Abstract Introduction/Objective Diffuse meningeal melanocytosis is a rare melanocytic proliferation that poses significant risk of severe hydrocephalus and mortality among children and young adults. Although the clonal melanocytes do not typically exhibit malignant morphological features, their capability for extensive invasion and malignant-like behavior necessitates tissue biopsy alongside immunohistochemical and molecular testing for definitive diagnosis. Methods/Case Report A 17-year-old male presented with progressive headaches, photophobia, and nausea, initially attributed to migraines. Neuro-opthalmological assessment revealed papilledema, leading to a diagnosis of idiopathic intracranial hypertension. Serial imaging showed fluctuating leptomeningeal enhancement and moderate communicating hydrocephalus without parenchymal lesions. Therapeutic lumbar punctures provided modest symptom improvement; increased opening pressure was observed. Evaluation of seven CSF specimens showed low glucose levels, increased cellularity consisting of bland appearing epithelioid cells of unknown etiology, and increased lymphocytes. Infectious causes were excluded. Due to the indeterminate CSF findings, discussion between the cytopathologist and neuro-opthamologist was crucial to facilitate tissue biopsy to exclude a neoplastic process. Subsequent shunt placement and cerebral cortex biopsy revealed neoplastic cells with sheet-like architecture coating the dura without overt brain invasion. The tumor cells had eosinophilic cytoplasm without pigment and enlarged nuclei with irregular contours, vesicular chromatin, and prominent nucleoli. No high-grade features were seen. Immunohistochemical stains were positive for MART1, HMB45, and PRAME, consistent with a melanocytic lesion. FISH melanoma panel was negative. The final diagnosis was diffuse meningeal melanocytic neoplasm, most consistent with meningeal melanocytosis. The patient received chemotherapy with improved symptoms and stable disease. Results (if a Case Study enter NA) NA Conclusion Diffuse meningeal melanocytosis is a challenging cytologic diagnosis as melanocytes can morphologically mimic lymphocytes and monocytes, and the low cellularity of CSF specimens often results in insufficient cell blocks for ancillary tests. The direct communication of the pathologist with the clinical team to correlate pathology, radiology, and clinical symptoms was essential to ensure the proper management of this patient.