Cellulose-grown Cells Research Articles

Quantitative proteomic analysis of the cellulolytic system of Clostridium termitidis CT1112 reveals distinct protein expression profiles upon growth on α-cellulose and cellobiose

Clostridium termitidis CT1112 is an anaerobic, mesophilic, cellulolytic bacterium with potential applications in consolidated bioprocessing of lignocellulosic biomass. To understand how C. termitidis degrades lignocellulose, iTRAQ-based 2D HPLC-MS/MS proteomics was used to measure protein expression in cell lysates and extracellular (secretome) fractions of C. termitidis grown on α-cellulose and cellobiose at both exponential and stationary growth phases. Exoglucanases (GH48, GH9), endoglucanases (GH5, GH8, GH9), hemicellulases including xylanases (GH8, GH10, GH11, GH30) and mannanase (GH26) as well as extracellular adhesion proteins and cellulosome associated proteins, exhibited higher expression on cellulose-grown cells. The expression of these proteins increased with a decrease in growth rate. Non-cellulosomal proteins however did not change significantly between substrate conditions, although there were a few exceptions. Collectively, these would contribute to hydrolysis of lignocellulosic material for uptake through ABC sugar transport proteins. On cellobiose, chitinases (GH18) were expressed abundantly. Although a large number of proteins were shared between the fractions analyzed, some proteins were detected exclusively in the cellular fraction, while others were detected in the secretome. This study reports for the first time on the cellulolytic machinery employed by C. termitidis to hydrolyze cellulosic substrate and provides an understanding of how this microbe deconstructs biomass. Biological significanceThe genome of C. termitidis CT1112 contains genes for a wide variety of carbohydrate active enzymes. Based on bioinformatics analyses, many of these genes appear to encode cellulosome-associated proteins, while others may be secreted extracellularly. To understand how C. termitidis degrades and depolymerizes cellulosic substrates, cells were grown on simple and complex carbohydrates, and quantitative 4-plex iTRAQ-based 2D HPLC-MS/MS proteomics was applied to measure protein expression levels in biological replicates of both cell lysates and extracellular protein (secretome) fractions, at exponential and stationary phases of growth. The resulting data have provided insight into the range of substrates that may be hydrolyzed by C. termitidis, and may be useful in determining potential industrial applications of C. termitidis in biomass to bioenergy production via consolidated bioprocessing.

Proteomic analysis ofClostridium thermocellumATCC 27405 reveals the upregulation of an alternative transhydrogenase–malate pathway and nitrogen assimilation in cells grown on cellulose

Clostridium thermocellum is a Gram-positive thermophilic anaerobic bacterium with the ability to directly convert cellulosic biomass into useful products such as ethanol and hydrogen. In this study, a quantitative comparative proteomic analysis of the organism was performed to identify proteins and biochemical pathways that are differentially utilized by the organism after growth on cellobiose or cellulose. The cytoplasmic and membrane proteomes of C.thermocellum grown on cellulose or cellobiose were quantitatively compared using a metabolic (15)N isotope labelling method in conjunction with nanoLC-ESI-MS/MS (liquid chromatography- electrospray ionization- tandem mass spectrometry). In total, 1255 proteins were identified in the study, and 129 of those were able to have their relative abundance per cell compared in at least one cellular compartment in response to the substrate provided. This study reveals that cells grown on cellulose increase their abundance of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase while decreasing the abundance of pyruvate dikinase and oxaloacetate decarboxylase, suggesting that the organism diverts carbon flow into a transhydrogenase-malate pathway that can increase the production of the biosynthetic intermediates NADPH and GTP. Glutamate dehydrogenase was also found to have increased abundance in cellulose-grown cells, suggesting that the assimilation of ammonia is upregulated in cells grown on the cellulosic substrates. The results illustrate a mechanism by which C.thermocellum can divert carbon into alternative pathways for the purpose of producing biosynthetic intermediates necessary to respond to growth on cellulose, including transhydrogenation of NADH to NADPH and increased nitrogen assimilation.

