Charge Recombination Pathways Research Articles

Highly Efficient Photoelectrochemical Alkene Epoxidation on a Dye-Sensitized Photoanode.

In photoelectrochemical (PEC) cells, selective oxidation of organic substrates coupled with hydrogen evolution represents a promising approach for value-added chemical production and solar energy conversion. In this study, we report on PEC epoxidation of alkenes at a ruthenium dye-sensitized photoanode in a CH3CN/H2O mixed solvent with LiBr as a mediator and water as the oxygen source. The dye-sensitized photoanode was found to exhibit significant advantages in the simultaneous improvement of charge separation and suppression of charge recombination. First, LiBr as a redox mediator plays a critical role in charge separation, leading to an excellent excited electron injection efficiency of 95% and a high dye regeneration efficiency of 87%. Second, the predominant charge recombination pathway on the dye-sensitized photoanode is efficiently blocked by the reaction between alkene and the in situ generated bromine oxidant. As a result, the current system achieved a remarkable photocurrent density of over 4 mA cm-2 with a record-high incident photo-to-current efficiency (IPCE) of 51% and extraordinary selectivity of up to 99% for the epoxidation of a wide range of alkenes. Meanwhile, nearly 100% Faradaic efficiency for hydrogen evolution was obtained. The performance shown here exceeds that obtained by metal oxide-based semiconductor photoanodes under comparable conditions, demonstrating the great potential of dye-sensitized photoelectrodes for organic synthesis owing to their diversity and tunability.

Insights into the Interfacial Charge Transfer Dynamics in Semiconductor–Molecular Catalyst Assemblies for Photo–Induced CO2 Reduction

AbstractThis mini–review summarises examples of photo and photoelectrochemical CO2 reduction reactions (CO2RR) using semiconductor–molecular catalyst–based hybrid assemblies in which studies of charge transfer dynamics were also performed. In these catalysts, the grand challenges are controlling ultra–fast one–electron charge separation and simultaneously governing its impact on the efficiency and product selectivity in the multielectron and multi–proton–assisted CO2RR. In practice, several unwanted electron recombination processes occur in the femtosecond to millisecond timescale range impacting the overall catalysis efficiency. Titanium di‐oxide (TiO2) nanoparticle, mesoporous TiO2 film, copper indium sulphide (CuInS2) quantum dots were used as semiconductor materials, in turn rhenium (I) bipyridine, cobalt (II) terpyridine, cobaloxamine complex, and iron (III) porphyrins were investigated as molecular catalysts. The results of the charge transfer dynamic studies operating in such hybrid systems shed light on their charge accumulation processes, their rate constants for the intramolecular charge transfer processes and the decay lifetimes of the different excited state species that are produced. Moreover, a comprehensive understanding of the catalysts’ charge transfer dynamics is crucial to identifying detrimental charge recombination pathways. These undesired pathways can be used as rational basis for improving the design of future multi–redox–driven hybrid catalysts.

Charge carrier recombination processes, intragap defect states, and photoluminescence mechanisms in stoichiometric and reduced TiO2 brookite nanorods: an interpretation scheme through in situ photoluminescence excitation spectroscopy in controlled environment.

The study of titanium dioxide (TiO2) in the brookite phase is gaining popularity as evidence has shown the efficient photocatalytic performance of this less investigated polymorph. It has been recently reported that defective anisotropic brookite TiO2 nanorods display remarkable substrate-specific reactivity towards alcohol photoreforming, with rates of hydrogen production significantly (18-fold) higher than those exhibited by anatase TiO2 nanoparticles. To elucidate the basic photo-physical mechanisms and peculiarities leading to such an improvement in the photoactive efficiency, we investigated the recombination processes of photoexcited charge carriers in both stoichiometric and reduced brookite nanorods via photoluminescence excitation spectroscopy in controlled environment. Through an investigation procedure employing both supragap and subgap excitation during successive exposure to oxidizing and reducing gaseous agents, we firstly obtained an interpretation scheme describing the main photoluminescence and charge recombination pathways in stoichiometric and reduced brookite, which includes information about the spatial and energetic position of the intragap states involved in photoluminescence mechanisms, and secondly identified a specific photoluminescence enhancement process occurring in only reduced brookite nanorods, which indicates the injection of a conduction band electron during ethanol photo-oxidation. The latter finding may shed light on the empirical evidence about the exceptional reactivity of reduced brookite nanorods toward the photo-oxidation of alcohols and the concomitant efficiency of photocatalytic hydrogen generation.

