Shallow lakes are typically dominated by macrophytes, which have important functional roles regulating trophic conditions and creating biological habitat. Macrophytes have been shown to strongly influence water chemistry and shape microbial communities in shallow lakes. In Florida, many large, shallow lakes are dominated by alien invasive, submersed macrophytes, such as hydrilla (Hydrilla verticillata [L.F.] Royle) and are intensively managed to reduce infestations and contain the spread of these alien invasive macrophytes. In this study, we investigated the effects of large (40 ha) herbicidal and mechanical control treatments on a large lake located in Central Florida that resulted in the reduction of Hydrilla and concomitant changes in water chemistry and microbial communities (both bacteria and protists [microbial eukaryotes]). We observed a considerable decrease in macrophyte coverage associated with plant control treatments as well as a temporal change in macrophyte coverage in Lake Tohopekaliga. We found that changes in macrophyte coverage, regardless of treatment type, significantly affected the water chemistry of the lake, resulting in a sharp increase of chlorophyll a concentration as well as an increase in turbidity with the decrease of macrophyte coverage. Moreover, the decline in macrophytes led to decreases in microbial community diversity with over-representation of phototrophic functional groups. Specifically, we observed an increase in cyanobacteria with the decrease in macrophyte coverage. Our study highlights the advantages and disadvantages of macrophyte control. Although there was an initial decrease in macrophyte coverage associated with the chemical and mechanical control of aquatic plants, after a few months, we found a considerable increase in coverage. In addition, the increase of cyanobacterial relative abundance demonstrates the possible consequences of aquatic plant control such as cyanobacterial blooms if there is a continued decline of macrophytes.