Hydrolytic and phosphorolytic metabolism of cellobiose by the marine aerobic bacterium Saccharophagus degradans 2-40T

Saccharophagus degradans 2-40 is a marine gamma proteobacterium that can produce polyhydroxyalkanoates from lignocellulosic biomass using a complex cellulolytic system. This bacterium has been annotated to express three surface-associated β-glucosidases (Bgl3C, Ced3A, and Ced3B), two cytoplasmic β-glucosidases (Bgl1A and Bgl1B), and unusual for an aerobic bacterium, two cytoplasmic cellobiose/cellodextrin phosphorylases (Cep94A and Cep94B). Expression of the genes for each of the above enzymes was induced when cells were transferred into a medium containing Avicel as the major carbon source except for Bgl1B. Both hydrolytic and phosphorolytic degradation of cellobiose by crude cell lysates obtained from cellulose-grown cells were demonstrated and all of these activities were cell-associated. With the exception of Cep94B, each purified enzyme exhibited their annotated activity upon cloning and expression in E. coli. The five β-glucosidases hydrolyzed a variety of glucose derivatives containing β-1, (2, 4, or 6) linkages but did not act on any α-linked glucose derivatives. All but one β-glucosidases exhibited transglycosylation activity consistent with the formation of an enzyme-substrate intermediate. The biochemistry and expression of these cellobiases indicate that external hydrolysis by surface-associated β-glucosidases coupled with internal hydrolysis and phosphorolysis are all involved in the metabolism of cellobiose by this bacterium.

Cel9D, an Atypical 1,4-β- d -Glucan Glucohydrolase from Fibrobacter succinogenes : Characteristics, Catalytic Residues, and Synergistic Interactions with Other Cellulases

The increasing demands of renewable energy have led to the critical emphasis on novel enzymes to enhance cellulose biodegradation for biomass conversion. To identify new cellulases in the ruminal bacterium Fibrobacter succinogenes, a cell extract of cellulose-grown cells was separated by ion-exchange chromatography and cellulases were located by zymogram analysis and identified by peptide mass fingerprinting. An atypical family 9 glycoside hydrolase (GH9), Cel9D, with less than 20% identity to typical GH9 cellulases, was identified. Purified recombinant Cel9D enhanced the production of reducing sugar from acid swollen cellulose (ASC) and Avicel by 1.5- to 4-fold when mixed separately with each of four other glucanases, although it had low activity on these substrates. Cel9D degraded ASC and cellodextrins with a degree of polymerization higher than 2 to glucose with no apparent endoglucanase activity, and its activity was restricted to beta-1-->4-linked glucose residues. It catalyzed the hydrolysis of cellulose by an inverting mode of reaction, releasing glucose from the nonreducing end. Unlike many GH9 cellulases, calcium ions were not required for its function. Cel9D had increased kcat/Km values for cello-oligosaccharides with higher degrees of polymerization. The kcat/Km value for cellohexaose was 2,300 times higher than that on cellobiose. This result indicates that Cel9D is a 1,4-beta-D-glucan glucohydrolase (EC 3.2.1.74) in the GH9 family. Site-directed mutagenesis of Cel9D identified Asp166 and Glu612 as the candidate catalytic residues, while Ser168, which is not present in typical GH9 cellulases, has a crucial structural role. This enzyme has an important role in crystalline cellulose digestion by releasing glucose from accessible cello-oligosaccharides.

Global View of the Clostridium thermocellum Cellulosome Revealed by Quantitative Proteomic Analysis