Cover Feature: Plugging the 3MC Sink in RuII‐Based Photocatalysts (ChemCatChem 4/2023)

The Cover Feature shows a representation of a multi-step electron transfer process in a hydrogen generating, RuII intramolecular photocatalyst. A prominent deactivation pathway can occur via 3MC state population on the photocentre, resulting in undesired charge recombination. In their Research Article, S. Kupfer and co-workers use quantum chemical methods to demonstrate that coordination of biimidazole based co-ligands around the RuII photocentre centre can direct the initial photoexcitation exclusively towards the catalytic bridge. Furthermore, in the triplet manifold, 3MC population from the 3MLCT state is also reduced. These ligand motifs thereby provide a potential means to control initial photoexcitation and to reduce a possible charge-recombination pathway in photoactive transition metal complexes. More information can be found in the Research Article by S. Kupfer and co-workers.

Plugging the 3MC Sink in RuII‐Based Photocatalysts

AbstractQuantum chemical methods have been utilised to explore the kinetics and thermodynamics of a prominent charge recombination pathway in a series of RuII based molecular photocatalysts. Selective tuning of the RuII coordination sphere, replacing the tbbpy ligands of the hydrogen evolving parent photocatalyst with electron rich, biimidazole based ligands, promotes unidirectional charge transfer towards the bridging ligand during initial photoexcitation. These electronic effects are also significant in the triplet manifold, where the predicted rate of the undesired deactivation process from the 3MLCT state on the bridging ligand to a 3MC state on the ruthenium centre, is decreased relative to the parent complex, by 1–2 orders of magnitude, alongside a decrease in electronic coupling. This design methodology could be utilised to promote targeted (light‐driven) electron transfer pathways, as well as to potentially reduce 3MC deactivation pathways in commonly used polypyridyl‐based RuII photocentres, thus enhancing the quantum efficiency of light driven catalysis.

Triplet states in the reaction center of Photosystem II.

In oxygenic photosynthesis sunlight is harvested and funneled as excitation energy into the reaction center (RC) of Photosystem II (PSII), the site of primary charge separation that initiates the photosynthetic electron transfer chain. The chlorophyll ChlD1 pigment of the RC is the primary electron donor, forming a charge-separated radical pair with the vicinal pheophytin PheoD1 (ChlD1+PheoD1-). To avert charge recombination, the electron is further transferred to plastoquinone QA, whereas the hole relaxes to a central pair of chlorophylls (PD1PD2), subsequently driving water oxidation. Spin-triplet states can form within the RC when forward electron transfer is inhibited or back reactions are favored. This can lead to formation of singlet dioxygen, with potential deleterious effects. Here we investigate the nature and properties of triplet states within the PSII RC using a multiscale quantum-mechanics/molecular-mechanics (QM/MM) approach. The low-energy spectrum of excited singlet and triplet states, of both local and charge-transfer nature, is compared using range-separated time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT). We further compute electron paramagnetic resonance properties (zero-field splitting parameters and hyperfine coupling constants) of relaxed triplet states and compare them with available experimental data. Moreover, the electrostatic modulation of excited state energetics and redox properties of RC pigments by the semiquinone QA- is described. The results provide a detailed electronic-level understanding of triplet states within the PSII RC and form a refined basis for discussing primary and secondary electron transfer, charge recombination pathways, and possible photoprotection mechanisms in PSII.

