very local urban practices. Peter Marcuse's discussion of the development of Manuel Castells' theoretical project offers both a rare overview of Castells project and an impassioned critique of Castells' most recent work. And Mark Gottdeiner's attempted demolition of the LA School of Michael Dear et al. critique would be a too measured description of what Gottdeiner is up to) is a scream.
Read full abstract