A metabolic isotope-labeling strategy was used in conjunction with nano-liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry peptide sequencing to assess quantitative alterations in the expression patterns of subunits within cellulosomes of the cellulolytic bacterium Clostridium thermocellum, grown on either cellulose or cellobiose. In total, 41 cellulosomal proteins were detected, including 36 type I dockerin-containing proteins, which count among them all but three of the known docking components and 16 new subunits. All differential expression data were normalized to the scaffoldin CipA such that protein per cellulosome was compared for growth between the two substrates. Proteins that exhibited higher expression in cellulosomes from cellulose-grown cells than in cellobiose-grown cells were the cell surface anchor protein OlpB, exoglucanases CelS and CelK, and the glycoside hydrolase family 9 (GH9) endoglucanase CelJ. Conversely, lower expression in cellulosomes from cells grown on cellulose than on cellobiose was observed for the GH8 endoglucanase CelA; GH5 endoglucanases CelB, CelE, CelG; and hemicellulases XynA, XynC, XynZ, and XghA. GH9 cellulases were the most abundant group of enzymes per CipA when cells were grown on cellulose, while hemicellulases were the most abundant group on cellobiose. The results support the existing theory that expression of scaffoldin-related proteins is coordinately regulated by a catabolite repression type of mechanism, as well as the prior observation that xylanase expression is subject to a growth rate-independent type of regulation. However, concerning transcriptional control of cellulases, which had also been previously shown to be subject to catabolite repression, a novel distinction was observed with respect to endoglucanases.

Transcriptional Analysis of the cip-cel Gene Cluster from Clostridium cellulolyticum

Twelve genes encoding key components of Clostridium cellulolyticum cellulosomes are clustered. Among them, the first, second, and fifth genes encode the assembly factor CipC and the two major cellulases Cel48F and Cel9E, respectively. Cellulolytic clones were selected from the noncellulolytic cipC insertional mutant trans-complemented with a cipC expression vector, in which one homologous recombination event between the 3' end of the chromosomal cipC gene and the plasmidic cipC gene has restored the cluster continuity. The absence of the enzymes encoded by the cluster in the cipC mutant was thus only due to a strong polar effect, indicating that all genes were transcriptionally linked. Two large transcripts were detected in cellulose-grown cells by Northern hybridization: a 14-kb messenger which carries the cipC-cel48F-cel8C-cel9G-cel9E coding sequences and, in a smaller amount, a 12-kb messenger which carries the genes located in the 3' part of the cluster. Four smaller transcripts were found in large amounts: a cipC-cel48F bicistronic one and three monocistronic ones, cipC, cel48F, and cel9E. The cipC-cel48F and cel48F messengers were shown to be stable. Analysis by reverse transcription-PCR suggested transcriptional linkage of all of the open reading frames. The production of a primary very large transcript covering the entire cluster was hypothesized. Primer extension analysis has identified two putative transcriptional start sites located 638/637 and 194 nucleotides upstream of the cipC translational start. The processing of the primary transcript would lead to the production of several secondary messengers displaying different stabilities, contributing to fine tuning of expression of individual genes of the operon.

The extracellular xylan degradative system in Clostridium cellulolyticum cultivated on xylan: evidence for cell-free cellulosome production.

In this study, we demonstrate that the cellulosome of Clostridium cellulolyticum grown on xylan is not associated with the bacterial cell. Indeed, the large majority of the activity (about 90%) is localized in the cell-free fraction when the bacterium is grown on xylan. Furthermore, about 70% of the detected xylanase activity is associated with cell-free high-molecular-weight complexes containing avicelase activity and the cellulosomal scaffolding protein CipC. The same repartition is observed with carboxymethyl cellulase activity. The cellulose adhesion of xylan-grown cells is sharply reduced in comparison with cellulose-grown cells. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis revealed that cellulosomes derived from xylan- and cellulose-grown cells have different compositions. In both cases, the scaffolding protein CipC is present, but the relative proportions of the other components is dramatically changed depending on the growth substrate. We propose that, depending on the growth substrate, C. cellulolyticum is able to regulate the cell association and cellulose adhesion of cellulosomes and regulate cellulosomal composition.