Electrical characteristics of a Hall effect thruster body in a vacuum facility testing environment

The operational characteristics of Hall effect thrusters are altered by conductive surfaces in vacuum facilities. Conductive surfaces alter charge distribution in the plume by providing pathways for electron-ion recombination that do not exist in the spaceflight environment. Charge recombination pathways impact thruster performance and plume behavior through mechanisms that are not entirely understood. The incomplete understanding of the relationship between charge recombination pathways and thruster behavior limits the ability to characterize thruster performance through ground testing. This paper quantifies the effect of polarity and magnitude of body-to-cathode voltage on coupling between the thruster body and the local plasma environment. The effort operates the T-140 Hall thruster at a single, fixed operating condition of 300 V, 3.5 kW, with anode and cathode xenon flow rates of 11.6 ± 0.03 mg/s and 1.61 ± 0.12 mg/s, respectively. During data collection, the chamber was maintained at a pressure of 8.7 × 10–6 Torr-Xe. The thruster body-to-ground voltage is manipulated by varying body-to-ground resistance. Results show the thruster pole face and body circumference couple to the local plasma environment through distinct sheaths. The polarity of the body-to-cathode voltage determines the characteristics of these sheaths. Therefore, the body-to-cathode voltage controls the interaction between the thruster body recombination pathway and the local plasma environment.

Spin Orbit Coupling in Orthogonal Charge Transfer States: (TD-)DFT of Pyrene-Dimethylaniline.

The conformational dependence of the matrix element for spin–orbit coupling and of the electronic coupling for charge separation are determined for an electron donor–acceptor system containing a pyrene acceptor and a dimethylaniline donor. Different kinetic and energetic aspects that play a role in the spin–orbit charge transfer intersystem crossing (SOCT-ISC) mechanism are discussed. This includes parameters related to initial charge separation and the charge recombination pathways using the Classical Marcus Theory of electron transfer. The spin–orbit coupling, which plays a significant role in charge recombination to the triplet state, can be probed by (TD)-DFT, using the latter as a tool to understand and predict the SOCT-ISC mechanism. The matrix elements for spin–orbit coupling for acetone and 4-thio-thymine are used for benchmarking. (Time Dependent-) Density Functional Theory (DFT and TD-DFT) calculations are applied using the quantum chemical program Amsterdam Density Functional (ADF).

Temperature dependence of nanosecond charge recombination in mutant Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers: modelling of the protein dynamics

We investigated the influence of a range of factors—temperature, redox midpoint potential of an electron carrier, and protein dynamics—on nanosecond electron transfer within a protein. The model reaction was back electron transfer from a bacteriopheophytin anion, HA−, to an oxidized primary electron donor, P+, in a wild type Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center (RC) with a permanently reduced secondary electron acceptor (quinone, QA−). Also used were two modified RCs with single amino acid mutations near the monomeric bacteriochlorophyll, BA, located between P and HA. Both mutant RCs showed significant slowing down of this back electron transfer reaction with decreasing temperature, similar to that observed with the wild type RC, but contrasting with a number of single point mutant RCs studied previously. The observed similarities and differences are explained in the framework of a (P+BA− ↔ P+HA−) equilibrium model with an important role played by protein relaxation. The major cause of the observed temperature dependence, both in the wild type RC and in the mutant proteins, is a limitation in access to the thermally activated pathway of charge recombination via the state P+BA− at low temperatures. The data indicate that in all RCs both charge recombination pathways, the thermally activated one and a direct one without involvement of the P+BA− state, are controlled by the protein dynamics. It is concluded that the modifications of the protein environment affect the overall back electron transfer kinetics primarily by changing the redox potential of BA and not by changing the protein relaxation dynamics.

(Invited) Single Nanosheet Photoelectrochemistry: Probing Charge Recombination and Transport Pathways in Monolayer Transition Metal Dichalcogenide Photoelectrodes

Monolayer heterojunctions such as MoS2/WS2 are attractive for solar energy conversion applications because the interfacial electric field spatially separates charge carriers in less than 100 femtoseconds. Photoelectrochemical cells represent an intriguing platform to collect the spatially separated carriers. However, the recombination, transport, and interfacial charge transfer processes that take place following the ultrafast charge separation step have not been investigated. Here we demonstrate novel charge recombination and transport pathways in monolayer MoS2/WS2 photoelectrochemical cells by spatially resolving the net collection of carriers (i.e., the photocurrent) at the single nanosheet-level. We discovered an excitation wavelength-dependent recombination pathway that depends on the heterojunction stacking configuration and the carrier generation profile in the heterostructure. Photocurrent mapping measurements revealed that charge transport occurs parallel to the layers over micrometre-scale distances even though the indium tin oxide electrode and liquid electrolyte provide efficient charge extraction pathways via intimate electron- and hole-selective contacts. Our results reveal how composition heterogeneity influences the performance of bulk heterojunction electrodes made from randomly oriented nanosheets and provide critical insight into the design of efficient heterojunction photoelectrodes for solar energy conversion applications. Figure 1

