The effects of polymeric fiber addition on the multiple cracking performance of composites have been investigated. For this purpose, cement-based matrices incorporating fly ash and a latex emulsion have been designed. Prismatic samples have been prepared and subjected to four-point bending load. The load-midpoint deflection curves and crack patterns have been determined. Meanwhile, flexural strength and relative toughness values have been calculated. Finally, the number of visible cracks formed throughout the testing period has been analyzed.Test results showed that the toughening improvement mechanisms of PP and PVA fibers in a cement-based matrix are extremely different and matrix modifications significantly change the multiple cracking performance. The addition of a latex emulsion in a weak matrix decreased the multiple cracking tendency of PP fiber reinforced composites. However, the same modification attempt improved the multiple cracking capacity of weak matrix in case of PVA fiber reinforcement. The possible causes of this performance improvement have been discussed with the aid of microstructure investigations.