Rheological, Mass Transfer, and Mixing Characterization of Cellulase-Producing Trichoderma reesei Suspensions

Steady and dynamic shear measurements are utilized to characterize the rheological behavior of Trichoderma reesei RUT-C30 fungal suspensions during batch growth on xylose (soluble substrate) or cellulose (particulate solid substrate) at three different fermentor impeller speeds (250, 400, and 550 rpm). Biomass concentrations versus time were unimodal on xylose and bimodal on cellulose. This behavior is consistent with relatively rapid, early growth on easily metabolized growth medium components (yeast extract), followed by a second, slower growth phase due to hydrolysis of recalcitrant cellulose by increasing cellulase concentrations. Critical dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration for T. reesei growth on cellulose was found to be 0.073 mmol/L. The DO was kept above this level by supplementing the air feed with pure oxygen, implying that mass transfer limitations were not the cause of bimodal cell growth. Steady shear rheological data showed shear thinning behavior and a yield stress for all broth samples regardless of substrate. Casson and Herschel−Bulkley constitutive equations fit steady shear data well. Dynamic shear measurements on broth suspensions indicated “gel-like” behavior at low strains, with microstructural breakdown at larger displacements. Time variations of the Casson model parameters (yield stress and Casson viscosity) and dynamic moduli (elastic and viscous modulus) followed both cell mass and morphology: a single maximum in all rheological variables resulted when cells were grown on xylose or on cellulose at impeller speeds of 400 or 550 rpm, and dual maxima were observed for cellulose-grown cells at 250 rpm.

Transcriptional analysis of the Clostridium cellulovorans endoglucanase gene, engB.

An endoglucanase gene, which was shown to be identical to the previously sequenced engB gene [Attwood et al. (1993) Abstr. Ann. Meet. Am. Soc. Microbiol.], was isolated from a Clostridium cellulovorans genomic library. Because of the lack of transcriptional information concerning engB we examined its expression in C. cellulovorans and in the heterologous hosts Escherichia coli and C. acetobutylicum following transformation of engB. Northern analysis suggested that both E. coli and C. acetobutylicum produced several transcripts of various sizes. C. cellulovarans produced a single transcript of 1600 bp with the relative amount of engB mRNA from cellulose-grown cells being much greater than that from cellobiose-grown cells. Primer extensions showed that engB was transcribed from a single transcription initiation site in C. cellulovorans preceded by sequences similar to promoter sequences found in Gram-positive bacteria. Primer extensions from both E. coli and C. acetobutylicum strains containing the engB gene showed multiple transcription initiation sites, none of which corresponded to the site determined in C. cellulovorans. We conclude that transcriptional control of the engB gene is less stringent in heterologous backgrounds and postulate that expression of the engB gene in C. cellulovorans is increased in the presence of cellulose.

Separation of outer and cytoplasmic membranes of Fibrobacter succinogenes and membrane and glycogen granule locations of glycanases and cellobiase

The outer membrane (OM) of Fibrobacter succinogenes was isolated by a combination of salt, sucrose, and water washes from whole cells grown on either glucose or cellulose. The cytoplasmic membrane (CM) was isolated from OM-depleted cells after disruption with a French press. The OM and membrane vesicles isolated from the extracellular culture fluid of cellulose-grown cells had a higher density, much lower succinate dehydrogenase activity, and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis protein profiles different from those of the CM. The OM from both glucose- and cellulose-grown cells and the extracellular membrane vesicles from cellulose-grown cultures exhibited higher endoglucanase, xylanase, and acetylesterase activities than the CM and other cell fractions. Endoglucanase 2 was absent from the isolated OM fractions of glucose- and cellulose-grown cells and from the extracellular membrane vesicles of cellulose-grown cells but was present in the CM and intracellular glycogen granule fractions, while endoglucanase 3 was enriched in the OM. Cellobiosidase was located primarily in the periplasm as previously reported, while cellobiase was mainly present in the glycogen granule fraction of glucose-grown cells and in a nongranular glycogen and CM complex in cellulose-grown cells. The cellobiase was not eluted from glycogen granules by cellobiose, maltose, and maltotriose nor from either the granules or the cell membranes by nondenaturing detergents but was eluted from both glycogen granules and cell membranes by high concentrations of salts. The eluted cellobiase rebound almost quantitatively when diluted and mixed with purified glycogen granules but exhibited a low affinity for Avicel cellulose. Thus, we have documented a method for isolation of OM from F. succinogenes, identified the OM origin of the extracellular membrane vesicles, and located glycanases and cellobiase in membrane and glycogen fractions.