Effect of Ligand Functionalization on the Rate of Charge Carrier Recombination in Metal-Organic Frameworks: A Case Study of MIL-125.

Ligand functionalization is a powerful approach for modifying the electronic structure of metal-organic frameworks when targeting the optimal electronic properties for photocatalysis and photovoltaics. However, its effect on the charge carrier lifetimes and recombination pathways remains unexplored. In this work, first-principles simulations, including nonadiabatic molecular dynamics, are performed for the representative TiO2-based metal-organic framework systems MIL-125-X to unravel the impact of ligand functionalization on the nonradiative electron-hole recombination process, decoherence rates, and phonon modes giving the largest contribution to the nonradiative decay. Nonradiative recombination rates, simulated using the PBE0 density functional, are in excellent agreement with experiment. The ligand functionalization in MIL-125-X influences the recombination rates, unraveling the trend opposite to the evolution of the band gap and affecting the nonadiabatic coupling coefficients. Ligand modification impacts the phonon modes, which contribute most to the recombination process, altering the distribution between soft phonon modes and vibrational modes associated with specific structural motifs.

Remarkable variation of visible light photocatalytic activities of M/Sn0.9Sb0.1O2/TiO2 (M=Au, Ag, Pt) heterostructures depending on the loaded metals

Sn0.9Sb0.1O2/TiO2 (ATO/TiO2) heterostructure is a potential visible light photocatalysts that function via an inter-semiconductor hole-transport mechanism. Herein we selectively deposited Au, Ag, or Pt onto the ATO surface of ATO/TiO2 to investigate charge-trapping behaviors of the noble metals and their effects on photocatalytic performance. We observed that Pt deposition greatly enhanced the photocatalytic activity whereas effects of Au or Ag depositions were not significant. The result of spectroscopic analysis also indicates that Pt is the most effective in scavenging the electrons from the ATO CB. Particularly, Pt/ATO/TiO2 (ATO:TiO2 = 15:85 in weight) produced CO2 of 42 ppmv in 2 h, which is 16 times and 4.8 times that of bare ATO/TiO2 and nitrogen-doped TiO2, respectively. Pt deposition on the ATO seems to suppress two independent charge recombination pathways, that is, recombination of electron-hole pairs in ATO and electron transport from the ATO CB to TiO2 VB.

(Invited) Single Nanosheet Photoelectrochemistry: Probing Charge Recombination and Transport Pathways in Monolayer Transition Metal Dichalcogenide Photoelectrodes

Monolayer heterojunctions such as MoS2/WS2 are attractive for solar energy conversion applications because the interfacial electric field spatially separates charge carriers in less than 100 femtoseconds. Photoelectrochemical cells represent an intriguing platform to collect the spatially separated carriers. However, the recombination, transport, and interfacial charge transfer processes that take place following the ultrafast charge separation step have not been investigated. Here we demonstrate novel charge recombination and transport pathways in monolayer MoS2/WS2 photoelectrochemical cells by spatially resolving the net collection of carriers (i.e., the photocurrent) at the single nanosheet-level. We discovered an excitation wavelength-dependent recombination pathway that depends on the heterojunction stacking configuration and the carrier generation profile in the heterostructure. Photocurrent mapping measurements revealed that charge transport occurs parallel to the layers over micrometre-scale distances even though the indium tin oxide electrode and liquid electrolyte provide efficient charge extraction pathways via intimate electron- and hole-selective contacts. Our results reveal how composition heterogeneity influences the performance of bulk heterojunction electrodes made from randomly oriented nanosheets and provide critical insight into the design of efficient heterojunction photoelectrodes for solar energy conversion applications. Figure 1

Critical Role of Organic Spacers for Bright 2D Layered Perovskites Light-Emitting Diodes.

