Kenneth M. Bauer, High Frontiers: Dolpo and the Changing World of Himalayan Pastoralists, New York: Columbia University Press, 2004.In High Frontiers, Bauer presents an ecological history of a remote region in the high Himalaya just south of the border between Nepal and the Tibet Autonomous Region (China). He traces developments in the lives of Dolpo agro-pastoralists through the changes wrought by successive political waves in both Nepal and China. Although Bauer's work grew out of his training and work in ecology and development, particularly for the WWF in Nepal, it is also based on ethnographic research in Dolpo from 1996-97, and archival work on the histories of Nepal and Tibet The fruits of this multidisciplinary methodology and approach are readily apparent in this account of social adaptation to political and ecological change that takes full account of wider processes, yet remains rooted in the details and conditions of daily life. For anthropologists, the book offers an interesting and highly readable account of the effects of large-scale transnational and state processes on the daily lives of people concerned with yaks, trade and wresting crops from the steppe.Chapter 1, Agro-Pastoral System, gives a sense of daily life in the harsh climate and marginal physical environment of circa 1997. In what is perhaps the most ethnographic chapter of the book, Bauer describes a triad of interrelated and overlapping forms of production-agriculture, animal husbandry and trade-linking these to daily household practices, and to a religious and ceremonial life closely tied to subsistence concerns. The second chapter, Pastoralism in View and Review, considers the situation in Dolpo in terms of two influential approaches in academic interpretations of pastoralism, the first giving analytic primacy to social organization, the second giving primacy to the workings of ecological relations. Drawing from both approaches, Bauer contextualizes Dolpo herding practices and rangeland management strategies as variations of general types of subsistence patterns found elsewhere. Through this description, he questions assumptions commonly made, for example, in discussions of the tragedy of the by showing how the commons in Dolpo is not exploited through capricious acts of self-interest, but is instead regulated through a variety of cooperative social practices such as lotteries (administered by religious specialists) in which all have a chance at the best pastureland, and others take their turn making do with less desirable ranges. Likewise, he describes how collective labour groups ensure the equitable distribution of essential commodities gathered from the commons, like dung (fuel).Chapter 3, A sketch of Dolpo's History, is based largely on archival and published sources, and sets the stage for the following two chapters by describing Dolpo's changing relationship with neighbouring populations from 650 to 1950, and by demonstrating how similarly lengthy and fluctuating relationships between (what are now) India, China, Tibet and Nepal influenced the region, particularly in terms of trans-border trade and pastoral movement.Chapters 4, A New World Order in Tibet, and 5, Nepal's Relations with its Border Populations and the Case of Dolpo, describe how the Tibet Autonomous Region (China) on the one side, and the Nepalese state on the other have influenced Dolpo livelihoods since the 1950s. These two parallel chapters describe how critical events in state manoeuvrings and policy-making had dramatic influences on centuries-old subsistence patterns. Chapter 4 (based on the published scholarly work), for example, describes how Chairman Mao's successive campaigns to unify and reorganize China and repress resistance, resulted in changes in transportation, settlement and the organization of agricultural production that disrupted and all but severed Dolpo-pa patterns of seasonal grazing and trade in Western Tibet. …
Read full abstract