Effects of cellobiose on cellulose colonization by a mesophilic, cellulolytic Clostridium (strain C401)

When cultured on a mixture of cellobiose and cellulose, Clostridium C401 did not initially attach to cellulose but remained in the liquid phase. After cellobiose exhaustion, bacterial cells grew in association with the insoluble cellulose. Carboxymethylcellulase (CMCase) production on Avicel cellulose was four- to fivefold greater than on cellobiose, and cellulose-grown cells adhered to filter paper with an initial adhesion rate about four- to fivefold greater than did cellobiose-grown cells. Using tritiated thymidine incorporation as a measure of growth, it appeared that transfer of strain C401 from cellobiose to cellulose required an adaptation phase. An extracellular cellulase complex was isolated by affinity chromatography. This enzyme system is a multicomponent aggregate (molecular mass above 5 MDa), and yielded two major polypeptide bands by SDS-PAGE having molecular masses of 130 and 70 kDa. Cellobiose strongly inhibited Avicelase activity and slightly inhibited p-nitrophenylcellobiose hydrolysis (pNPCbase), but had no effect on the CMCase activity of the cellulase complex. In addition, polyclonal antibodies, raised against the purified 130 kDa protein inhibited Avicelase activity, but not CMCase and pNPCbase activities.

α-Glucuronidase and Other Hemicellulase Activities of Fibrobacter succinogenes S85 Grown on Crystalline Cellulose or Ball-Milled Barley Straw

Fibrobacter succinogenes produces an alpha-glucuronidase which cleaves 4-O-methyl-alpha-d-glucuronic acid from birch wood 4-O-methyl-alpha-d-glucuronoxylan. Very low levels of alpha-glucuronidase activity were detected in extracellular enzyme preparations of F. succinogenes on birch wood xylan substrate. The release of 4-O-methyl-alpha-d-glucuronic acid was enhanced when the birch wood xylan substrate was predigested by either a purified Schizophyllum commune xylanase or a cloned F. succinogenes S85 xylanase. These data suggest that the alpha-glucuronidase is unable to cleave 4-O-methyl-alpha-d-glucuronic acid from intact xylan but can act on unique low-molecular-weight glucuronoxylan fragments created by the cloned F. succinogenes xylanase. The cloned xylanase presumably must account for a small proportion of the indigenous xylanase activity of F. succinogenes cultures, since this xylanase source does not support high glucuronidase activity. The alpha-glucuronidase and associated hemicellulolytic enzymes exhibited higher activities in culture fluid from cells grown on ball-milled barley straw than in that of cellulose-grown cells. The profile of xylanases separated by isoelectric focusing (zymogram) of culture filtrate from cells grown on barley straw was more complex than that of culture filtrates from cells grown on cellulose. These data demonstrate that F. succinogenes produces an alpha-glucuronidase with an exacting substrate specificity which enables extensive cleavage of glucuronic acid residues from xylan as a consequence of synergistic xylanase action.

Cellulosome-like entities inBacteroides cellulosolvens

Cellulosome-like complexes were identified in the broth and sonic extracts of cellobiose-and cellulose-grown cells ofBacteroides cellulosolvens. The extracellular fractions contained three to four major polypeptides and several minor polypeptide bands that were localized in two major gel filtration peaks indicating average molecular weights of about 700 kDa and >10 MDa. A relatively large molecular weight component (Mr 230 kDa) was found to contain carbohydrate, but no apparent enzymatic activity of its own could be detected. The cell sonicate displayed a more complicated polypeptide profile, and glycosylated polypeptides were larger (ca. 310 and 290 kDa) than that of the extracellular fraction. The 230-kDa extracellular component interacted strongly with the GSI isolectin fromGriffonia simplicifolia, exhibited immunochemical cross-reactivity with the S1 subunit of the cellulosome fromClostridium thermocellum, and displayed anomalous pH- and salt-dependent migratory behavior in SDS-PAGE. Taken together, this evidence strongly suggests a structural similarity between the glycoconjugates of these two distinct cellulolytic bacteria. A major 84-kDa polypeptide was identified as a xylanase, and a 50-kDa polypeptide displayed endoglucanase activity. Additional biochemical and cytochemical evidence indicated that cellulosome-like cellulolytic complexes are associated with the cell surface in this bacterium.