Light‐emitting diodes (LEDs) made with quasi‐2D/3D and layered perovskites have undergone an unprecedented surge as their external quantum efficiency (EQE) is rapidly approaching other lighting technologies. Manipulating the charge recombination pathway in semiconductors is highly desirable for improving the device performance. This study reports high‐performance layered perovskites LEDs with benzyl ring as spacer where radiative recombination lifetime is longer, compared with much shorter alkyl chain spacer yields. Based on detailed optical and X‐ray absorption spectroscopy measurements, direct signature of charges localization is observed near the band edge in exchange with the shallow traps in benzyl organics containing layered perovskites. As a result, it boosts the photoluminescence intensity by 7.4 times compared to that made with the alkyl organics. As a demonstration, a bright LED made with the benzyl organics with current efficiency of 23.46 ± 1.52 cd A−1 is shown when the device emits at a high brightness of 6.6 ± 0.93 × 104 cd m−2. The average EQE is 9.2% ± 1.43%, two orders of magnitude higher than the device made with alkyl organics. The study suggests that the choices of organic spacers provide a path toward the manipulation of charge recombination, essential for efficient optoelectronic device fabrications.

Spin-Controlled Charge-Recombination Pathways across the Inorganic/Organic Interface.

Charge transfer and recombination across the inorganic/organic interface in nanocrystal or quantum dot (QD)-molecule hybrid materials have been extensively studied. Principles of controlling charge transfer and recombination via energetics and electronic coupling have been established. However, the use of electron spin to control transfer and recombination pathways in such systems remains relatively underexplored. Here we use CdS QD-alizarin (AZ) as a model system to demonstrate this principle. Using time-resolved spectroscopy, we found that the charge-separated states (QD--AZ+) created by selectively exciting AZ molecules mostly recombined to regenerate ground-state complexes, whereas apparently the "same" charge separated states created by exciting QDs recombined to produce AZ molecular triplet states. Such a difference can be traced to the distinct spin configurations between excited QDs (QD*, with an ill-defined spin) and AZ (1AZ*, spin singlet) and the asymmetric electron and hole spin-flip rates in II-VI group QDs. The transferability of such a principle was confirmed by similar observations obtained for CdS QD-tetracene complexes. Opening an avenue for controlling charge transfer and recombination pathways via electron spin is potentially important for applications such as artificial photosynthesis.

Photogenerated charge collection on diamond electrodes with covalently linked chromophore monolayers

Encouraged by its rich surface chemistry and excellent electrochemical properties, boron-doped nanocrystalline diamond (B:NCD) is a promising p-type photoelectrode in dye-sensitized solar cells. One method of diamond surface functionalization using stable carbon-carbon bonds involves the electrochemical grafting of diazonium salts. However, this method typically leads to multilayers that may complicate the transport of photogenerated charges. Here, we establish functionalization of B:NCD electrodes by a monolayer of ethynylphenyl molecules using sterically hindered 4-(trimethylsilyl)ethynylbenzenediazonium tetrafluoroborate. Both the density and structural orientation of the grafted layer are investigated by angular resolved X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, confirming the presence of covalently grafted monolayers. After removal of the trimethylsilyl protective groups, the resulting ethynyl functionalities are employed to immobilize organic donor-acceptor chromophores via Sonogashira cross-coupling reactions. Homogenous surface coverage is achieved even on the B:NCD electrode. Atomic scale DFT computing reveals that for the chromophore with the strongest acceptor unit, efficient charge separation of 20 Å is obtained where photogenerated holes move directly into diamond. Yet, photocurrent and photovoltage measurements suggest competitive electron recombination to the diamond electrode via the redox electrolyte. Correlation between the density of the molecular layer and photocurrents/photovoltage provides better understanding of the charge generation and recombination pathways in diamond-organic photoelectrochemical cells.

Probing Charge Carrier Transport and Recombination Pathways in Monolayer MoS2/WS2 Heterojunction Photoelectrodes.