Physiological properties of Cellulomonas fermentans, a mesophilic cellulolytic bacterium

The fermentation of cellobiose, glucose and cellulose MN 300 by Cellulomonas fermentans was studied. The molar growth yields (i.e. grams of cells per mole of hexose equivalent) were similar on cellobiose and cellulose at low sugar consumption levels (47.8 and 46.5 respectively), but was lower on glucose (38.0). The occurrence of cellobiose phosphorylase activity, detected in cellobiose- and cellulose-grown cells, might explain this result. The specific growth rates measured in cultures on cellobiose, glucose and cellulose were 0.055 h-1, 0.040 h-1 and 0.013 h-1 respectively. Growth inhibition was observed, and a drop in YH occurred after relatively low but different quantities of hexose were consumed (2.2 mM, 5 mM and 8 mM hexose equivalent with cellulose, glucose and cellobiose respectively), which coincided with a change in the fermentative metabolism from a typical mixed acid metabolism (1 ethanol, 1 acetate and 2 formate synthesized by consumed hexose) to a more ethanolic fermentation. When growth ceased in cellulose cultures, consumption of cellulose continued, as did production of ethanol.

Cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase in Thermomonospora curvata.

Cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase (PDE; EC 3.1.4.17) in Thermomonospora curvata was purified and characterized. Fractionation of cell extracts by ion-exchange and size-exclusion chromatography revealed four PDE isozymes, which differed markedly in molecular weight, theophylline sensitivity, pH optima, and substrate affinity. Although the enzyme was labile after purification, total recovery of PDE activity was fivefold that of the crude extract. PDE biosynthesis appeared sensitive to the growth phase, growth rate, and carbon source. PDE levels in batch cultures peaked and declined rapidly during mid-exponential-phase growth. In continuous culture, maximal PDE and cellulase production occurred at dilution rates yielding mean cell generation times of about 5 and 17 h, respectively. The addition of glucose to cellulose-grown cells caused declines in both cyclic AMP and PDE levels, suggesting that the enzyme was subject to, rather than the agent of, catabolite repression.

Regulation, initiation, and termination of the cenA and cex transcripts of Cellulomonas fimi.

We characterized the in vivo transcripts of two Cellulomonas fimi genes, the cenA gene, which encodes an extracellular endo-beta-1,4-glucanase (EC 3.2.1.4) and the cex gene, which encodes an extracellular exo-beta-1,4-glucanase (EC 3.2.1.91). By Northern blot analysis, cenA mRNA was detected in C. fimi RNA preparations from glycerol- and carboxymethyl cellulose-grown cells but not from glucose-grown cells. In contrast, cex mRNA was detected only in the preparations from carboxymethyl cellulose-grown cells. Therefore, the transcription of these genes is subject to regulation by the carbon source provided to C. fimi. By nuclease S1 protection studies with unique 5'-labeled DNA probes and C. fimi RNA isolated in vivo, 5' termini were found 51 and 62 bases before the cenA translational initiation codon and 28 bases before the cex translational initiation codon. S1 mapping with unlabeled DNA probes and C. fimi RNA which had been isolated in vivo but which had been 5' labeled in vitro with guanylyltransferase and [alpha-32P]GTP confirmed that true transcription initiation sites for cenA and cex mRNA had been identified. Comparative analysis of the DNA sequences immediately upstream of the initiation sites of the cenA and cex mRNAs revealed a 30-base-pair region where these two sequences display at least 66% homology. S1 mapping was also used to locate the 3' termini of the cenA and cex transcripts. Three 3' termini were found for cenA messages, whereas only one 3' terminus was identified for cex mRNA. The transcripts of both genes terminate in regions where their corresponding DNA sequences contain inverted repeats.