Monolayer heterojunctions such as MoS2/WS2 are attractive for solar energy conversion applications because the interfacial electric field spatially separates charge carriers in less than 100 fs. Photoelectrochemical cells represent an intriguing platform to collect the spatially separated carriers. However, the recombination, transport, and interfacial charge transfer processes that take place following the ultrafast charge separation step have not been investigated. Here we demonstrate novel charge recombination and transport pathways in monolayer MoS2/WS2 photoelectrochemical cells by spatially resolving the net collection of carriers (i.e., the photocurrent) at the single nanosheet level. We discovered an excitation-wavelength-dependent recombination pathway that depends on the heterojunction stacking configuration and the carrier generation profile in the heterostructure. Photocurrent mapping measurements revealed that charge transport occurs parallel to the layers over micrometer-scale distances even though the indium tin oxide electrode and liquid electrolyte provide efficient charge extraction pathways via intimate electron- and hole-selective contacts. Our results reveal how composition heterogeneity influences the performance of bulk heterojunction electrodes made from randomly oriented nanosheets and provide critical insight into the design of efficient heterojunction photoelectrodes for solar energy conversion applications.

Ion-Pair Dynamics upon Photoinduced Electron Transfer Monitored by Pump-Pump-Probe Spectroscopy.

The excited-state dynamics of the radical anion of perylene (Pe) generated upon bimolecular photoinduced electron transfer (PET) with a donor was investigated using broadband pump-pump-probe spectroscopy. It was found to depend on the age of the anion, that is, on the time interval between the first pump pulse that triggers PET and the second one that excites the ensuing Pe anion (Pe•-). These differences, observed in acetonitrile but not in tetrahydrofuran, report on the evolution of the PET product from an ion pair to free ions. Two photoinduced charge recombination pathways of the ion pair to the neutral Pe*(S1) + donor state were identified: one occurring in a few picoseconds fromPe•-*(D1) and one taking place within 100-200 fs fromPe•-*(D n>1). Both processes are sensitive to the interionic distance over different length scales and thus serve as molecular rulers.

Charge Separation and Recombination Pathways in Diblock DNA Hairpins.

Achieving high-yielding photoinduced charge separation through the π-stacked bases of DNA is a critical requirement for realizing numerous DNA-based technologies. In the current work, we combine two strategies for achieving high-yield charge separation. First, a chromophore with a high driving force for charge injection, naphthalenediimide (NDI), is used because it generates hot carriers that enhance charge-transfer rates. Second, a diblock DNA sequence is used with two or three adenines followed by a series of guanines to implement an energy landscape that accelerates charge separation while retarding charge recombination. The photoinduced dynamics of these NDI diblock oligomers with and without a terminal hole acceptor are probed by femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy. The measured rate constants for various charge separation and recombination processes are interpreted within the context of a full kinetic model of these systems. We find that the A2 and A3 oligomers achieve similar charge separation yields (as high as 20-25%) for a given length, yet the critical recombination process that determines these yields occurs at different distances from the NDI chromophore and on different time scales. This type of analysis could be used to predict charge separation efficiencies in candidate DNA structures.

A kinetic model for redox-active film based biophotoelectrodes.

Redox-active films are advantageous matrices for the immobilization of photosynthetic proteins, due to their ability to mediate electron transfer as well as to achieve high catalyst loading on an electrode for efficient generation of electricity or solar fuels. A general challenge arises from various charge recombination pathways along the light-induced electron transfer chain from the electrode to the charge carriers for electricity production or to the final electron acceptors for solar fuel formation. Experimental methods based on current measurement or product quantification are often unable to discern between the contributions from the photocatalytic process and the detrimental effect of the short-circuiting reactions. Here we report on a general electrochemical model of the reaction-diffusion processes to identify and quantify the "bottlenecks" present in the fuel or current generation. The model is able to predict photocurrent-time curves including deconvolution of the recombination contributions, and to visualize the corresponding time dependent concentration profiles of the product. Dimensionless groups are developed for straightforward identification of the limiting processes. The importance of the model for quantitative understanding of biophotoelectrochemical processes is highlighted with an example of simulation results predicting the effect of the diffusion coefficient of the charge carrier on photocurrent generation for different charge recombination kinetics.